Friday, May 6, 2016

Blog 6: Reflections



Last week (April 28th) was my final week with at my internship site. I did the exit and evaluation interview which was shorter than I expected. I guess it was because my other supervisor was not at work that day. The interview was basically about my experience at the commission and whether I would recommend other students to work for them (that kind of questions). It was roughly 10 minutes. I summarized the work I did from January until April, what I enjoyed most and what I least enjoyed. I also had to tell my supervisor what I learned in the four months I have been with them. He expressed his gratitude on how the final research project I was working on will be of great help for the commission and thanked me for helping them. I had a list of questions I prepared prior the exit interview. Questions that I have been raising throughout my blog posts, that I had no answers to and still do not have answers even now. I had hoped I would talk to them about my questions, but that did not happen. 

In this last post I just want to reflect on my experiences with my internship; why I chose it, what I learned from them, the questions that I am still left with.  When I was looking for an internship I wanted to work with an organization that is different from what I am familiar with (community outreach and organizing). I wanted something new that would challenge me and possibly learn a new skill. So, when I started with San Francisco Human Rights Commission I went in there with so many thoughts and biased ideas of what government agencies do.  My initial thought was comparing how grassroots organizations are different from government agencies who also are for social justice.  I was thinking, what are the differences and what are the implications? How is the funding handled and who’s agency is represented? I also went in with my assumption of the state as “tyrannical and oppressive” and need to be deconstructed and destabilized. I wanted to experience it first-hand that indeed the state is just about its own interests and not about people. Looking at contexts such as, how do the state measure equality and human rights from a position of “power”? Also, the programs they implement, are they what the community need, and what really is the relationship between the state and the community.

What I wanted to learn.
I wanted to familiarize myself with policy work and have a better understanding how government policies are implemented, by who and why?  I was curious (and still am) to know who the policymakers have in mind when crafting policies. I further wanted to figure out if theory can translate into practice…if what I learned in my WGS classes can be applied to my internship site. 

What I did.
I attended external events such as forums and stakeholders’ meetings, which gave me more insight to what the HRC does outside the office. I reviewed different policies to offer recommendations on how they can be reviewed or better implemented. I worked on the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing Report. I looked also at the Sanctuary City Ordinance suggested revisions by city legislators, both these policies have a significant impact on marginalized groups and women of color.  I worked also on a huge research project on transgender housing in prisons. This policy is a call by a coalition of grassroots organizations who work with transgender communities and the Sherriff department. I looked at five cities across the US that have trans prisoners’ inclusive policies to see how these policies were implemented and what were their shortcomings.  

What I learned.
HRC is a government agency, therefore, it is a huge part of the NPIC and furthering neoliberal ideologies. Even so, the HRC works with both other government agencies and nonprofit organizations. What stood out for me was the realization that they collaborate with both state and non-state agencies. Collaborations are essential, yes they are messy but essential. While working on the transgender housing research, I noticed how different NGOs with diverse demands but with a common goal work together to protect transgender people’s rights. So despite differences, collaborations can be instrumental. One of my recommendations to them on the transgender prisoners report was they (HRC), when implementing new policies or revising old ones, should always take into account communities voices and other stakeholders. It should center the community because often, justice means different things to different people. Often communities (what I realized from the forums I attended) do not want more properly structured, beautiful policies, they want immediate action, and sometimes they want the policies as that “promise” that they are legally protected.

Questions I am still left with.
After noticing the huge disconnect between the community and law enforcement…e.g. the wigger party (my second blog). I am still left wondering what laws and policies can be placed to deal with historical / colonial legacies such as racism? Also with the forums: the SFPD/Youth forum and the Noble forum: they have been ongoing and yet there seems to be no change in as far as the relationship with law enforcement and the community is concerned. How does that HRC offer recommendations to the Police Commissioner from these forums? And also, how does the SFPD and HRC measure whether these forums have a positive impact? I am still not sure how I feel overall about my time with the commission, otherwise, it was an okay experience.

3 comments:

  1. Hi Sam, thank you for your thoughtful reflection. Like you, I'm also wondering how policies can address the legacy of racism, especially in how it pertains to the relationship between communities and law enforcement. From you blogs throughout this semester, it seems like HRC focussed most of its efforts on organizing "police trainings" and community interactions between law enforcement and communities. While I recognize that this is a start, this effort is based on the idea that specific people as opposed to the whole police institution is racist. There has to be a reason why after all this se trainings SFPD is still dealing with things like the recent racist texts issue. Is this really about errant racist police officers or about a punitive system that is rooted in a systematic criminalization of poor people of color. I wonder if HRC's approach to this problem would have been different if it was not a state agency. Would it recommend solutions beyond police trainings?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Sam, thank you for your thoughtful reflection. Like you, I'm also wondering how policies can address the legacy of racism, especially in how it pertains to the relationship between communities and law enforcement. From you blogs throughout this semester, it seems like HRC focussed most of its efforts on organizing "police trainings" and community interactions between law enforcement and communities. While I recognize that this is a start, this effort is based on the idea that specific people as opposed to the whole police institution is racist. There has to be a reason why after all this se trainings SFPD is still dealing with things like the recent racist texts issue. Is this really about errant racist police officers or about a punitive system that is rooted in a systematic criminalization of poor people of color. I wonder if HRC's approach to this problem would have been different if it was not a state agency. Would it recommend solutions beyond police trainings?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sam - This is a wonderfully comprehensive and thoughtful final blog post. I'm sorry that you didn't get to have a dialogue with your ongoing supervisor about some of these questions; I hope there some sort of opportunities for continued dialogue. Your critical engagement with core issues is inspiring, and I strongly feel that you will be part of the solution in the organizations with which you work.

    ReplyDelete