Friday, March 25, 2016

Activism as Survival (and Work)

During our last class, we were asked to research the budget of our respective organizations. I found out that the TGI Justice Project has a very small budget and that only four people in the entire organization are on their payroll. This completely shocked me because so many people visit the TGIJP offices frequently to help and play key roles in our collective. Although I am shocked and saddened that so many people do not receive direct compensation for the important work they do for TGIJP, it also makes me extremely grateful to be interning at a site that attracts so many passionate and committed people.
I am not only impressed by the fact that so many people contribute their time and energy without receiving pay, but I am also impressed that the few people who do receive direct compensation work much more than what their salary takes into account. The four staff members are at every single event, every single action, and still try and make time to lend a helping hand to other organizations in need. This reminds me of the Bojar piece, which describes the gendered politics of volunteer work and how oftentimes women do so much more work than they are paid to do. 
Additionally, the fact that so many staff members and volunteers contribute such an intense amount of time to their cause makes it obvious how urgent this cause is. It is not merely something they volunteer for, but it is an issue they must address and advocate an end to (in this case gendered violence) because they feel the violence on an daily basis. I am not saying this is a reason why activists that fight for causes should be okay with being paid less, but rather it serves as a reason for me to understand why anyone would work in such intense conditions. 

Friday, March 18, 2016

Blog #3 Akiko Yamada

Hi, I want to write about my experience of making power point slides at Asian Women's Resource Center. I've made a power point presentation for staff members (especially for my supervisor) to introduce the organization to others.

My supervisor asked me to make power point slides including the history of organization, our programs/ services, etc. I've used power points before, but it made me scared or I didn't have enough confidence to present the organization because I was only there for two months at that time. I felt like I wasn't the person to make it. (it was like the syndrome of "female college students not having enough confidence to be in class" which professor. Martha Kenney told us on March 4th.)
I had some feedback, and had to revise some parts of the slides, but it was a great opportunity to learn the history, programs, and services of the organization. I feel like I can present what they do now.

Right now, I'm kind of struggling to change my mind of "working too much." I feel like I have "Mother Teresa Syndrome" that Karen Bojar writes in "Volunteerism and Women's Lives" although I haven't worked as hard as teachers and social workers Bojar mentions. I've completed more than 60 hours of work study at the organization. I'm working until the end of April because I have a project of planning the schedule of field trips in summer school. I know this is my problem, but I feel so guilty to ask my supervisor if I can get a day off somewhere by the end of April, or shorten my working hours (although I constantly have the thought of "not wanting to work").

I'm curious what you guys think.
How do you deal with this kind of thought?

Post #3

Hello, everyone! These last two weeks have been mostly great, but not perfect. I have started building good relationships with a lot of the students at my assigned school. Some of them run up to me and give me hugs or high-fives when I walk into the cafeteria at the start of each day’s session. I can already tell it’s going to be hard to say goodbye at the end of the semester. I find myself constantly impressed with these kids and their knowledge and understanding of things I didn’t (or couldn’t) comprehend when I was 9 years old! For example, I was helping someone with their homework last week and somehow the conversation between the other kids at my table turned to politics. They started talking about how much they hated Donald Trump because of his racism, sexism, and classism! They actually used words like “racist” and “sexist” and it was great! They knew about how he wants to build a wall and make Mexico pay for it. They knew about how he has talked about women. I was completely shocked at their knowledge about such things. But the more I thought about it, the more it made sense that they would know. This school’s population is mostly lower class people of color, so their parents have probably told them all about Trump because it would affect them differently than it would have affected me when I was 9. The kids asked me what I thought about him, but I told them that I didn’t think it would be appropriate for me to talk about my political views in a school setting, which is unfortunate because I would love to be able to let them know that I, as a white man, am on their side.


Speaking of being a white man, I have begun to wonder how the kids feel about me being an authority figure to them. Not so much the kids that hug and high-five me, but there are other kids that don’t always do what I ask them to do, or they swear at me (when they do that, I have to tell on them, which makes them dislike me even more). This is a program that has a focus on the advancement of people of color and I understand the problematic nature of having a white person being somewhat in charge of them. They’ve already shown me that they have a good understanding of racism, and like I said last time, there are Black Live Matter and other kinds of race empowering posters all around the school.

Blog post #3 : Crisis Support Services/ frustration!

Hey everyone,
          A few weeks ago I interviewed a few of the counselors to see what they thought should be included in the training I'm helping with and they gave me some really helpful incite and ideas. They both felt as though there should be an inclusion of personal experience in the presentation to help engage those who attend the training. I agree with them and do think it would be helpful to have someone with lived experience talk and so I expressed this with my supervisor. Although she said she liked the idea she kind of dismissed it this past week when we checked in about the training and our next goals. She told me that the training were doing is more of a general training and will be a lot shorter. We hadn't previously talked about the length of the training and I was disappointed and a little frustrated that we aren't listening to what the counselors are saying they need in a training around creating a safe space for LGBT callers and texters. We also created a survey for all the counselors of CSS to check in about what they know and what they want to know. As of now it feels as though my supervisor is wanting to create something short and is going to have others present it. A part of me is questioning what I'm even doing there if she's not wanting to go more in depth.
          Not only that, but I don't like the idea of having my name attached to a training that isn't something I completely agree with. She listens to a lot I have to say, but I don't fully feel as though she's on the same page as me. It's kind of difficult to work with a cisgendered straight woman on a training surrounding LGBT safety, as a bisexual woman. I feel as though personal experience is vital in the training, as do other LGBT members of the CSS community, yet my supervisor won't include it. Apparently, there are organizations that come in at times to do similar trainings, but we have heard they are boring and not engaging.
Is it a financial issue to make it shorter/not include lived experience? (more likely)
Does my supervisor not agree with or trust my knowledge of the topic? (less likely/ me getting in my head about it)
Also, if it's going to be a shorter presentation and training, what do we include and what do we leave out? Bleh..
All of this is making me think of hierarchy in organizations and internships/community service learning. As well as privilege in these environments and interactions.

Space matters

March 18 2016

This week I have been able to get some more insight on the dynamics of the organization I am interning in. The organization houses 6 different programs that range from the direct legal services that my program does, to education and advocacy for tenants rights in the mission. The building is two stories, relatively small, and with nine separate offices that are shared between two to four people. The offices are split between two floors, the downstairs offices are occupied by the shelter managers, la colectiva de mujeres, mission SRO collaborative, and the day laborer program, while the upstairs offices belong to the director of the organization, the accountant, and both legal programs. When I first started, someone in my program had made a joke about how the tenants rights staff never invited our program out because they referred to us as “upstairs people” I realized that I had also previously heard some on the staff call us “lawyer” people in casual conversation which I did not think twice of at all. On moving day, two of the “downstairs” programs moved offices with the accountant, and while doing so they jokingly said, “look we are upstairs people now”. Seemingly benign comments are signs of an otherwise unspoken hierarchy that can be manifested in space. While the space that legal programs occupy is not much larger than those of the offices downstairs, there is overall understanding that being above is good or “better”. The politics of space can encompass simple things as arrangement of offices, and who gets to occupy them is then understood in terms of their value to the organization or their credentials. I had not given such ideas much thought until I began thinking about the different types of services that are provided by this non profit. The programs downstairs are primarily mobilizers, they are organizers, activists, and mostly members of the same communities they target. They hold weekly educational workshops as well as coalition meetings in the shared “vvc” space downstairs. While attorneys from the deportation defense program are very much active advocates of the communities they serve, they are primarily concerned with the individuals they are able to represent.


From the interactions I have had with other members of my program as well as other staff, I have started to understand how the activities of each program shape such program’s overall “place” in the organization. While the activists work is very much necessary and valuable, it is viewed as a more radical form of service than that of the attorneys. It is also important to note the distinction between the individuals that are part of the activist work in contrast to the legal service team. While this may not be the case for all attorneys, the attorneys of my program all come from a middle class, upper middle class background; they are either white or second and third generation children of immigrants while their target community is very low income, undocumented folks. All of the “downstairs” programs are staffed by previously homeless individuals and members of the same communities they organize. Bickford and Reynolds make a similar distinction between service learning and activist work, “It is fruitful at this point to consider the connections between activism and service-learning based on relationships. In most situations, relationships are clearly based on difference: I’m homeless; you’re not. Activism argues for relationships based on connection.” (237) I believe it is important to acknowledge these differences and the racial and class implications involved. Rather than understanding the programs as opposites and completely separate from the other, I think that they should be understood as complementary. While the attorneys hold a position that allows them to produce some change, it is limited by the underlying system that creates the “illegal” and deportable subject in the first place. Mobilizing and pressure from activist is what forces legislators to reevaluate their policies, allowing for the gradual change of the system, not just of the individual applicant. 

Blog #3



For the past week, I have been feeling useless and getting bored with just going to my internship site and only doing research. I am not saying the project I am working on is irrelevant but it can be discouraging to be stationary and sit in one place and do the same thing over and over again. It is rather isolating, too. I knew when I accepted this internship that it would be a different experience altogether because of the nature of the work that the HRC does, which is research and policy analysis and not have much direct contact with the community. I wanted to get a sense of how the state does reach the decision that a certain policy should be implemented and who is involved in making sure that the policy is correctly implemented, and whether it is what the community needs. However, when I went in this week, I was so excited to know that we would be attending a conference in Oakland.
My supervisor and I went to Oakland to attend The Noble Forum on 21st Century Policing. It was a dialogue, and had four different panelists: the Community Advocates panel which included NGOs and Civil Right lawyers, the Chief of Police panel which included chief officers from San Francisco, Oakland, Highway Patrol and Bart Police, the Policy Oversite panel which included the Oakland Citizen’s Police Board, San Jose Independent Police Auditor and the San Francisco Director of the Office of Citizen Complaints, and finally the 21st Century Pillar panel which included professors, police captains, and psychologists. There are three panels that stood out for me which raised concerns and further complicated this fractured relationship between law enforcement and the community. The Community Advocate panel which was comprised of community leaders and advocacy groups expressed their grievances, and exposed the disconnect between the community and law enforcement and how it is affecting them on a daily basis. Second, the Chief of Police panel was tackling the challenges they are facing applying the 21st century recommendations in their respective counties through rigorous different trainings of police officers. My question after they presented was how can we safely say that police officers are applying this training when they go to communities? How do we know these trainings are effective where people are still protesting against law enforcement misconduct? And of course people will continue to complain because policies that are meant to protect them are failing them. Then lastly, the Policy Oversite panel discussed how to access community rights and how they are of service to the communities. One of their missions, mentioned by the panelists was that they investigate community complaints/ grievances and provide policy recommendations to the Police Commissioners. They continued to stress that police officers who are violating laws and policies should be held accountable. So the question is, if the group is not able to hold the police officers accountable then how can communities hold them accountable?

The goal of this forum was to discuss ways of building community and law enforcement relationships using the 21st-century policy recommendations set forth by the Department of Justice. In the audience were community members, students, police officers, other government agency representatives, faith-based organization representatives, and professors. The Human Rights Commission had to attend because as a government agency, we were there to critique, observe and see how this strained relationship between these different counties communities and law enforcement can be revived. Some of the outreach programs between San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) and surrounding communities are initiated by HRC. So we were at the forum also to evaluate what can be done better to improve these programs. We were also there to see whether these counties were indeed complying with the 21st-century recommendations, and more than anything else, we were there to listen to communities’ grievances and how to better assist.

The main themes that I took out of the forum was that police do not trust black and brown people, and black and brown people do not trust the police. The question that kept coming up was what kind of policies can be put in place to bridge this trust issue? What system/policy can be put into action to acknowledge historical legacies of segregation, oppression, and racial inequalities? There need to be policies that actually deal with deep rooted systematic issues. On the other hand, communities do not necessarily want more policies; they want accountability, they want transparency, they want their voices to heard, to be treated with respect and dignity, and more than anything else, to feel safe! Policies that are ambiguous, for example; police officer’s ability to use force when they feel they are in imminent danger, allows them to justify shooting somebody when they could have defused the situation in another way. How scared can a police officer be that he can shoot an unarmed (possibly with mental health issues) person 28 times? I was just left wondering why it is so difficult for police departments to reform themselves despite trainings, protests, and community engagement? Why is it so hard? Why is it so hard to bridge this gap between community and law enforcement? This disconnect between law enforcement and the community makes me think of the limitations of praxis, and questioning whether we can take what we learn in the classroom and apply it to our daily life. If the police are trained a certain way to respond to mentally ill people, if they are trained when and how to use force, and are trained to be conscious and be respectful and treat community members with dignity, why is police brutality still so prevalent?