“The auditorium felt silent” (Clay, 385) Judy Grahn “joked” about race with Pat Parker. Clay and others were puzzled whether to laugh or not.. That silence is intriguing, it got me think about the WGS spaces I’ve navigated over the last few semesters, non-profits I’ve volunteered for, and even at my internship site. I should only speak for myself, so I guess what i am trying to say is- more the critical consciousness developed in me, more silent and more disconnected I want to become. To be politically correct is one thing, but to demand others to be politically correct is another thing. At my intern, during one of the training program, everyone was introducing one’s self. Some people shared that they have two names, one in English and one that was given to them by their parents. I used to go by Emma then about three years ago I regained Enkhmaa. It was due to how I ended up with Emma-story goes-when I was 16, at my first job in the states-my boss could not pronounce my name-so he rushed me to come up with a nick name. For eleven years, I’ve gone by Emma until one day- I realized that I was stuck with Emma because of someone’s ignorance. Gaining Enkhmaa back was a long process, only now if I could make my father to call me Enkhmaa, not Emma. I yell out,Enkhmaa!!! I explained to him why it is important to me to be called by my name but he said, “it is just a name!” I said, “IT’S VERY POLITICAL!” Anyways, during the training program, I shared this transition. Then I felt awful end of the day, I kept thinking to myself-( what if I offended somebody! I shouldn’t have shared that story! ) I hope it makes sense.
I am often urge to remind the trainees to think about the power-dynamics created between them and the residents, acknowledge that these dynamics are created regardless-therefore volunteers and staffs could work towards to minimize these dynamics. However, when I share this concern with the trainees, they seem to not get me. I often think afterwards that I shouldn’t have. So, I stopped expressing this concern. There are not much going on with my internship right now, my super is out of town until the first of May.
Friday, April 29, 2016
Personal Politics Aligning with the Workplace
One
issue looking back about my internship was how I noticed the people didn't hold
themselves accountable for what they said being aligned with their work and
values around anti-bullying. This is an anti-bullying non-profit and yet I
found ways that I didn't like what they had expressed and found it to be
uncomfortable with what they are working towards. It makes me think of how if
you're not in social justice work for the right reasons then the difficulties
of it like securing funding can bring out the negativity in people.
There
were three main people that I worked around for my internship duration, and all
three of them at various points said things that I thought were inappropriate
and constituted forms of bullying themselves. One was when my supervisor was
when my supervisor lady was going off at me about a woman she had thought was
rude to her but then in her talk about her was very degrading herself and
calling her a bitch. Another time was when one of the other ladies was talking
about her son who had been bullied, and if he were still getting bullied she
would want him to basically like push the kid back if he were doing that to her
son, and basically standing up for himself but through physical force if that's
what the bully were doing. A third time was when I was listening to a call the
founder was having with someone about the bad job someone else had done over
doing a newsletter or something like that. He was like "it's look like a
10-year-old wrote it." I was shocked that he would say that considering he
is someone who was bullied as a kid, and secondly because he is in the field of
supporting children and youth.
I feel like there was a real break between
what their work is supposed to be about and the values its upholding, versus the
principles and messages of their own actions and behavior. All of the behavior
was a form of bullying especially because it was kind of done in this manner of
being behind people's backs. I think the
reasoning for it is because of their neutral a-political standing. Because of
this therefore I don't think they have developed personal political praxes
around how they can be bullies themselves and how in such a discriminatory
culture we are always having to unlearn prejudice.
Blog #6
The last few weeks have been interesting at CCWP. As I mentioned before, most of my time in the last weeks I have been by myself. I have continued to respond to letters the best way that I can. This internship did not turn out as I had hoped but I think I have learned a lot within my time there, specifically that I am certain I want to remain active and involved. I have learned the limitations of non-profits and activism work and have a new understanding of how these structures work and try and survive within larger systems. That has been eye opening. Reflecting on what I hoped to gain from this experience and what I have learned, I understand that I was hoping to have "projects". To feel like I "was getting things done". I have realized that much of how CCWP connects with prisoners on the inside is through letter writing and that they are greatly under resourced when it comes to this task. In the beginning of my time at CCWP I was given a variety of tasks and then sort of fell into constant letter writing because my supervisor has not been there the same days as me. This is probably one of the few things I can do on my own without supervision. But I also realized that they need a lot of help in this area.
During the summer I am going to continue with CCWP, working with one of their members on a project regarding prisoners with LWOP (Life Without Parole) sentences as well as attending the monthly letter writing sessions. Even though the Internship did not turned out as I hoped, I am thankful I was able to connect with CCWP because I understand that the work they and other similar organizations do is extremely important in our society where far too many people are criminalized and then forgotten. Next weekend I am also going to attend a meeting next weekend that will discuss the ways people "on the outside" can advocate for people "on the inside" by learning to understand legislation and more in depth about prison laws and policies. Even though organizations like CCWP are working to fight against the Prison Industrial Complex, they can only do so by challenging the system within the system until more progress is made.
Recently I have been thinking a lot about the readings from last week in which they talked about how organizations grow. In order to survive, individuals and organizations are constantly negotiating between survival/needs and work that stays true to the heart of the individual and organization's mission and goals. I also have been reminded that what we hope something may be and look like always isn't the case. I wanted to get involved particularly with CCWP because they have a grassroots feel and their work is decentralized and non-hierarchical. What I found is that being in environments like that have made me uncomfortable and uneasy at times. Like I said before I want to have a project and see its completion, etc. But if I am to get involved and stay involved with work similar to the work CCWP does, it takes being committed long term and understanding that the results "I want" to see may never happen but continuing to move closer to those goals is what's most important.
During the summer I am going to continue with CCWP, working with one of their members on a project regarding prisoners with LWOP (Life Without Parole) sentences as well as attending the monthly letter writing sessions. Even though the Internship did not turned out as I hoped, I am thankful I was able to connect with CCWP because I understand that the work they and other similar organizations do is extremely important in our society where far too many people are criminalized and then forgotten. Next weekend I am also going to attend a meeting next weekend that will discuss the ways people "on the outside" can advocate for people "on the inside" by learning to understand legislation and more in depth about prison laws and policies. Even though organizations like CCWP are working to fight against the Prison Industrial Complex, they can only do so by challenging the system within the system until more progress is made.
Recently I have been thinking a lot about the readings from last week in which they talked about how organizations grow. In order to survive, individuals and organizations are constantly negotiating between survival/needs and work that stays true to the heart of the individual and organization's mission and goals. I also have been reminded that what we hope something may be and look like always isn't the case. I wanted to get involved particularly with CCWP because they have a grassroots feel and their work is decentralized and non-hierarchical. What I found is that being in environments like that have made me uncomfortable and uneasy at times. Like I said before I want to have a project and see its completion, etc. But if I am to get involved and stay involved with work similar to the work CCWP does, it takes being committed long term and understanding that the results "I want" to see may never happen but continuing to move closer to those goals is what's most important.
No way out of the NPIC
On my last day working at Women and Girls Lead Global
(WGLG), I mailed myself everything I had written/researched/proofread during my
time there. I had been maintaining weekly folders of my work and, as I was
going through them one by one I realized I hadn’t been able to do the things
that I had been most excited about. On my first day there my supervisor had
expressed interest in having me watch films and develop discussion guides for
them and I was really looking forward to working on them. Not only are discussion
guides central to facilitated community conversations that are at the heart of
WGLG’s core work, they would have allowed me to bring together feminist film
critique and praxis. From whatever little I have seen, the guides already do a
fairly good job at arriving at critical and thoughtful discussion questions
that try to unravel the structural reasons behind the issues addressed in the
film. The discussion guides offer a flexible
and open-ended map for facilitators to talk about the films. They are framed in
a way that offers the facilitators multiple starting points for a conversation
about the film while leaving room for them to weave in the specific local
context in which the films are being screened. In other words, they are the
backbone of a program with the potential to do consciousness-raising work while
negotiating the trappings of international funding and behavior change jargon. Needless
to say, I was excited about the opportunity to do this work. And yet as I went
through my work folders I found just one unfinished document with discussion
questions about two short films. Throughout the weeks every time I started work
on the discussion guide something else, something more urgent came along. The
fact that I was asked to watch the films I was supposed to write the guides for,
always at the end of work days, says something about how important or
unimportant this work seemed to be for my supervisor. To be fair though these
films weren’t part of their core curriculum yet. They were short films in
Bangla commissioned by WGLG. In any case, other things like writing blogs about
WGLG’s activities, doing research about monitoring and evaluation tools,
developing and translating surveys etc were prioritized because they were all
about proving the usefulness of WGLG’s work. In her piece, Ford-Smith writes
about how international funding diluted the focus of Sistrens work. I think all
this while I imagined that only small grass roots organizations would suffer
from the impact of these demands. But as I look back, the amount of time I
spent working on various things that in their own way measure the efficacy of
WGLG’s work, I realize that even in a well funded organization like Independent
Television Service project based funding derails the core of their work. It
seems like if you’re working in a non-profit there is no way out of these
demands, regardless of the size of the organization, diversity of funding or
mission. This then is what it feels like to work in the NPIC, there is no way
out. But I hope that there are small ways to subvert this paradigm. I still
feel dissatisfied with my own work at WGLG, I wish I had more time to work on
the discussion guides, I wish I had spent less time doing monitoring and
evaluation research. But I really hope that the fact that I was doing all the
impact evaluation related work meant that my supervisor was able to do
something more useful.
6th (intergenerational organizing)
The Andreana Clay piece from last week made me think a lot about the importance of intergenerational organizing. It really made me wonder what it would look like to have this type of organizing take place on the ground. A lot of my time at HOMEY has been spent mentoring high-risk youth on how to become the next generation of leaders and organizers in their communities. Successful or not, I think that at the very least, HOMEY does a good job at planting these seeds. In reflecting on my own experiences, however, I feel like I've never really had the kind of activist mentors that I think is needed to bridge this intergenerational divide that Clay talks about. In fact, a lot of the the older activists that I've had direct contact with have usually gone on and on about how younger activists don't exist anymore. They see the younger generation as either apolitical or too concerned with things that distract us from doing social justice work. In these moments, what I think they mean to say is that our models for social change looks different because of the way social institutions have changed over time. Even in those moments when older activists preach about "handing the torch over to us," they say it in a way that distances themselves from younger activists. In other words, they are giving us the permission to do this work, but aren't willing to do this work with us.
Blog Entry 6
Hello everyone, in my last post I talked about how power is organized in Galería and I’ve learned a little bit more about this since then. A couple of weeks ago, I was able to sit in on one of the meetings the staff regularly has to check in on projects, issues that might need addressing, etc. At one point, our director mentioned speaking with the Board of Directors about upcoming projects, and one of the staff members asked if it was possible to set up a meeting with them to also discuss the project. The staff member added that they had not met all the people on the Board of Directors personally, and the other staff also mentioned they aren’t even sure who is on the Board of Directors. This was a bit of surprise for me because I was under the impression the staff worked more closely with the Board. Interestingly, the Board member everyone (including myself) has met and spoken with is the one Board member who consistently attends opening receptions or other events. Learning all of this has changed the way I understand the power structure at Galería to be a bit more defined with the Board members at the top. I think the current relationship between the staff and the Board members has the possibility of being a point of conflict in the future, especially when the only person in regular contact with them is our Executive Director. We’ve addressed the various power structures in nonprofit organizations with articles like the Mananzala & Dean, Bierria and Ford-Smith articles, but it would have been interesting to read more about how staff can hold their Board of Directors accountable to their expectations. The Bernice Johnson Reagon article we read at the beginning of the semester acknowledged coalition building between different groups of people, but what happens when there’s a need for coalition building (however small it may be) within one group or organization? Is aligning different views and ideas for the purpose of a single cause within an organization considered coalition building?
I want to continue the reflection on what I have accomplished at my internship this semester. In terms of the goals I wanted to accomplish at Galería de la Raza, I think they were mainly centered on personal growth. I wanted to challenge myself in a space where I sometimes felt I did not have the skills or knowledge to be in. While the idea of achieving a certain personal goal through nonprofit work has been contested (Bickford and Reynolds), I also think there is no way working with a nonprofit will not result in achieving whatever personal goal you had, whether you acknowledged that goal or not. Personally, I always set myself a goal whenever I start a new semester, and that wasn’t any different this semester. Except my goal became connected to the work I was going to do at Galería, so it was interesting to see how my internship integrated with both my personal and academic life. But I don’t think working at Galería has necessarily changed something fundamental about me, that just isn’t what I think working with a nonprofit should do. I learned to appreciate and be critical of nonprofit work, and to be really critical of how state structure both allows nonprofits to exist and also pressures them into not existing in the way they should.
Thursday, April 28, 2016
Tiffany - April 15 post
From Tiffany:
The past couple of weeks at my site has been a challenge for me. A challenge in the sense, that I have been doing task that are not what I am used too. The past couple weeks the youth in our program have been on spring break (week of the 14th and 21st of March). And during that time I was assigned task like answering phones, reading through case file and separating them by clients needs, such as clothing, food, and social services needs. I enjoyed doing these different task, because it gave me a whole new outlook on the center, I was more hands on with things instead of just being stuck up stairs.
When doing these task I was able to get a closer look and feel of how things are really ran and organized and honestly would not mind doing the admin stuff. When doing the admin task and other things of that nature, staff members were able to see my organization skills and they appreciated it, because I was able to start a few new filling systems that really helped in organizing client fills and information. Doing the admin work for those couple days brought me into the inner workings of my site and how things get funded for clients and how they clients are prioritized.
When the kids came back the week of the 28th, it was a little hectic because none of them had any homework since it was the start of a new quarter and being they just returned from spring break. This week the other volunteers and I wished that these middle school teachers were like college professors and gave homework over vacations, so they would have something to do. The kids were all hyped up and it was so hard to get a control of them, the boys mostly. I was getting so annoyed with how they were acting (hitting each other, throwing ping pong balls), I was racking my brain to think of things for them to do and so were the other adults. We found ourselves walking away from certain situations when we found ourselves getting frustrated with the non-listening and talking back, we also asked someone else to step in when getting to this point. I came up with just sending them outside with the male employee who oversees the youth program to play basketball. And that worked for a short amount of time, they back in complaining that they were "bored." If anyone has ideas for keeping middle school boys busy please fill me in.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)