Since the first week, I’ve come to realize I feel a little inadequate. Is anyone else feeling similarly? I feel that the skills I have to offer don’t really translate over. For example, I’ve gained skills in rape crisis counseling and organizing activities or creating websites, but I haven’t found these skills to be necessarily beneficial for Hand in Hand’s mission. As a result, I feel that I’m doing busy work that yes, allows me to learn more about the organization itself but simultaneously restricts my capacity to be an effective agent to their cause. Does that make sense at all?
Despite my insecurities, I am learning more about how non-profits function and the struggles that come with passing legislation. I think the concept of “ally” has troubled me a bit. In the same way that Millenials believe that re-posting a recycled “feminist” picture on Facebook makes them a “feminist,” I’ve noticed that many of those who identify as “allies” to the organization think that the identification alone is sufficient support. Even though they say they are allies, many refuse to actually be active about their supposed support, like attending the campaign rallies, going to workshops to learn more about the many facets of the organization—or, at the least, listing themselves publicly as supporters to the cause in order to push legislation. I think in order to render oneself an ally, there should be a requirement of active support. But it seems that simply identifying as an “ally” is sufficient support to many, and perhaps it gives good “feels” because they allegedly believe in the mission of the organization.
As I wrote that second paragraph, I realized how ableist I sounded, as many of those that are allies are actually differently-abled seniors. I’m going to keep that paragraph there as a reminder for me to check myself, especially in my conceptualization of “active support.” What constitutes as “active” considering physical restrictions? It actually makes me think about ways in which I can assist with digitizing the workshops for those who can’t physically make it out to the offices, or something to that effect for other ways to get involved. Friday will be the organization’s campaign launch, and perhaps I can propose to do more things surrounding digitization and taking advantage of the ever-growing power of social media coverage.
Thanks for taking part in my stream of consciousness and self-realizations. I hope to continue learning...your thoughts and opinions are appreciated.
Added edit: I've realized, after putting more analysis into the assigned readings, that my experience has to do with direct service versus activism, as differentiated by Bickford and Reynolds. I suppose this is what has made me uncomfortable: my inexperience with being able to lead my own workshops, for example, regarding how to be effective activists when dismantling certain attitudes of domestic work and lobbying for adequate recognition. I guess this discomfort and fear of the unknown is what drew me to this particular internship in the first place. I can already feel my insecurities lifting a bit, cheers! to uncomfortable realizations.
Monday, February 29, 2016
Saturday, February 27, 2016
Blog entry #2
I've really been enjoying my internship at Dress For Success so far. I've learned a lot my past few weeks there, and have had my fair share of small injuries like dropping a laptop on me, and I'm still recovering from that one. I've gotten to know the organization pretty well, and have done multiple things that both interest me and is fulfilling. My first couple of weeks there, I got to know the back room pretty well, My tasks included organizing the clothes, sorting through the inventory and donations, and cleaning up the dressing area. The organization also holds weekly donation drives so sometimes when there are a shortage of volunteers, I go down to the street and pick up the donations, give the tax receipts out, and take everything back up to the office suite. It does get pretty hectic at times, a lot of donations can come through at one time or multiple clients may be there at one time, it varies a lot. Sometimes, clients don't show up at all and miss their opportunity for a free outfit that could really help them while they are actively seeking work.
Reagon's piece about coalition politics is very relatable as I'm going through this internship. She says, "It must become necessary for all of us to feel that this is our world," (365). This makes me think of my time at Dress for Success so far; I've had two clients that I've had to "personal shop" for. A personal shopper is usually a volunteer, and their duty is to pick the outfits for the clients to try on, as well as the shoes, accessories and purse. Both of the clients I had said "I feel like a million bucks!" after their appointment, and it was such an overwhelming feeling of happiness I felt to see such happiness in these women. No matter what circumstances we are under, there is always a silver lining somewhere, and it felt so great to have been able to make someone feel like a million bucks. That's the thought I had as I read Reagon's article. It's not fulfillment that should define coalition work, but the awareness, the consciousness, the knowing that THIS is worthwhile to individuals lives because we all belong here, and we all deserve the opportunity to make our world as big as we can.
After reading Bickford and Reynolds article Activism and Learning: Volunteerism as Acts of Dissent, their take on students writing journal entries and reflecting about their experiences does make one
question deeper as to Why are we doing this? The opportunity to expand our critical consciousness
and contribute to social change are more than just the experiences, but reflecting on those experiences. A part that stuck out to me in their essay, was their focus on the goals of consciousness raising (CR), saying, "CR's goals extended beyond shared experiences; its force lay in uncovering and analyzing structures of oppression so that effective action for change could occur," (240). Crucial change doesn't happen over night, and as the authors also say, "activism is a process". It is imperative to analyze EVERYTHING around why activism is so vital. How boundaries, and politics of space play a part; who is in control and who is being controlled? Questions answered, raising consciousness and creating social change.
Reagon's piece about coalition politics is very relatable as I'm going through this internship. She says, "It must become necessary for all of us to feel that this is our world," (365). This makes me think of my time at Dress for Success so far; I've had two clients that I've had to "personal shop" for. A personal shopper is usually a volunteer, and their duty is to pick the outfits for the clients to try on, as well as the shoes, accessories and purse. Both of the clients I had said "I feel like a million bucks!" after their appointment, and it was such an overwhelming feeling of happiness I felt to see such happiness in these women. No matter what circumstances we are under, there is always a silver lining somewhere, and it felt so great to have been able to make someone feel like a million bucks. That's the thought I had as I read Reagon's article. It's not fulfillment that should define coalition work, but the awareness, the consciousness, the knowing that THIS is worthwhile to individuals lives because we all belong here, and we all deserve the opportunity to make our world as big as we can.
After reading Bickford and Reynolds article Activism and Learning: Volunteerism as Acts of Dissent, their take on students writing journal entries and reflecting about their experiences does make one
question deeper as to Why are we doing this? The opportunity to expand our critical consciousness
and contribute to social change are more than just the experiences, but reflecting on those experiences. A part that stuck out to me in their essay, was their focus on the goals of consciousness raising (CR), saying, "CR's goals extended beyond shared experiences; its force lay in uncovering and analyzing structures of oppression so that effective action for change could occur," (240). Crucial change doesn't happen over night, and as the authors also say, "activism is a process". It is imperative to analyze EVERYTHING around why activism is so vital. How boundaries, and politics of space play a part; who is in control and who is being controlled? Questions answered, raising consciousness and creating social change.
Friday, February 26, 2016
Between negotiation and resistance- a vision of women's agency
Over the past few weeks I got more deeply involved in the
work that Women and Girls Lead Global (WGLG) is doing. I edited and re-wrote a
number of blogs about the activities of their community engagement partners in
Bangladesh and Jordan. I finally had the opportunity of watching one of the
films they’ve been using in their community screenings, mostly because I was
proofreading the discussion guide for that film. Discussion guides are an
important part of the film-based curriculum for community engagement that WGLG
uses. They are developed in conversation with their local partners and I was
surprised at the vision of agency one of them proposes. The discussion guide in
question was for a documentary about girls’ education in Casablanca, where the
state has trained women to work as Morchidat (official Islamic
spiritual guides). Their mandate is to offer guidance around living an
“ethical” and compassionate life while supporting the state’s efforts to
encourage girl’s education and tackling domestic violence. The Morchidat
seem to draw their credibility not just from their official training but from
their gendered position, as motherly advisers, or as women who seem to have
some special access to spirituality and compassion by virtue of being women.
They seem to promote girl’s education, often in marginalized communities, while
working within the logic of gendered norms. For instance, they argue that
fathers should commit to educating their daughters because being caring by
nature (by virtue of being girls) they will continue to support their families
once they start working. The discussion guide recognizes this move as a
strategic decision and prompts the facilitator to ask the community audience in
Jordan about strategies they have used to convince their families about girl’s
education.
The film as well as the discussion
guide can be read as a reinforcement of problematic patriarchal norms. Where
girls should get educated because they will take care of their families,
because they are caring or nice etc. They can be critiqued for positioning the
Morchidat as empowered women “saving” girls while completely overlooking the
privileged class position they occupy. The discussion guide can be faulted for working
on an assumption that a film made in the context of Casablanca would
automatically be relevant to communities in Jordan because of a “religious” connection.
Even as I have many critiques about the film and the discussion guide I am
still interested in the complicated vision of women’s agency they offer, where
agential action is not always tied to explicit resistance, where it can mean a
negotiation with structures of power. In fact, agential action by women can emerge even in
the act of re-enforcing norms.
In the end, I am still trying to understand what it means for WGLG to support and screen a film that explicitly positions itself as tied to a "tolerant/compassionate" vision of Islam.Tolerant/compassionate in opposition to what? I wonder if WGLG would ever support a film critical of the impact of US foreign policy on women's lives across the world.
Age and Technology at TGIJP (Blog Post #2)
As I detailed in my first post, I felt that there were very little skills I would be able to offer the veteran activists and organizers at the TGI Justice Project. But these past two weeks have given me the opportunity to learn many new skills as well as share my own skills with the staff. Particularly, I am very involved in helping develop the technological skills of the team.
Although the tasks I complete while I am at TGIJP range, many of my tasks consist of computer work. I send outreach e-mails, enter information on our database, help update the website, upload pictures online, produce manuals, and edit/reformat many of the materials we prepare for trans women inside prisons. I focus on these tasks because according to Janetta, the executive director, I am one of the few activists on the team that began organizing when e-mailing and online work was necessary. Before, according to her, technology was important but not necessary. Now she feels that without advanced technological skills, it is extremely difficult for collectives to function. So, rather than purely completing these tasks for the organization, I write manuals/instructions on how to complete these tasks. I send these instructions to the rest of the organization so that in the future everyone could complete these tasks.
There is a certain ageist mentality among organizers that there should be a clear division between "new" activists and "old" activists. New activists complain about how old activists are not up-to-date or that they're from a different generation; old activists complain about how new activists do not have the experiences they do and are thus less equipped to handle activist work. My time so far at the TGI Justice Project has reflected a collaboration between "new" and "old" where knowledge continues to transfer from generation to generation. We all acknowledge that we hold different experiences and knowledge. But rather than see that as an irreparable disjuncture, we try our best to learn from one another. My experience thus far has helped me unlearn ideas of age that claim that "old" people are inherently ignorant or unable to learn as quickly. Rather, I'm walking away from this internship with an understanding that younger and older activists have many things to learn and give.
Although the tasks I complete while I am at TGIJP range, many of my tasks consist of computer work. I send outreach e-mails, enter information on our database, help update the website, upload pictures online, produce manuals, and edit/reformat many of the materials we prepare for trans women inside prisons. I focus on these tasks because according to Janetta, the executive director, I am one of the few activists on the team that began organizing when e-mailing and online work was necessary. Before, according to her, technology was important but not necessary. Now she feels that without advanced technological skills, it is extremely difficult for collectives to function. So, rather than purely completing these tasks for the organization, I write manuals/instructions on how to complete these tasks. I send these instructions to the rest of the organization so that in the future everyone could complete these tasks.
There is a certain ageist mentality among organizers that there should be a clear division between "new" activists and "old" activists. New activists complain about how old activists are not up-to-date or that they're from a different generation; old activists complain about how new activists do not have the experiences they do and are thus less equipped to handle activist work. My time so far at the TGI Justice Project has reflected a collaboration between "new" and "old" where knowledge continues to transfer from generation to generation. We all acknowledge that we hold different experiences and knowledge. But rather than see that as an irreparable disjuncture, we try our best to learn from one another. My experience thus far has helped me unlearn ideas of age that claim that "old" people are inherently ignorant or unable to learn as quickly. Rather, I'm walking away from this internship with an understanding that younger and older activists have many things to learn and give.
2nd Blog Entry
I would say that everything at my internship has gone pretty smoothy. My first day there was pretty exhausting. I began my day at 2pm and didn't end up leaving until 11:30pm. One of the first things that I was asked to do was go through the applications of youth who applied to the mentorship program at HOMEY. As I was going through the applications, I was asked to enter the information they included into a spreadsheet. This was difficult because a lot of the youth had important information that was missing from their applications. It was also difficult because a majority of the applications were in Spanish and I can't read or speak the language. I definitely feel a little bit guilty about being one of the only people there that doesn't read or speak Spanish. This language barrier made me think a lot about my experiences growing up. I still remember feeling like I wasn't White enough for White people and wasn't Mexican enough for Mexican people. I always struggled with feeling like I wasn't connected to my history or roots. I am happy that HOMEY really reinforces the importance of youth reclaiming their history and roots. I am hopeful that HOMEY will provide a healing space of transformation for both myself and the youth. I think that the process of reclaiming our history and roots is a never-ending process. We are constantly pushing back against a white supremacist society that says that our experiences, stories, and voices don't matter.
Moving forward, my initial encounter with the youth was interesting. I definitely felt like an intruder in a space where everyone knew each other and spoke the same language. I think that I will continue to feel this way until I build stronger relationships with the youth. I think that the youth are skeptical as to whether or not I will stick around and are interested in establishing a foundation of trust with me first. I don’t blame them! I think that it will be important for me to show consistency, compassion, and patience when working with the youth. I could definitely tell that the youth saw HOMEY as place of refuge and, more importantly, a place where they could let their guards down and be themselves. I could also tell that the staff and youth established a bond that resembled that of a family. It is clear that the staff look out for the youth and the youth look out for the staff. HOMEY is definitely a collaborative space that seeks to transform the lives of both staff and youth. I am excited to see where my journey with HOMEY takes me...
the world of volunteering
I am just writing my second blog in response to the some of the readings due for next week. I had never really thought about nor realized the ways that women have been so actively at the forefront of volunteering efforts. It is really interesting to see the ways women have impacted so many organizations with their unpaid work skills and knowledge. It was also interesting to read the connections of the mainstream feminist women's movement and religious organizations. In our culture women are just expected to "help out". In most of the families I know and friends I have the women are the ones who do the organizing and so many other things that are to take care of others. I really think that women are used to doing work and not getting acknowledge for it. I really like in the article "Volunteerism and Women's Lives" how the authors, Karen Bojar highlighted the differences between classes as well, acknowledging that low income women don't even consider much of the work they do as volunteer whereas middle-upper class women "are much more likely to participate in organized volunteering-and to get the recognition for it." (39)
What is troublesome to me and is a conversation I've had many times with other people is the fact that any job that is service related is paid very little. I can think of very few careers where people are doing work that is helpful and guided by service and justice and actually get paid a livable salary. I think we will see this as we begin to explore more of the organizations many of us are interning with. In reading this article I also can't help but think about the educational system and how many of us are in school to get jobs that will allow us to survive AND make a difference or have some kind of positive impact on the world. Will this be possible? Will we have to work in a field that allows us to make money so that we can live and volunteer time, skills, money to organizations that do not get acknowledged for the work they do?
What is troublesome to me and is a conversation I've had many times with other people is the fact that any job that is service related is paid very little. I can think of very few careers where people are doing work that is helpful and guided by service and justice and actually get paid a livable salary. I think we will see this as we begin to explore more of the organizations many of us are interning with. In reading this article I also can't help but think about the educational system and how many of us are in school to get jobs that will allow us to survive AND make a difference or have some kind of positive impact on the world. Will this be possible? Will we have to work in a field that allows us to make money so that we can live and volunteer time, skills, money to organizations that do not get acknowledged for the work they do?
Reflections on CCWP
My time at California Coalition for Women's Prisoners is going really well. I look forward to going every week. The office space is very small and quiet and because they share the space with LSPC-Legal Services for Prisoners with Children, the office is surrounded with buzz about "the system". It's similar to learning a new language. It's one thing to learn the letters and sounds, and memorize words, but being immersed in a language is when the true knowledge of a language begins. That's how I feel at CCWP. I've read and "learned" about the PIC for many years now but seeing it in action and being immersed in the environment is how true knowledge can be obtained about what is really going on.
Last week I began responding to prisoner mail. Most of the letters I respond to are just requests to receive CCWP's newsletter, called the Fire Inside. It publishes poetry, short stories, and artwork by women in prison and circulated throughout all California Prisons to anyone who requests free subscription. In the responses I write, I use a template letter, include a copy of The Fire Inside, and a self addressed envelope with stamp as to encourage continued correspondence. Even though I am only responding to simple general requests for the newsletter, I am able to open a lot of the incoming mail and sort through it, delivering it to other volunteers who have more of a personal correspondence with women inside or volunteers who respond to specific issues. The process of opening and reading the letters is very intimate. The idea of inside/outside is heightened even more, knowing that so many women have very few people they are able to correspond with on the "outside". I keep going back to the fact that so many women are in prison for defending themselves against abuse or merely trying to survive. How many people's lives are being thrown away for mistakes and circumstances out of their control?
I have been going to CCWP for about 6 hours a week and every time I leave I feel this sense of how little can be achieved in those 6 hours a week. I guess every little but does count, but the enormity of our prison systems and the amount of work that needs to be done to transform it is devastating.
This Saturday I am going to a 3 hour letter writing event that CCWP has once a month to gather people together specifically just to respond to incoming mail. I am looking forward to learning from people who have been doing this for years and get a sense of how they help, make connections, and continue correspondence with women inside.
Work Stress
The biggest
challenge I have been initially dealing with has been exhaustion and tension
after my 5 hours of interning for the day. I have had 5 intern days so far, and
I am always beat afterwards when I get home for the rest of the day. The third
time I went I was not so tired but I think that was because the two main people
were out of town so I was pretty much on my own. It feels very stressful for me
to feel pressure for how much I'm able to get done each time I'm there
especially since the second time I went they had me work on an entirely
different research/statistics project that they wanted by the end of the day.
It wasn't too bad and I was able to is the expected level of work produced at
the end of each working day. But then this week when I went, I had scheduled a
meeting with the founder to just make sure I'm on the right track with my
research. But then he wanted a specific statistic that he had never made known
to be that I had to get to him by the end of the day which was within an hour.
So I was kind of annoyed that on the paper of the assignment description for my
research on the effects of porn on youth, it never said that he was looking for
the specific stat on how much exact time teenagers are watching porn each week.
I don't even particularly agree that this stat is important at all. Rather I
think it's more important to determine if kids are watching a lot of porn as in
if they are in the porn addict category, which I think would be hard to find
data on, or the percentage of kids who have just been exposed to hardcore porn
at all I think is far more important. Simply a stat on how much porn kids are
watching rather than what they're watching I don't think leads much of
anywhere. I think since I haven't been in communication with him as much this
is the problem, and I think I should probably just email him to sort out what
his objective is and how I want to approach it differently.
Now I'm shifting back to talking about
the physical strain of working. It feels like I got so much going on which is
good in the sense that it's forcing me to be more on top of everything, but
it's also unsettling because I am someone who typically needs to have a lot of
downtime during the day because I will get flare-ups of chronic pain throughout
the week. And that's what's also annoying because there is always this element
of instability in how I will be feeling in a given time of the week, and it's
hard for me to have to be at this point of planning all of my time throughout
my week and not knowing how I will be feeling each day to know if I can pull it
off. I have a lot of physical problems so it is not only a concern of mine for
how I will manage my internship but will manage a job in the working world
after I graduate. I want to get a few years of working experience before I
would consider going back to school, partially because I am exhausted from
school but also to find out what I would want to write a thesis on. But I am
also concerned about wearing on my mental physical health just through working
as well. I have had different jobs in my life, and have had an internship
before when I took a semester off, but it's been so long for me and I don't
think that seemed as stressful because it wasn't as high stakes as this
internship since my previous one was in the field of parks and recreation. I
thought I wanted to work at the place I'm interning at before, but now I'm not
so sure because I feel like its awkward and uncomfortable in talking with the
founder. I don't know if we view issues in the same way. Above all I think I'm
someone with whom it's almost more important for me with who I'm working with
rather than what work I'm doing. I'm someone who is affected by people's energy
very easily and if I don't like people I work with I know it's going to do me
more harm than good, no matter how good of a cause it is because then I will
not be doing my best work.
Thinking about this stuff makes me think of reagon's
piece we read on coalition building, that it should not be homey or
comfortable, but I wonder if this is perhaps abelist at the same time. For people
with disabilities we actually do need to be comfortable, because having to
perform well while working through pain is extremely difficult. I think this is what leaves the issue of disability by the
wayside because no matter how much of a positive working environment you have,
working itself takes a physical toll and that is going to disproportionately
affect people with disabilities. And this is part of the stress I feel that
under abelist capitalism, it makes us feel bad about ourselves if we aren't able to live up to
the demands of others, when it really depends on what the person with
disabilities determines they can get done at any given time. But then people
misinterpret this as lazy, self-centered, or unreasonable. However I do want to specify that I
don't take to mean a comfortable environment as one where everyone agrees with
one another and there's this fake cheerful attitude. Rather I think a
comfortable environment is one in which communication comes easily between
people, people can express a negative mood they are in and it not be reflected
as poor manners, and where people know they have to coincide their expectations
of others with meeting them where they are at.
So yeah in response, if anyone has had similar struggles or has
any suggestions then I would love some advice on how to feel less
stressed/fatigued physically from working.
Blog 2: Installation and Exhibit Opening
Hello everyone! I want to start this post off addressing some of the comments and questions that were left on my first blog post. Galería de la Raza has six paid employees, three interns and a good few people that make up the core group of volunteers. I don’t have exact numbers for the amount of volunteers, so I’ll try to find out that number soon. The exhibits are chosen by the curator and the executive director of the gallery. The current exhibit was actually created after their originally planned exhibit fell through, so the curator and executive director decided to create an open call for art. I believe this is the first open call for artwork that Galería has been involved in, so the whole process was new to all of the staff members. In terms of making the art more accessible, Galería is open to the public free of charge, and the many times I have worked as a gallery attendant has shown me that this is one of the most important parts of reaching a wider audience. A lot of the people who come into the gallery space happen to walk by and see something that caught their eye through the window. They are part of the wider audience that the artwork reaches when it is free to view, and that might not have been reached if it was in a gallery with entrance fees.
The time between my last post and now has been, once again, taken up by installing the artwork. Last time, we were starting to receive some of the pieces to install them. The soft opening for the exhibit was last Saturday, and at that point, we had yet to receive all of the artwork. One of the most difficult things during this time was the lack of communication between the artists and the curator, as well as between staff members. There was a deadline for when artists needed to have their artwork at the gallery, but due to a lot of shipping issues or in the case of one artist, submitting a piece of artwork they no longer owned, the deadline became flexible. This caused some issues with installation because we were installing the pieces as we received them, and sometimes the artwork was bigger than expected. This occurred with two pieces we received a few days before the opening. The two paintings (pictured below) were not going to fit on any wall except the main gallery wall, which already had a vinyl mural (also pictured below) already hung up on it. This forced us to basically take down all the pieces we had already installed and rearrange them on different walls. The day we had to do this, we were all frustrated, but managed to channel a lot of that frustration into getting the artwork up.
As I read Karen Bojar’s article “Volunteerism and Women’s Lives..,” I was surprised that I had not previously thought about the gendered aspects of volunteerism. Bojar’s article made me more conscious of the positionality of Galería de la Raza and its staff, which is almost completely made up of not just women, but women of color. I bring this up because Bojar at one point says that “for men, most voluntary organizations were a small part of their lives; for women, voluntary organizations were an alternative career ladder” (36). The fact that volunteer work more frequently becomes career paths for women is showed by the staff at Galería, who for the most part, also started working there as volunteers. But I wonder why even today, when women are now able to work beyond volunteering, the majority of volunteer and social justice positions are filled by women. What gendered expectations are in place that might emphasize and encourage volunteer work for women more then men? I’m hoping these questions have somewhat clearer answers as I work through the semester. For now, I’ll leave everyone with some pictures of the main gallery space that is now finished (we still haven't gotten labels for each art piece yet, so I'm not able to give the artists' names but I will edit this post when I do have them available. However, the first picture is the mural painted by Jessica Sabogal):
Sunday, February 21, 2016
First month
Hi all!
A little late here. I have actually been completing a fellowship with the deport defense team at Dolores Street Community Services since last May, but have been able to increase my hours to work on a set of different tasks for the 698 course. Prior to this January, my tasks ranged from overall support for the attorneys, form filing, translation of documents, interpretation at asylum interviews, and country condition research to support asylum applications. While my tasks varied, they were mainly involved working with the cases of children who have been identified by the court as unaccompanied minors, or minors that entered the United States without their parents, and are therefore in placed in the primary dockets of the immigration court. As part of the added weekly hours, I have now gotten the chance to work on the asylum cases of adult women who are also on this docket, but whose cases are being reviewed by the immigration judge (IJ), rather than an asylum officer as was the case for the children.
While the process of filing and preparing for asylum is fairly similar, the experience of working women survivors of many violences is much different.
I have found it particularly difficult to ask women to share very intimate and traumatic experiences from their past, some of which they had not shared with other individuals or had not completely addressed at all.This retellings of violence is the beginning of a long process in which the client relives her trauma by in front of several different individuals (legal service provider, mental health evaluator, immigration judge or officer ..etc), a process in which her story is scrutinized and picked apart in order to determine her eligibility for asylum. I have learned that most of the cases involving women survivors of domestic and sexual violence are grouped under the category of “particular social group” which can range from “Married women in Guatemala who are unable to leave their relationship” to “Women/girls in El Salvador without adequate protection from male abusers” both of which have been accepted by the IJ in cases I’ve collaborated with this office. I was troubled with the way our clients experiences were reduced to a victim framework in order to be recognized by the court, I was to a point relieved to learn that the attorneys felt this way too, but they also noted that we were unfortunately working within an outdated and unfair system that wants just that.
Not too long ago, I was able to sit in a client’s individual court hearing for the first time. I had spend a significant amount of time drafting her declaration together with her, putting together relevant country condition research to support her claim, as well as reaching out to family member in her home country for letters of support, all of which were submitted to the court in advance. It was a great relief to witness her being granted asylum and seeing her emotional celebration with her children who were also granted. At that moment, I hoped that besides her new status, she could take with her the knowledge that she had overcome yet another obstacle in her life, highlighting not her victimhood but her strength.
Friday, February 19, 2016
First Blog Entry: CCS
Hey everyone!
I am currently an intern at Crisis Support Services of Alameda County (CSS). At CSS counselors offer counseling services onsite as well as a suicide hotline that's open to the public, and a text line that is geared towards the youth, but also open to the public. A lot of the people who handle the hotlines are volunteers and many of them have been there for many years. Before I signed with CSS I really struggled to find a place that felt right to me. I think mainly the most frustrating thing for me in the process was waiting to hear back from organizations, not hearing back from some at all, and the interviews (I get tons of anxiety and forget everything!). Thankfully, the week school started I was able to sign with CSS and am extremely excited about the experience.
I started with CSS the first week of school. The first day I met with my supervisor, we did some introductions to get familiar with each other, talked about scheduling, as well as some ideas on what CSS is looking for. My supervisor talked about how she was interested in having me help her create a training for the counselors surrounding LGBTQ issues and explore how they can create safe spaces for callers and texters. I'm excited for this process because of the intersectional framework we will being using! For the internship I am going to interview some of the counselors and directors in the office to see what they think could be added and improved in their training, create a survey to give to the other members of the organization, do research, work on powerpoints, create worksheets, etc. The next few meetings following the first we went into a more brief version of the training that the counselors themselves go through. We have now started a little more on the survey as well as research about what could be useful, but are still going through the training as well.
So far, I feel extremely welcomed intro the community despite my initial nerves that I had the first week I started. I've met so many different people in the organization already and am constantly learning new things. I'll keep you updated!
-Samantha
I am currently an intern at Crisis Support Services of Alameda County (CSS). At CSS counselors offer counseling services onsite as well as a suicide hotline that's open to the public, and a text line that is geared towards the youth, but also open to the public. A lot of the people who handle the hotlines are volunteers and many of them have been there for many years. Before I signed with CSS I really struggled to find a place that felt right to me. I think mainly the most frustrating thing for me in the process was waiting to hear back from organizations, not hearing back from some at all, and the interviews (I get tons of anxiety and forget everything!). Thankfully, the week school started I was able to sign with CSS and am extremely excited about the experience.
I started with CSS the first week of school. The first day I met with my supervisor, we did some introductions to get familiar with each other, talked about scheduling, as well as some ideas on what CSS is looking for. My supervisor talked about how she was interested in having me help her create a training for the counselors surrounding LGBTQ issues and explore how they can create safe spaces for callers and texters. I'm excited for this process because of the intersectional framework we will being using! For the internship I am going to interview some of the counselors and directors in the office to see what they think could be added and improved in their training, create a survey to give to the other members of the organization, do research, work on powerpoints, create worksheets, etc. The next few meetings following the first we went into a more brief version of the training that the counselors themselves go through. We have now started a little more on the survey as well as research about what could be useful, but are still going through the training as well.
So far, I feel extremely welcomed intro the community despite my initial nerves that I had the first week I started. I've met so many different people in the organization already and am constantly learning new things. I'll keep you updated!
-Samantha
Hello Everyone!
I unfortunately had a tough time finding an internship site, but lucky for me someone finally gave me an opportunity. I get to intern at Women's Community Clinic in San Francisco! My dream is to become a nurse and this women's clinic will give me a great experience towards my dream.
I know it's a bit late to start at our internships, but I'm not to worried because I have interned before. At my past internship I had to earn 180 hours between January and May, but I was able to earn well over 300 hours.
I have signed up to work Tuesdays through Thursdays 1pm to 5pm, which allows me to get over our required 60 hours.
Hopefully all goes well and on my next blog I will be sure to let you all know how my first day or week went, so look for my next entry.
Have fun at you intern sites everyone!!!
-Sheevena Singh
I unfortunately had a tough time finding an internship site, but lucky for me someone finally gave me an opportunity. I get to intern at Women's Community Clinic in San Francisco! My dream is to become a nurse and this women's clinic will give me a great experience towards my dream.
I know it's a bit late to start at our internships, but I'm not to worried because I have interned before. At my past internship I had to earn 180 hours between January and May, but I was able to earn well over 300 hours.
I have signed up to work Tuesdays through Thursdays 1pm to 5pm, which allows me to get over our required 60 hours.
Hopefully all goes well and on my next blog I will be sure to let you all know how my first day or week went, so look for my next entry.
Have fun at you intern sites everyone!!!
-Sheevena Singh
Mission Graduates
Hello, all! I have had some difficulty landing a volunteer
position, but I was finally able to find one at Mission Graduates! It's an
organization that offers several programs for grade school students, but my
time with them will be with their after school programs for elementary and
middle school students. Their Extended Day Program (EDP) is spread across three
elementary schools and helps the students transition into a middle school
setting. The Mission Community Beacon (MCB) is held at one middle school and
helps them prepare for lives as successful adults. The MCB is also much less
structured than the EDP because as older students, they have more autonomy.
I have not worked with the children yet, as I had to get a
background check and tuberculosis test done, and I am still waiting for the
results of both. But I should have them within the next few days. After that, I
will be meeting with them two or three days a week. I’ll be starting off going
doing the MCB and the EDP, but my supervisor said that after a couple of weeks,
I can choose to commit to one program or stick with both. Without any
experience with either of them, my first thought was to keep doing both, but
then I thought that maybe it would be a good idea to stay with one school so
the students get more familiar and comfortable with me. I’ll make my best judgment,
but what do you all think?
I’m very excited to be working with Mission Graduates. My dream
job after college is to work with children, so I know this will be a great opportunity
for me to learn more about their needs and how their minds work. You can only
read so much about children, but getting to work with them in person will yield
much more knowledge.
Intro and First Week
I chose an internship at Hand in Hand: The Domestic Employers Network. Their purpose is to advocate for respectful and fair working conditions, which shows up as community outreach, lobbying, campaigning, etc. My understanding is that public policy protects laborers with the exception of domestic work, which would include those in housecleaning, home attendance, and nannying. This means that things that I’ve unknowingly taken for granted in my almost ten years of employment, like overtime pay and human resources protection, are not granted to domestic workers. I took this internship because it made me uncomfortable. I have naturally been drawn to work surrounding sexual trauma and youth outreach, so that is primarily where my knowledge lies. The fact is I know nothing about employment policies or how campaigning and lobbying works. Since majority of the employees I work with are undocumented women of color, and I had just recently written a paper about immigration detention centers as sites of the PIC, I was all the more interested in learning more.
My first week has been interesting. My first day was at a campaign meeting where they discussed HiH’s involvement in upcoming events and the domestic worker rights legislative campaign. It was cool to see their way of organizing, figuring out ways to move forward with domestic workers’ rights, both at the legislative level through lobbying and the community level through trainings. My tasks so far have not been super significant, as my supervisor wants me to learn more about the organization and essentially train a bit on what they do. My tasks have been things like meeting preparation (creating folder packets for upcoming meetings), taking down the agenda, data entry, and phone banking.
After the first week, I’d have to say I’m a little conflicted with what I’m a part of. While it is a great mission to fight for the rights of domestic workers, it troubles me to think that if the legislation gets passed that they have worked years to bring to fruition—that means agencies will both monitor employer compliance and enforce policy if they refuse to comply. What does “enforcement” look like? If the primary population of employees is undocumented, I keep telling myself that this compounds their risk of deportation. Considering my research on the increasing number of immigrant detainees as lucrative bodies for the prison industrial complex, it troubles me that already-vulnerable people are made even more vulnerable to detainment and eventual deportation.
The mission states that the network is “grounded in the conviction that dignified and respectful working conditions benefit worker and employer alike.” For some reason, a scenario keeps recurring in my head: if an employer refuses to comply, can’t they easily threaten their employee with deportation? So how would passing legislation “benefit worker and employer alike”? I feel that the PIC and deportation are the very things that have enabled employers of domestic workers to veil the very things that HiH is trying to fight against: unfair pay, unpaid overtime, sexual harassment, unsafe working conditions, etc. I am honestly not confident that new public policy will actually change those things, especially considering what enforcement would look like. If anything, it may make matters worse for the lives of the primary subjects.
I remember learning a couple of years ago about how the marketing of “save the sexually trafficked!” actually, for mostly all cases of undocumented immigrant sex workers, worked against them and led to deportation to living conditions that they were trying to be freed from in the first place. Instead, this “saving” benefited U.S. deployment of racist and heteropatriarchal imperialism (and conveniently fed into colonialist and savior discourses). I guess my main fear, despite the good intentions of the organization, is to be an agent in something that would cause more problems for workers in the long run.
My first week has been interesting. My first day was at a campaign meeting where they discussed HiH’s involvement in upcoming events and the domestic worker rights legislative campaign. It was cool to see their way of organizing, figuring out ways to move forward with domestic workers’ rights, both at the legislative level through lobbying and the community level through trainings. My tasks so far have not been super significant, as my supervisor wants me to learn more about the organization and essentially train a bit on what they do. My tasks have been things like meeting preparation (creating folder packets for upcoming meetings), taking down the agenda, data entry, and phone banking.
After the first week, I’d have to say I’m a little conflicted with what I’m a part of. While it is a great mission to fight for the rights of domestic workers, it troubles me to think that if the legislation gets passed that they have worked years to bring to fruition—that means agencies will both monitor employer compliance and enforce policy if they refuse to comply. What does “enforcement” look like? If the primary population of employees is undocumented, I keep telling myself that this compounds their risk of deportation. Considering my research on the increasing number of immigrant detainees as lucrative bodies for the prison industrial complex, it troubles me that already-vulnerable people are made even more vulnerable to detainment and eventual deportation.
The mission states that the network is “grounded in the conviction that dignified and respectful working conditions benefit worker and employer alike.” For some reason, a scenario keeps recurring in my head: if an employer refuses to comply, can’t they easily threaten their employee with deportation? So how would passing legislation “benefit worker and employer alike”? I feel that the PIC and deportation are the very things that have enabled employers of domestic workers to veil the very things that HiH is trying to fight against: unfair pay, unpaid overtime, sexual harassment, unsafe working conditions, etc. I am honestly not confident that new public policy will actually change those things, especially considering what enforcement would look like. If anything, it may make matters worse for the lives of the primary subjects.
I remember learning a couple of years ago about how the marketing of “save the sexually trafficked!” actually, for mostly all cases of undocumented immigrant sex workers, worked against them and led to deportation to living conditions that they were trying to be freed from in the first place. Instead, this “saving” benefited U.S. deployment of racist and heteropatriarchal imperialism (and conveniently fed into colonialist and savior discourses). I guess my main fear, despite the good intentions of the organization, is to be an agent in something that would cause more problems for workers in the long run.
Hi. This is Elizabeth. My
internship, at Hand in Hand, is off to a slow start. I have only hand one full
day of work so far because I go in on Fridays. I’ve had three shorter days, or
tasks, for my internship so far. The first was to go to Lindsay’s house so she
could fill out my contract for this course, and also so we could go over the
guidelines for responsibilities. My primary project with Hand in Hand (HiH) is
to manage testimonials from employers of domestic workers to be used in support
of a new bill, SB 1015, which will require overtime pay
after 9 hours of work. The testimonials will be used at rallies and gatherings for
the bill, but also presented to legislators when lobbying. I contact employers
to ask for testimonials, edit testimonials, send testimonials to volunteers for
editing, and scribe testimonials. Lindsay wants to record people with speech
disabilities giving their testimonials and have them captioned so that they
will actually be able to speak for themselves, rather than having someone else
speak their words. I have experience with basic video editing, so that is
another responsibility for further down the road. It was interesting to be in
Lindsay’s home and work with her one-on-one because it gave me more context on
her life and what she does with HiH. Every single tab on her laptop (and there
were Savci level tabs) were for HiH.
The second
was an organizing meeting where members from HiH came to discuss plans. This
was the day after our first class, so the readings were fresh in my mind. HiH
does a lot of work with people with disabilities, and the first person who
arrived to the meeting was Monique. We were serving snacks at the meeting, and
Monique asked me to get her a tangerine so I brought her one. She then asked me
to feed her, which made me uncomfortable because I’ve never had to hand feed a
person before. It was a very jarring experience for me because it felt like an
intimate act, but this was part of Monique’s daily life. Aside from that, the
meeting was overwhelming because I just stepped into a Movement and I’ve just
started my internship. Like, I’m doing this as a requirement for a class when
this is a movement that at least hundreds of people have devoted themselves to
for years and is impacting thousands of people. It’s a strange contrast.
The third
day was yesterday. I drove to a center called Ability Now to scribe a
testimonial for a man named Kevin. I was very nervous because he has a speech
disability, and since I was scribing for him it meant he doesn’t have use on
his hands. We spoke on the phone earlier in the week and went through a speech
service called Speech to Speech. The service was a great tool, but I had never
used a speech service before and they went through the instructions a bit too
quickly for me, so the phone call could have gone more smoothly. I got to our
appointment early and checked in at the front desk. Kevin came over right away.
He was younger than I thought he’d be, and he was very friendly. Overall I
think the process was okay. I’m realizing that the more I work with people with
disabilities, the more I will about their community and the correct way to
interact. For instance, many customs and manners are inaccessible for some
people like shaking hands or looking a person in the eye or at their face when
having a conversation.
Since
starting my internship, I’ve interacted with people who are disabled more than
I ever have before. I have started thinking about my ability, and how it
impacts the way I interact with the world. Disability truly is the most
underrepresented group. I’ve never had to evaluate my physical ability, but I
have seriously overlooked my privilege and I didn’t even realize. It has been
difficult to grapple with the way ableism and privilege are deeply engrained
into me. I’m still trying to work through my thoughts about this, so right now
things are a bit jumbled. When I have a clearer understand I’ll explain. But,
yeah, that’s my internship so far!
My first blog entry. Asian Women's Residence/ Resource Center.
Hi, this is Akiko. I work at Asian Women's Resource Center once a week from 1/20.
My tasks are to do some office work, tutor elementary school children (1st~ 5th grade), and sometimes make some presents for residents or produce some ideas of fundraising.
Most of people at AWRC are bilingual/ semilingual, so it makes me feel relieved (not nervous?) that I am not the only one who doesn't know English well. Thus, they understand how difficult it is to communicate in the language we aren't best at, and they don't get angry even if there was a misunderstanding. I feel comfortable working at such an environment.
I had some difficulties tutoring children. I knew that it would be challenging to teach them English, but I didn't think that math would be hard to teach them, too although I have experiences in tutoring kids as a part-time job. A student asked me how much a yard is, and I wasn't able to answer because I usually use meters and kilograms. Since I am not familiar with inches, ounces, etc, I had to ask another teacher to help with the student. I wasn't able to help solving a 5th grade math problem either because of tricky sentences. Eventually, I felt like children didn't want help from me. I completely lost my confidence in teaching, but my supervisor told me that it was a good opportunity for me to learn, too.
After tutoring, I was talking to a staff, and parents of those children came to pick them up. I finally understood that why AWRC offers tutoring services then. Many of the parents I met seemed that their first language wasn't English by hearing their conversation with children and staff. I didn't think about education of children of immigrants or non-English speakers, but if I were a parent, I would definitely need tutors to help my child for their homework because I don't think I can teach them. I thought it was a great opportunity for the children and their parents because for children, they have more chance to speak/write English outside of school so that they won't (hopefully) struggle at school due to language barriers. For their parents, it is great because tutors help their kids' homework even if they don't have time to help or they might not be able to teach them.
My tasks are to do some office work, tutor elementary school children (1st~ 5th grade), and sometimes make some presents for residents or produce some ideas of fundraising.
Most of people at AWRC are bilingual/ semilingual, so it makes me feel relieved (not nervous?) that I am not the only one who doesn't know English well. Thus, they understand how difficult it is to communicate in the language we aren't best at, and they don't get angry even if there was a misunderstanding. I feel comfortable working at such an environment.
I had some difficulties tutoring children. I knew that it would be challenging to teach them English, but I didn't think that math would be hard to teach them, too although I have experiences in tutoring kids as a part-time job. A student asked me how much a yard is, and I wasn't able to answer because I usually use meters and kilograms. Since I am not familiar with inches, ounces, etc, I had to ask another teacher to help with the student. I wasn't able to help solving a 5th grade math problem either because of tricky sentences. Eventually, I felt like children didn't want help from me. I completely lost my confidence in teaching, but my supervisor told me that it was a good opportunity for me to learn, too.
After tutoring, I was talking to a staff, and parents of those children came to pick them up. I finally understood that why AWRC offers tutoring services then. Many of the parents I met seemed that their first language wasn't English by hearing their conversation with children and staff. I didn't think about education of children of immigrants or non-English speakers, but if I were a parent, I would definitely need tutors to help my child for their homework because I don't think I can teach them. I thought it was a great opportunity for the children and their parents because for children, they have more chance to speak/write English outside of school so that they won't (hopefully) struggle at school due to language barriers. For their parents, it is great because tutors help their kids' homework even if they don't have time to help or they might not be able to teach them.
Thursday, February 18, 2016
First Blog Entry
My work as
an intern commenced early January. I had to prepare a budget PowerPoint
presentation for my supervisor on the very first day, a task that felt like
being thrown at the deep end and took me the entire day to accomplish. I went
back home thinking ‘I am not going back there.' My prior work experiences have
all been boots on the ground, being on the streets and mobilizing people. I had
chosen the Human Rights Commission for two main reasons: I wanted to
familiarize myself with policy work and law implementation and to get hands on
experience how laws are formulated and better understand where the gap occurs
when they do not translate into practice. Second, I have always worked with
NGOs and always been critical of the failures of the government and how it only
seeks to protect its interests. HRC’s mission is to protect and promote human
rights for all, and I wanted to experience this first hand, to see for myself
how the commission works with communities on issues of inequalities and
discrimination and how it recognizes and rises to its failures and limitations.
I spent the first two weeks familiarizing myself with the work done by the HRC,
attending staff meetings and community meetings which gave me a real sense of
who they work with and how they collaborate with communities. I am currently
working on a project called Housing and Search Policies for Transgender and
Nonconforming prisoners.
This has
been an ongoing project for the past two years. It is a coalition of various
NGOs that advocate Transgender rights. The NGOs involved have been working on
developing a housing policy that respects gender identity of all prisoners. They
urge the San Francisco Sheriff Department to revise policies that address the
important housing and programming needs for transgender and non-conforming
prisoners. There are however issues of miscommunication and different working
strategies amongst the NGOs and HRC was brought on board as a mediator.
One-half of the coalition seeks to pursue a more radical approach because trans
women of color continue to be highly criminalized and when incarcerated are
vulnerable to violence, so they want the Sheriff to take prompt action. The
other half is more interested in reviewing other related options, like revising
the already drafted policy and have a dialogue with Sheriff and the Chief Legal
Counsel. What is at stake here is that the more the coalition remains divided,
the lesser chances of this policy being passed and implemented. HRC has a task
of overseeing how this policy can be smoothly carried out with both sides
reaching a consensus. While working on this project, few questions came to my
mind: how can HRC be involved and not be biased (it is a government agency
after all); How can the HRC bypass be entangled in political
disputes/conflicts? I will be working on this project until the end of my
internship, meeting with these organizations and thinking through the limits
and dangers of coalition building. And further thinking of how they can work
together beyond their differences? What strategies can be employed to ensure
that the common goal is met? This experience reminds me of Reagan's
articulation that coalitions should not be a place of comfort.
Friday, February 12, 2016
Introduction + 1st Blog Entry
I am interning at Homies Organizing the Mission to Empower Youth (HOMEY), which is a 501(c)3 organization that was formed in 1999 in response to the approximately 40 youth that were murdered in the Mission District due to street violence. Although I haven’t started my internship yet, I’m excited to be working within an organization that is committed to addressing issues related to gentrification, police brutality, and the prison industrial complex. What compelled me to reach out to HOMEY was their commitment to motivating youth of color to become the next generation of leaders in the community. I feel like I could have benefited from an organization like HOMEY when I was growing up. Being a Brown kid embedded in a system that didn’t value my history or voice was difficult, which is why this work is so important to me. I was excited to learn that most of the founders and people working within HOMEY are former street affiliated youth who know firsthand what it is like to have to navigate multiple forms of oppression. Although HOMEY has been relatively male-dominated, they have voiced a commitment to changing the gender dynamics within the organization.
Within the next week or so, I will begin working directly with the youth. What I am most excited about is taking some of the skills that I've learned within the major and applying them to the way that I interact with the youth. I recently read an excerpt from Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom by bell hooks. One of the things that she argues is the importance of seeing the relationship between teacher and student as one that is reciprocal, meaning that the teacher acts as a student and student acts as a teacher. I think it will be incredibly important to remember that I will be teaching the youth and also being taught by them. I want them to know that it is a two-way street. In addition, I always want them to feel like their stories and voices matter. Another thing I took away from the arguments outlined by hooks is the importance of teachers instilling an ethic of self-care and self-love into their students. I feel like this will be valuable when working with the youth at HOMEY. I feel like confidence is not something that is nurtured within Black and Brown kids, and I want to instill a sense of self-care and self-love back into them. This teacher-student dynamic is important because I will be mentoring the youth.
My first day at ITVS - Women and Girls Lead Global
As some
one who is interested in feminist filmmaking I’m often hounded by the thought “what
must film do”?Among others, the films of Maya Deren, Julie Dash, Agnes
Varda, Chantal Akerman, Catherine
Breillat have in their own ways changed me. But the change has been inexplicable.
So even as I recognize the transformative potential of film I cringe a little
at the thought of films being used as a “tool for social change”. What is
social change? How does one measure it? How does one calculate the quality of
change? Are there certain kinds of films that are some how more amenable to
this project of change? The campaign I was to work on at ITVS wanted to “use
women’s stories to create social change”. As you can tell, I went into my first
day at work with a number of concerns about their vision. However given that
most media for development/change programs rely on educational programming I was
also curious to be part of a project that brought film and community work
together.
My first impression of ITVS was how well funded they seemed.
They had a large office downtown with almost 80 employees. Things were clearly
going well in the documentary funding business. My supervisor was quick to
welcome me and help me settle in. I was given a range of regional campaign
strategy documents to read while my supervisor and her boss went into a
conference call with their local partners in India, Jordan, Kenya, Bangladesh
and Peru. As I was looking through the documents I couldn’t help but think
about this transnational conference call happening in the other room. It was
9.30 am in San Francisco but what time was it in India, Jordan, Kenya,
Bangladesh and Peru? Late night? The language of the strategy documents
described their local partners as “stakeholders”, “collaborators”. In other
words they appeared to be equally invested in running the WGLG film screenings
in their regions. However, I couldn’t help but see this conference call as a
telling sign of the power dynamics in this partnership, where all their
regional partners had to make themselves available according to dictates of the
American work day.
After the call I was briefed about the social media strategy
of WGLG global. Over the course of the conversation it became clear that social
media numbers (followers, likes, re-tweets) are another indicator of social
change/impact not necessarily for the organization but for the funders. I
wonder what this requirement to have “measurable” impact even if its currency
is likes and double taps means for community work that is not visible in this
way? What about community work where “visibility” might come with the threat of
violence? What about community work that doesn’t have access to this new medium
of social media and the new language it requires.
My day ended with proofreading a discussion guide that is to
accompany a film that had been selected for community screening. I also edited
a blog entry that had been submitted to the WGLG team by one of the local
partners. While both the discussion guide and the blog included work by WGLG’s
regional collaborators, I left work that day thinking about the almost
invisible tyranny of “proper” English and professionalization.
First Blog Entry: AWS : Enkhmaa
I look forward to intern with Asian Women’s Shelter (AWS). AWS’s values consist of survivor centeredness, anti-oppression framework, and non-hierarchical organizational structure. This is not the first time that I am getting involved with AWS. My involvement with AWS has started since 2012, where I completed the mandatory 74 hours of volunteer/language advocates training. I had volunteered at AWS for little more than year. Then in 2015, I chose to complete volunteer/language advocates training again. I did that because I had a plan to volunteer abroad, Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia -in Summer of 2015.
At my intern, I will focus on a particular project, it is to create ‘phrase manual’ in six different languages. My part in the project is to coordinate language advocates from six different communities; this part of the intern involves recruiting suitable language advocates based on their language skills from AWS’s language advocate files, communicating through phone and email to schedule and set up the initial meeting, introducing project’s goal and expected outcome. The project is expected to be completed by June, 2016, this is a great opportunity to experience how a project begins and ends, also what obstacles might occur. The expected number of participants in this project are three language advocates from each community. I believe this task will help me further my organizational skills, interpersonal skills and community building skills.
Another aspect of the project is the actual process of creating the phrase manual. I haven’t yet discussed about the introduction of the manual. I expect there to be one, this is where I hope to apply my transnational analytic skills and intersectionality discussed in WGS discourse, particularly on the representation of survivors of domestic violence. The introduction has significant role to remind advocates to comprehend the possible power dynamic that would occur in their relationship with survivors of DV and human trafficking. This power dynamic is vital to advocacy work; this power dynamic could be easily created through language; ex: victim v. survivor, partner v. husband/wife/boyfriend/girlfriend (assumption of sexual orientation based on gender), help v. support, gender-neutral pronoun v. (assumption of gender based on voice/tone or assumption of sexual orientation based on voice/tone- particularly on phone conversation) etc.,. The power discussed here is imagined to take place in such an intimate space, it may not be easy to grasp. As Kimberly Crenshaw defines transnational analysis as “ WGS examines power, privilege, and differences within or across boundaries and through processes ranging from the intimate to the global….” (1989) Similar to Grewal’s examination of problematic power relations such as ‘who is speaking for whom? what relations of power enable them to speak for others? what forms of violence do these representations perform?’ inscribed in their/NGO’s/grass-root organizations’ efforts.
Volunteerism tends to project saviorism; this worries me, particularly the word “HELP” or the idea that volunteer to help. The word ‘HELP’ easily creates power dynamics between parties. Here I would like to share a quote by Lilla Watson, “If you have come to help me, you are wasting your time. If you have come because your liberation is bound up with mine, then let us work together.” ~Lilla Watson. This quote speaks to me. One way of intersectionality is deployed is as approach to social justice that renders visible how systems of inequality function in overlapping ways. Domestic violence has been discussed as gendered violence; however, gender alone should not be discussed in isolation. This is where transnational analysis needs to be brought in. During my internship, my intention is to pay close attention to how domestic violence discussed in NGOs and their discourses.
I hope I made sense, I am open to suggestions, concerns, questions, and comments. Please feel free to do so.
Enkhmaa Enkhbold
First Impressions
I
am interning at an anti-bullying non-profit called No Bully started in 2003.
They have different kinds of schools trainings that they give to schools to
teach their school administrators, teachers, staff, and parents how to deal
with bullying. They are in several states and have recently been getting a
little international presence as well. It seems like a really nice model and
service and I am really hoping that I would be able to get a job there
afterwards. The lady I interviewed with and am working under used to be the CEO
of planned parenthood in the bay area so it is nice know that I am getting to
work under a feminist for my internship. They have me currently working on a
research project on the effects of porn on youth development and how this might
lead to greater sexual harassment and bullying. It is a very interesting topic because
we are really in this guinea pig era of not knowing what are going to be the
full long term effects on society and youth development, so it's exciting since
porn is not a topic I've learned about in WGS, but also very dark and shocking
because it is far worse than I ever could have imagined.
Since
the last time I was there it was just me and this other lady pretty much, she's
very sweet so I thought this would be a good chance just to ask her about the
likelihood of getting a job there afterwards. It is a pretty small group of
only 5 people so I haven't decided if this is a good or bad thing in trying to
get a position with them. She gave me some good advice that you basically have
to advocate for that there is a need for you with what you can provide that
they don't currently have. Like with whatever kind of work or assignments they
have you on, that is a good indicator of what they would need help with. Like I
am doing research for example, and they don't have anyone officially doing
research or really have a system in place for how they will update their
programming/trainings. This is something I asked about in my initial interview
with the lady I am working under on how they continue to incorporate scientific
evidence of what works best for bullying. She basically said the system is
pretty sound since it was based off research on what works best for kids and
follows a non-punitive approach and started off as a collaboration of
educators, psychologists, and lawyers to come up with the No Bully System.
While
I think they continue to improve upon their trainings, I get the impression
there is not an official system in place on continually looking into research
and building upon new evidence. I also asked the woman with whom I asked about
jobs with, if No Bully in their trainings addresses and breaks down bullying based
on race, gender, disability, sexual orientation, etc. and she didn't think it
did this stuff specifically. I am pretty surprised by this if this really is
the case and this might be another area where I will be able to advocate for a
position for myself within their group, since I am a WGS major, Race &
Resistance minor, and interested in going to grad school for Disability Studies,
so I think I could advocate for that I bring an important perspective to their
group. So my additional advice for anyone trying to get a job with their group
afterwards would be to ask as many questions as possible and try to find
possible holes or flaws in their programming, either to save yourself from
working with a group you will not like, or for finding out what problems there
are so you can potentially be the one to help in these areas.
Lisa Mears
Interning at CA Coalition for Women Prisoners
I have gone to my internship 4 times in the last few weeks and really like being there. I am starting to get to know people around the office (which they share with Legal Services for Prisoners with Children). Before starting I was really nervous about entering into the space. Even though I have been interested in the injustices in the prison system for a long time and have seen it from an outsiders view, I haven't been actively involved in the community. It is really inspiring to be around people who have devoted their life or parts of their lives to advocating for people who have been caught up in our injust system. What I particularly like about CCWP is that they have very few people that are hired on as staff. Most of the work being done is by volunteers, people that come from varied backgrounds. They also make it a point that at the very center of all their work in the women in the system, their words and experiences, being the most important. At this point I am there just taking it all in. I want to learn as much as I can about the work they do. My supervisor at CCWP gives me new reading material every time I come in and specifically seeks out material she knows will be of interest to me, like women's health care in the prison system and reproductive rights among incarcerated women and women who will be on parole. Last week I sat in on another organizations meeting who works with CCWP called Forward Together, which specifically advocates for women's healthcare and reproductive rights within the prison and jail system. In another month or so I will be able to join one of the prison visiting teams. Looking forward to this opportunity the first thing I think is, "what can I even offer?" After some thought, I realized that what I can offer right now is support and the willingness to listen. I can also offer the acknowledgement that I would like to better understand the circumstance these women are in. And with more time and knowledge, I will be able to offer more....
Blog 1: First Week and First Impressions
My first few days interning at Galeria de la Raza have been focused primarily with installing the new exhibition called “Womxn Are Perfect.” This exhibition is being comprised of many different artists who submitted their artwork during the open call. So far, I’ve helped prepare the gallery by painting the walls in the main exhibition room, one of which will have a mural painted by the artist in residence. While the Galeria de la Raza is small in comparison to other galleries, like the one in the Mission Cultural Center, I’ve learned that size by no means indicates the extent of work needed to prepare the space for a new exhibition. Of the five or so times I have gone in to work, I have spent two of those days painting during the whole time I was there. Apart from physically preparing the gallery for a new exhibition, there is the work that goes into curating the artwork and making sure all of it is delivered in time. As of this week, the main goals is having all the art delivered and ready for when installation begins sometime next week.
I chose Galeria de la Raza as my internship site because I was a volunteer last semester as part of a community service learning component for my Feminist Cultural Activism class. I had been familiar with Galeria as a space for Latinx/Chicanx artists through my sister, who was following the problems they were having with their murals depicting queer bodies being burnt down multiple times. After learning some more about them, I was interested in volunteering there mainly because they seemed keen on making art accessible for not only artists to have their artwork showcased, but also for the community they are a part of. Throughout taking WGS classes, I have been really interested in the use of culture, like art and media, as forms of activism, as well as how the arts can become more accessible to people. Interning at Galeria de la Raza will intersect with these interests really well, and hopefully allow me to learn more about this topic.
Since we are in the middle of prepping a new exhibit, it has been hectic and fast paced as we try to get a lot of tasks done within a limited time frame, so I have not gotten a full sense of what exactly my tasks and responsibilities will be. It will include some of the things I am doing right now like day-to-day admin updates, but because there are only about five paid employees who are in charge of setting up the exhibition, it is an all hands on deck situation where volunteers and interns are focusing on this one main task. Once the new exhibit opens, I will be able to make a bigger distinction of what I will be doing, and I will have a project I focus on for the rest of the semester.
I am very fortunate in that I was already familiar with the space and the people when I started my internship, and that was a very big part of why I decided to apply for the internship. There is a very familial feel to sharing the space with Galeria, and I think that is partly because it is such a small organization. While they are a small organization, they create and manage big events and programs that are open for the public. From the previous events I have helped with and with this new exhibit we are installing, it sometimes feels like they are stretched thin. I wonder if this will be a point of tension that will become clearer throughout the semester or if it is something they work around. Whatever the result of this wondering, there is really no denying that the staff works extremely hard to keep Galeria running, and they have for many years since they are celebrating their 45th anniversary this year.
Stranger Danger: First Day Tension at TGIJP
About a week ago, when I first arrived to the TGIJP offices,
I felt nervous. Everyone’s eyes drew to me, a stranger that they were
encountering for the first time. Janetta Johnson, the executive director of
TGIJP, talked about me before I arrived and spoke very highly of me. She
explained how she felt that I would bring many skills to the team, and that I
could learn a lot from their team as well. Although I thought this to be true,
I still felt like an intruder with very little to offer a team of veteran
organizers and activists. And to be honest, the apprehension I felt could be
felt among the members of the core collective. They stared at me, made sure I
was working correctly and effectively, and my male-body created a border that separated
me from them.
Sure
enough, though, after a few hours of conversation and working together, they
began to learn more about me. They asked me for my pronouns and replied “right
on” when I said they/them; they asked me where I was from and said “really?
That’s cool” when I said Compton, CA; they began to feel like I was no longer a
stranger but rather a comrade they did not yet know enough of. This made me
think of Regan’s claim that coalition work is not easy. It’s difficult, filled
with tensions, and it’s uncomfortable. Part of that discomfort, I found out my
first day, comes from the fear that those who are joining our coalitions do not
have as much at stake as some of us do.
Particularly,
I felt that many of the members were uncomfortable with the fact that I was
coming to fulfill a class requirement. There’s a certain class privilege that comes
with attending university, and also a whitening that occurs when you begin to
think, read, write, and speak like an academic. This oftentimes leads to
divisions between radical activists and academics. The radical activists claim
that the academics will not march on the streets; the academics claim that the
radical activists are not as radical as they think. This produces tensions and
missed opportunities for solidarity.
This
tension becomes heightened when an unknown body associated with the university
comes into close contact with a coalition of radical activists. The group feels
uneasy at first, but with the help and ethos of the executive director, they embraced and support me. This made me feel humbled and made me feel extremely driven to
work as hard as I could. I wanted to show my fierce investment towards prison
abolition and gender equity through the work I produced. I do not feel like I
did this for each person individually, but rather I did it for the success of the
organization and because I felt that doing so would help us reach the coalition’s
goals. Here is where I found that Regan’s idea of coalitions being formed
through a shared goal worked. I was willing to live with the tension, deal with the discomfort, and work through it all because I knew ultimately everyone was doing the work for common reasons.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)