After finding out Janetta had been named grand marshal, I discussed the decision with Woods, another member of TGIJP. They told me about how they also saw this as a move of “inclusion.” One that relies on the idea that simply folding bodies into an organization with a pre-existing structure will suffice. This contrasts the politics articulated by Spade and Bierra in which people are centered, not just included. We both agreed that Pride does not do anything for the most vulnerable members of the QTPOC community. Therefore, we felt a little uneasy for our participation in the festival.
However, Woods told me that a few years ago Pride invited Miss Major, the previous executive director of TGIJP, to be grand marshal. Woods recalled this experience with fondness. They told me that despite the understanding that Pride was not an organization they aspired to be like, they were also happy to have the chance to get together as an organization. Being able to march on the streets, with shirts that read #blacktranslivesmatter, felt validating and helped build rapport within the organization.
Woods helped me see that despite Pride’s own politics, that TGIJP was able to use the event to still gain something. It might not be the most radical thing in the world, but it helped me see that not all decisions can be reduced to “good” or “bad.” Rather, we all work within capitalism and other processes that force us to do the best we can.
Hi chris, thank you for this blog. I just want to say that I have felt for awhile now, that pride is no longer what it use to be. I especially felt this when I lived in LA and I was at pride there. It hit me that it was all about capitalism. I also felt that pride lost its original intentions, it became about partying and getting so wasted people could hardly walk. I found it very disturbing, because pride was and is about sharing a message with a community. On that note, I also feel that pride does exclude a huge space for the trans community. i sure hope it changes one day.
ReplyDeleteChris,
ReplyDeleteYou did a good job explaining how I feel about Pride. I've been really uneasy about it for a few years because I've never felt even a little represented as a queer Xicana, and that's honestly why I haven't participated in any Pride events. But reading your post made me realize that if I keep avoiding Pride it will just continue centering around only certain groups in the LGBTQ community. Because like Woods said, being involved in something like Pride can feel validating for some people, and I'm sure there's a part of me that wants that validation too. I've also started to realize recently (thanks in part to this class) that the binary of "good" vs "bad" is not so easy to distinguish, and I think you describe the difficulty of making those distinguishes really well. Maybe I'll try to find a Pride event I can get behind this year because if there's one thing I've learned through WGS is that binaries are always better when you deconstruct them. Thanks for the great post!