Hi, I want to talk about motivation at Asian Women's Resource Center again this week because I have been struggling about this for a very long time (I'm sorry to write that I had this conflicting thought since the beginning of the semester).
My original solutions were boba after work, but I don't think rewards solve the problem of losing motivation; I feel like it's only temporary. I go to the organization, get boba after work, repeating the same routine every week..... What's left? Only sugar and fat from the drinks, isn't it?
I've been trying to force myself to think that how my work connects to improvement of services that the organization provides, and how my work affects in future (such as the fact that children are able to go to field trips in summer school that I planned and made reservations). Even though I think like this, it's still difficult to keep up the motivation.
One thing that changed my mind is a reading by Michelle Tea. In "You Can't Fire Me; I Quit" from the book "How to Grow Up," Tea writes "If you grow up blue collar, you're generally not expected to find a job that you love; love and job are two words that rarely show up in the same sentence. You endure your job. Ideally, you make 'enough' money" (p.225). It sounds so rude, but I thought I can apply this quote to my work. I tutor children although I'm scared and terrified of children (from babies to high school age ish). It's challenging; if it's possible, I don't want to work with them. But, I decided to work at the organization anyways, and I told them I'm working until the end of April even if I completed total 60 hours of work anyways. Thus, I kind of gave up all the work I have to do is fun. Sometimes we all have to do things we don't want to do. So, I changed my solution to find some kind of fun in work that I'm not eager to do.
Friday, April 8, 2016
Blog post 4
Our last class conversation
around the NPIC really got me thinking about both my role within the
organization as well as the role of my program’s services within a broader context
of services and community needs. Learning the different ways in which the
NPIC is also complicit in the propagation of neoliberal and capitalist ideals
can be a very disheartening realization for someone who intended to disrupt
such institution within the assumed “less perverse” non profit sector. I was
relieved to learn that I was not the only one of my peers to be having such
conflicting thoughts after our readings and realizing that our labor within the
non profit system as well as our desire to pursue a “career” in such areas,
contributed to the politics we so fervently wish to reject. However,
while operating within these politics is quite paradoxical, it is also an un-escapable
reality. The more I thought about the professionalization of the non profit
beginning with the 501 (c)(3), the more I realized that the largest and most
influential institutions of power will always play either a prominent or more
nuanced role in regulating the types of services provided by the non profits. I
believe that to an extent this is a way in which the governmental institutions
perpetuate the shadow state, funding institutions that perform where the state
is unable or unwilling to.
Sad fact: unlike the criminal
court system that is required to provide free of cost legal representation
through the public defender’s office, the United States government is not
responsible for doing the same for individuals in the immigration court system.
So while an individual in the criminal court is considered “innocent until
proven guilty” and is provided with state funded legal representation, the
refugee seeking asylum is deemed and labeled an “illegal alien” a “ criminal”
until proven otherwise with the assumed representation of an immigration
attorney… do you see what I am getting at here? The U.S. government expects new
immigrants fleeing persecution to either be able to afford private legal
representation or somehow fight their way into the overly saturated non profits
that do pro-bono work. I say fight their way into because I experience it
every Tuesday at the office. Dolores Street Community Services holds open
consultations every Tuesday for non San Francisco residents who are all in
removal proceedings, desperately seeking representation and struggling to get
it. Every Tuesday, the attorneys at my office meet with several different
individuals and families that discuss their reasons for leaving, their
persecution, their fear of return all so that at the end of their consult the
attorneys can remind them that we are not currently taking any more cases, that
they should continue calling other non profits…just keep calling. While our
program does its best at helping individuals with certain pro se filing
(filing independently without the representation of an attorney), they are
unable to represent them at the court due to the limitations set by both capacity and the restrictions of the grants
through which our program is funded (mostly local government that seeks to
cover only San Francisco residents). This is extremely troubling.
There is an undeniable
increase in demand and not enough resources to avail it. The ve very few
organizations that actually do this type of work are heavily restricted by both
capacity and public grant limitations. While San Francisco has “stepped up” and
allocated significant efforts and money to fund organizations that represent
individuals and families at the immigrations court, it sets exclusive
regulations that weed out the hundreds of families and an overwhelming amount
of children. So why is the government unwilling to provide state funded
representation at the immigration court? Because the court is considered a
civil, administrative branch of the government not a criminal one. However,
such civil court and its judges hold the power to detain and incarcerate adults
and children for months and even years depriving them of the ability to seek
the representation they so desperately need. There have been lawsuits and certain
victories in the 9th circuit around requesting the government to
fund legal representation for certain individuals considered incompetent, yet
children are considered competed enough and expected to be able to represent
themselves in court. The Fair Day in Court Act
is an activist effort that seeks to guarantee legal representation for
minors in the immigration court system. Currently sitting in a committee, it is unknown whether or not
it will make it out and gain the support
it needs.
Blog 4: Response to Laura and Re-centering Work
Before I begin, I wanted to say I appreciate Laura's most recent post because it is a nice contrast to what I will talk about. Her post is entitled "Reflections on CCWP's commitment to those most affected by the PIC," and the part that particularly resonated with me is when she says "My frustrations in the beginning and feeling like I wasn't sure where I could help have now made me see that what makes CCWP so special is that they truly are grassroots and try to center those most affected by the PIC in everything they do. There is no centralization, no Executive Director, or no hierarchy. "
Especially considering the pieces by Bierra, Mananzala and Spade, they really speak about centering social justice work around those that are most affected by the issue to which the organizations are addressing. After reading these articles, and as I noted in my Response #2 paper, this really made me think about the effectiveness of Hand in Hand. Again, this organization is a domestic employers network, which means that they have taken on approaching the employer side of the domestic workers' rights movement. The organization, itself, I believe has great values and are very intentional in the ways they educate and inform employers of fair employment practices, such as providing workshops and free resources. However, referring back to Laura, I, too, was frustrated trying to find my place in the organization, as I am neither an employer nor an employee of domestic work. And I, too, believe Hand in Hand tries to be a grassroots organization.
But I want to think more about re-centering their work, "center those most affected" by the absence of fundamental domestic worker rights--and think more about whether or not Hand in Hand actually does this. It is true that Hand in Hand is run by employers, which would make sense for a domestic employers network. It is also true that employers, themselves, experience discrimination and oppression as most, for example, are seniors or differently-abled. However, I would argue that "those most affected" are the employees themselves. If they have workshops on "best employment practices," I'm curious as to why employers--not employees--run these workshops. I'm curious as to why there is not an equal ratio of employees at the monthly meetings as there are employers. I would think that employers would be better informed if there was input from workers, those who experience the most disenfranchisement in this issue.
My supervisor is very open, so I'm hoping to have a discussion with her to learn more about their intentions and reasons for operating the way they do. For example, I would want to know why Hand in Hand doesn't exist as a branch or team within a domestic workers coalition, but as a separate entity. How do they calculate the efficacy of their work by being run by employers? Things for me to think about.
Especially considering the pieces by Bierra, Mananzala and Spade, they really speak about centering social justice work around those that are most affected by the issue to which the organizations are addressing. After reading these articles, and as I noted in my Response #2 paper, this really made me think about the effectiveness of Hand in Hand. Again, this organization is a domestic employers network, which means that they have taken on approaching the employer side of the domestic workers' rights movement. The organization, itself, I believe has great values and are very intentional in the ways they educate and inform employers of fair employment practices, such as providing workshops and free resources. However, referring back to Laura, I, too, was frustrated trying to find my place in the organization, as I am neither an employer nor an employee of domestic work. And I, too, believe Hand in Hand tries to be a grassroots organization.
But I want to think more about re-centering their work, "center those most affected" by the absence of fundamental domestic worker rights--and think more about whether or not Hand in Hand actually does this. It is true that Hand in Hand is run by employers, which would make sense for a domestic employers network. It is also true that employers, themselves, experience discrimination and oppression as most, for example, are seniors or differently-abled. However, I would argue that "those most affected" are the employees themselves. If they have workshops on "best employment practices," I'm curious as to why employers--not employees--run these workshops. I'm curious as to why there is not an equal ratio of employees at the monthly meetings as there are employers. I would think that employers would be better informed if there was input from workers, those who experience the most disenfranchisement in this issue.
My supervisor is very open, so I'm hoping to have a discussion with her to learn more about their intentions and reasons for operating the way they do. For example, I would want to know why Hand in Hand doesn't exist as a branch or team within a domestic workers coalition, but as a separate entity. How do they calculate the efficacy of their work by being run by employers? Things for me to think about.
Blog 4
I am back tracking a little and going to explain my job at Girls Inc., I do several different things at this organization. The biggest task that I have is helping out the program that is set up for after school. So that the girls have something to do after school is out. Girls Inc. Serves several different schools that have families of low income and have little access to extra help and services. Girls Inc. after school program is charge free and it's a great program. Their main focus is on literacy, this is where I come in and help. First, I play with the girls outside on the yard with that comes conflict resolution. There are times when we are playing a game and the girls end up fighting over the rules, this is when I step in and help the calm down and get down to the answer. I also help them do their homework, I never do it for them but I guide them so that they feel accomplished and so that they understand what they are doing. I also help set up the activities that we do. Because literacy is their focus they have activities around that. The teachers create games that have them use grammar and word spelling. I always help the teacher set those activities up for them. I also help the volunteer coordinator at a different site. I help her with training for new volunteers. I help her set up, share my experience, and keep her on track when she is talking by moving the slides along with her talk.
In the reading by Bickford and Reynolds, they discuss that most students do service work or volunteer but they would not do activism. It makes me think, is what I am doing more volunteer or is there some activist involved in what I am doing. I have always “helped out” or did volunteer, but I can't say there was much activism involved in what I did. In reading it is mentioned that the students who were tutoring students, needed to get to know the students that they were helping, not just observing them. What I like about my internship is that, even though there is difference between the community that I work with and myself. I go into the program every day that I go and immerse myself with the girls. I get to participate in this area of their lives and help them grow and learn. The reading also talks about looking at the structures arounds us. Not sure that this applies, but to looking at the structures. However, when I was at the school we were sitting in the library and I noticed that there were not that many books offered to the children and it made me think. Is it possible that they don't get enough funding from the government to help supply children with a well stocked library? What else are the children not receiving and does it all connected to funding and the government and if so why is it happening?
Blog 4, I think.
Hello. I haven’t been to my internship in a long time. Since
March 22nd, so I feel kind of out of the loop. I’m going in today,
so I hope to have a conversation with my supervisor about my concerns with the
work. She has mentioned working with a project (?) that aims to provide for
government aid to people with disabilities in San Francisco, so maybe there
will be something I can do with that. Even knowing that program exists doesn’t
really quell my concerns though because all of the people I’ve met with disabilities
live in the East Bay, not San Francisco, so that just emphasizes how little
that will encompass and how many people would be left behind.
I also met with Kevin again to review his testimonial. When
I initially met with him I read the questions, and typed his replies verbatim.
From there, I organized his thoughts into a more concise piece and my
supervisor went over them again. This meeting was so I could read the version
made from his original replies for approval, and he was fine with it. At the
end of the meeting, I also asked if he would be comfortable being recorded his
testimonial. That way even when he can’t attend events in support of the bill,
literally his own voice would still be heard. He was fine with the idea, but he
said he would only do it if someone else were there to revoice his words and if
there were captions. Kevin has a speech disability, so it’s sometimes difficult
to understand him. He wanted to make sure that people with hearing loss or
disabilities would still be able to understand him. Captions alone wouldn’t be
enough because some people can’t or have trouble seeing.
Lately I’ve been thinking a lot about professionalism. With
Hand in Hand, I was immediately given a lot of hands on (no pun intended) work.
Lindsay, my supervisor, had me working with people with disabilities with
virtually no training. When I met with Kevin initially, Lindsay didn’t even
know what types of disabilities he had, so I just had to wing it. I wonder what
her reasoning was for my responsibilities. For instance, Chelsea is also
interning at HiH and while I have a car and that makes getting places easier,
Chelsea is much friendlier and more personable than I am. She seems like the
more obvious choice for outreach and meeting with people, but I was sent instead.
As the Bierra piece addressed in the CARA situation, the founders of CARA were
discounted for being young women of color. The founders of the other
organizations who advocated for a separation between clients/ providers of
services and had an overwhelmingly white staff were considered more
professional. I’m the opposite of many of the employers I’ve been in contact
with because I’m white, able, cis, and have my own form of transportation. I
wonder if I was given these responsibilities because I am, in many ways,
opposite from the people we are representing. Am I more equipped to do the work
I was given, was it just luck of the draw, or am I an image of professionalism?
Thursday, April 7, 2016
Fourth Blog Entry
I did not go to my
internship site this week, I was (and still am) sick with a cold, and so I am
doing a lot of self-care, just resting and eating a lot. Our last class (April
1st) got me thinking about the conversation I had with my supervisor about the
NGOs that the HRC fund. As a government agency, HRC gets its funding from the
city and county of SF; that is through tax revenues. It was interesting to
learn how they prioritize to whom they give grants and how the Mayor allocates
funds for each government agency. As we read the Bierria piece, just like how
CARA had to apply for the RFP to be funded, the HRC follows the same protocol.
They publish the RFP and solicit applications from NGOs. They decide to whom to
award the grant based on the NGO that somehow fits into their scope of work and
will meet their demands and further report back to them the outcomes and how
the grant was used.
And so I am thinking,
this is a state initiative, what do they (HRC) want from the organization they
are currently funding and how do they measure impact? What do these NGO’s have
to compromise to receive this money from the HRC? Currently, the HRC has given
grants to five different NGOs who provide health services, education, and
sensitivity training, mostly to transgender people. I then realized that they may choose to fund
organizations such as social service providers as opposed to radical policy
advocate collectives/ NGOs. My supervisor’s mention of the Mayor’s priorities
when allocating funds and preparing the budget for government agencies reminded
me of one of our class discussions regarding how state funding is often
neoliberal-driven. He said, should there be budget cuts, funds for social
justice, i.e., LGBTI will be the first to be reduced, and the police force,
transit, and other sectors will take priority – neoliberal framework rather
contributes to entities that generate more income and “safety.”
One last thing that is still
lingering in my mind is the question of how we, as scholars and activists we
can critique the NPIC while working within it. It makes me question my
implications. I am for and about social justice, but the thought of making a
career out of doing the work that I love is not far-fetched… so as we are
finding ways of dismantling the NPIC culture, I suppose we should also look
within ourselves – how are we both perpetuating while against it.
Friday, April 1, 2016
Blog 4: Reflections on CCWP's commitment to those most affected by the PIC
Blog 4: Reflections on CCWP's commitment to those most affected by the PIC:
After being with CCWP for the last few months and reading the articles from the last few weeks, I have really seen the ways CCWP lives what it means to be grassroots. A few weeks ago I attended an all day volunteer retreat meeting and it allowed time for many of the long time volunteers to present the projects that they work on. I was the only new volunteer, so it was a really good way for me to see all the projects that people work on. Because CCWP's consistent membership is scattered, being in the office every week hasn't allowed me to fully understand all the different aspects that volunteers work on.
I have heard about many names and projects but haven't met everyone, unless they attended the monthly volunteer meeting that happens once a month. I was taken back by how broad the work is. One of the members at the meeting stated that she wished meeting like this all day retreat happened more often, because she too, like me, did not fully know or understand the aspects and projects that many people work on. My frustrations in the beginning and feeling like I wasn't sure where I could help have now made me see that what makes CCWP so special is that they truly are grassroots and try to center those most affected by the PIC in everything they do. There is no centralization, no Executive Director, or no hierarchy. It's many people coming together to work on individual aspects they find most important under the name and work of CCWP.
A particular project I am going to get more involved in is A Living Chance project which features stories of women living in institutions with LWOP sentences (life without parole) A local artist who started volunteering with CCWP started this project many years ago and now it is on exhibit at The Yerba Buena Center for the Arts. I am going to help getting the word out about the project so that the artist can get ore interest in funding. Along with her full time work she has dedicated many hours to bringing a voice to women who have been forgotten about in society. She is now looking for grants so that she can increase the budget for her project and actually hire people to work alongside her. This is an example of what CCWP is and does. When doing the readings for this week, I noted many times where the authors noted what true grassroots organizing is and how to stay centered in those movements. The decentralization can be frustrating at times, especially for new volunteers. I have worked on a varied amount of tasks and have learned a lot about the organizations. But the past few weeks I have been feeling a little lost, like the skills I have and the time I have been spending there, still isn't doing much. I know I am contributing and helping, I just think being surrounded by so many people with so many skills and so much knowledge in community organizing, is making me feel like I have so much to learn. I am glad it is not a large, structured organization with a hierarchy and they have just taken me on to get specific tasks done.
After being with CCWP for the last few months and reading the articles from the last few weeks, I have really seen the ways CCWP lives what it means to be grassroots. A few weeks ago I attended an all day volunteer retreat meeting and it allowed time for many of the long time volunteers to present the projects that they work on. I was the only new volunteer, so it was a really good way for me to see all the projects that people work on. Because CCWP's consistent membership is scattered, being in the office every week hasn't allowed me to fully understand all the different aspects that volunteers work on.
I have heard about many names and projects but haven't met everyone, unless they attended the monthly volunteer meeting that happens once a month. I was taken back by how broad the work is. One of the members at the meeting stated that she wished meeting like this all day retreat happened more often, because she too, like me, did not fully know or understand the aspects and projects that many people work on. My frustrations in the beginning and feeling like I wasn't sure where I could help have now made me see that what makes CCWP so special is that they truly are grassroots and try to center those most affected by the PIC in everything they do. There is no centralization, no Executive Director, or no hierarchy. It's many people coming together to work on individual aspects they find most important under the name and work of CCWP.
A particular project I am going to get more involved in is A Living Chance project which features stories of women living in institutions with LWOP sentences (life without parole) A local artist who started volunteering with CCWP started this project many years ago and now it is on exhibit at The Yerba Buena Center for the Arts. I am going to help getting the word out about the project so that the artist can get ore interest in funding. Along with her full time work she has dedicated many hours to bringing a voice to women who have been forgotten about in society. She is now looking for grants so that she can increase the budget for her project and actually hire people to work alongside her. This is an example of what CCWP is and does. When doing the readings for this week, I noted many times where the authors noted what true grassroots organizing is and how to stay centered in those movements. The decentralization can be frustrating at times, especially for new volunteers. I have worked on a varied amount of tasks and have learned a lot about the organizations. But the past few weeks I have been feeling a little lost, like the skills I have and the time I have been spending there, still isn't doing much. I know I am contributing and helping, I just think being surrounded by so many people with so many skills and so much knowledge in community organizing, is making me feel like I have so much to learn. I am glad it is not a large, structured organization with a hierarchy and they have just taken me on to get specific tasks done.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)