Friday, March 4, 2016

New desk and more tasks

Hi all, 
It was an interesting past couple of weeks at my internship. There had been some rumors going around about moving offices (switching offices with another program) to have more space for clients. The move finally happened last Friday, accompanied by a fresh coat of paint which I suggested should be a light blue for a soothing effect. The walls are now painted light blue and I also officially have a space of my own! The program manager ordered me a nice little desk and a comfortable swivel chair which replaced my musical chair like use of everyone else’s desks (while they were at court or left the office early.)
Anyway, work wise I have been feeling great about the new tasks I have been assigned. Instead  of doing hours long research, I am conducting more face to face interactions with various clients as we prepare them for their individual merits hearing. Last week, I began drafting declarations for three different women from two different Central American countries. This has been an equal parts difficult, equal parts rewarding experience for me as I learn the unique histories of similarly aged women. Beginning with their childhood, I inquire about type of home they grew up in, the size of their families, the type of work they did, etc. All three women were unable to complete 6th grade due to the high cost of education in their home country. Besides  tuition costs, came in the required uniforms, supplies, books, and other miscellaneous that piled up for families who had up to 12 children. Two of the tree women did not complete the first grade as they were required to work in coffee plantations or in the markets selling tortillas or goods that their mothers had prepared. Factors that pushed their migration include a combination of violence against themselves or their close family members. 
This violence and the trauma it carries has concerned me from the moment I began learning about the years of normalized violence the client’s experienced throughout their lives. The particular attorney whom I am currently working with is also aware of the needs of our clients besides the legal service that our program provides. As a part of the team that is currently working on these cases, I have taken on the job of providing these clients and their families with resources to free or affordable counseling or psychotherapy. Both their immigration and mono linguist status place barriers to their access to quality behavioral health, preventing them from being able to fully cope with not just their past experiences but also the long and painful process that is being in immigration proceedings.  
I believe that a partnership between legal services providers and mental health service providers is absolutely necessary when dealing with clients whose traumatic histories are inquired for their immigration proceedings. I thought of the thousands that are undergoing these types of procedures, often paying tens of thousands of dollars to private attorneys that take little to interest in the well being of their clients. The readings made me think of "volunteering while working" and the hours that the attorneys of my office work. I have observed the difficulties they face in trying to provide services to the large population that is in desperate need of the legal help, but are unable to due to the constrains of city and privately funded grants. Nonetheless, those who do end up receiving services from the program, are met with full, often unpaid dedication of attorneys and volunteers alike. 

Second Blog



On February 17th, my supervisor and I attended a parents meeting at St. Ignatius College Preparatory High School. The Human Rights Commission received an invitation from the African American and Latino Parents Association (AALPA) following the race-themed “wigger” party which 14 white students who were part of it were suspended. The party took place at Stern Grove Park. A wigger party defined as “a slang term combining white and the n-word, it refers to a white person who adopts mannerisms and clothing seen as racially stereotyping of African Americans” (CSB news). HRC was invited to observe if it can intervene following the wigger party after several calls from the parents to close Stone Grove Park after 10 pm to avoid more racialized parties like this or any other race-related incidents. The meeting opened with a video of the school’s assembly where the student president and the leader of the Black Student Union shared their thoughts about the incident, a possible way forward. The girl from the Black Student Union emphasized on love as resistance. While the student president touched on how she is making it her mission to start conversations that will make white people aware of their privileges. Is it the responsibility of black people to educate white people about racism and white privilege? The school’s principal, Patrick Ruff also delivered a keynote acknowledging that racial issues are not something new in the school, and they are trying different avenues to address these problems. He mentioned how the school had started conversations about diversity, love and respect for differences. 

The floor was then opened for discussion, for parents to share their thoughts and views, and these were parents of color sharing how their children were affected by the incident, noting how there is more that needs to be done by the school to balance the racial ratio. So, now the question is, can HRC be of any assistance in this matter? Can the Commission propose laws and possibly a policy that bans people from being at Stone Grove after 10 pm? Can the government make these changes? After the meeting, I had a fascinating conversation with my supervisor on the relationship between law and practice, the question of laws not always translating into practice. I asked her how will the law/ policy stop these parties from happening? If they are not happening at Stern Grove, I am pretty sure they are happening elsewhere. Also, for e.g.: people can file claims with the HRC if they feel they are discriminated based on their race, but to what extent can a person prove that they did not get a job because of their race?  It is the same constitutional protection awarded by the South African government, protecting its citizens from discrimination on race, gender, sexual orientation, etc., but hate crimes are spiraling out of control, and the government is complicit. So, to what extent can we say policies are effective? To who do they apply to? Who do they protect or seek to serve? I am hoping by the end of my time at HRC I will be able to answer some of these questions.

Thursday, March 3, 2016

Blog 2


           
            Hello, 698 friends. I'm looking forward to seeing you all again! A few questions were asked in my last blog post, so I’ll start with answering those. Not all of the people involved in our organization are disabled, but I’ve specifically been assigned to work with people who are disabled. While I outreach to everyone for testimonials, the people I’m assisting are people who cannot record their testimonials without assistance. I’m contacting certain people within the member’s database who volunteered to do a testimonial. So, I’m in contact with the same people, but a lot of people. I’m only directly working with my supervisor and Lindsay, so HiH feels really small. Our office is located in downtown Oakland, but I’ve gone to a few different locations to meet with people because I have a car.
            I didn’t go to my internship at all last week because I was out of town on Friday, and Fridays are when my supervisor is in office. A large portion of my responsibilities for my internship has been phone banking, which has only declined the longer I did it. Hand in Hand has a few events coming up, so we were phone banking with members of the HiH database to raise awareness and gauge attendance. I feel like at least half the people I called went to voicemail, exactly four people were nice to me, and the rest were not nice when I called. Phone banking was tedious and more time-consuming than I initially thought it would be, and after my first thirty phone calls I wanted to stop. So many people, who had signed up as support for HiH or had helped in the past, were so rude on the phone and I have no idea why? I wanted to shout at them that 1. I am a person, 2. I am a volunteer at a non-profit they support, not a telemarketer, and 3. I’m just a volunteer! It was just a very frustrating experience for me. Demeaning. These aren’t cold calls, you know?
            Aside from phone banking, I’ve been following up with people for testimonials via email. I think I might’ve just been experiencing beginner’s luck … at the beginning because no one is emailing me back! I don’t want to be aggressive or pushy, but there are some people that I was in regular contact with, and then out of nowhere they stopped replying to me. I don’t know if I am doing something or if people are busy but I’m not feeling great.
            Tomorrow we’re having an actual event, and I was unable to attend any of the planning sessions. There was one I could have attended, but my dog had surgery last week and I’m nervous about leaving her at home (even though she seems to be fine). But, also, I didn’t want to travel from San Leandro (East Bay) to 24th Street for a two-hour meeting. It’s not a lot of money to get there, but it is money and I’m unemployed right now. I’ve been spending a bit on gas and public transportation, and people have told me I should ask for reimbursement but I’m nervous and I don’t know how. So, for the moment, I’m just kind of sitting on my hands.

Monday, February 29, 2016

Blog 2: Oh, the joys of stream-of-consciousness writing

Since the first week, I’ve come to realize I feel a little inadequate. Is anyone else feeling similarly? I feel that the skills I have to offer don’t really translate over. For example, I’ve gained skills in rape crisis counseling and organizing activities or creating websites, but I haven’t found these skills to be necessarily beneficial for Hand in Hand’s mission. As a result, I feel that I’m doing busy work that yes, allows me to learn more about the organization itself but simultaneously restricts my capacity to be an effective agent to their cause. Does that make sense at all?

Despite my insecurities, I am learning more about how non-profits function and the struggles that come with passing legislation. I think the concept of “ally” has troubled me a bit. In the same way that Millenials believe that re-posting a recycled “feminist” picture on Facebook makes them a “feminist,” I’ve noticed that many of those who identify as “allies” to the organization think that the identification alone is sufficient support. Even though they say they are allies, many refuse to actually be active about their supposed support, like attending the campaign rallies, going to workshops to learn more about the many facets of the organization—or, at the least, listing themselves publicly as supporters to the cause in order to push legislation. I think in order to render oneself an ally, there should be a requirement of active support. But it seems that simply identifying as an “ally” is sufficient support to many, and perhaps it gives good “feels” because they allegedly believe in the mission of the organization.

As I wrote that second paragraph, I realized how ableist I sounded, as many of those that are allies are actually differently-abled seniors. I’m going to keep that paragraph there as a reminder for me to check myself, especially in my conceptualization of “active support.” What constitutes as “active” considering physical restrictions? It actually makes me think about ways in which I can assist with digitizing the workshops for those who can’t physically make it out to the offices, or something to that effect for other ways to get involved. Friday will be the organization’s campaign launch, and perhaps I can propose to do more things surrounding digitization and taking advantage of the ever-growing power of social media coverage.

Thanks for taking part in my stream of consciousness and self-realizations. I hope to continue learning...your thoughts and opinions are appreciated.

Added edit: I've realized, after putting more analysis into the assigned readings, that my experience has to do with direct service versus activism, as differentiated by Bickford and Reynolds. I suppose this is what has made me uncomfortable: my inexperience with being able to lead my own workshops, for example, regarding how to be effective activists when dismantling certain attitudes of domestic work and lobbying for adequate recognition. I guess this discomfort and fear of the unknown is what drew me to this particular internship in the first place. I can already feel my insecurities lifting a bit, cheers! to uncomfortable realizations.

Saturday, February 27, 2016

Blog entry #2

I've really been enjoying my internship at Dress For Success so far. I've learned a lot my past few weeks there, and have had my fair share of small injuries like dropping a laptop on me, and I'm still recovering from that one. I've gotten to know the organization pretty well, and have done multiple things that both interest me and is fulfilling. My first couple of weeks there, I got to know the back room pretty well, My tasks included organizing the clothes, sorting through the inventory and donations, and cleaning up the dressing area. The organization also holds weekly donation drives so sometimes when there are a shortage of volunteers, I go down to the street and pick up the donations, give the tax receipts out, and take everything back up to the office suite. It does get pretty hectic at times, a lot of donations can come through at one time or multiple clients may be there at one time, it varies a lot. Sometimes, clients don't show up at all and miss their opportunity for a free outfit that could really help them while they are actively seeking work.
 Reagon's piece about coalition politics is very relatable as I'm going through this internship. She says, "It must become necessary for all of us to feel that this is our world," (365). This makes me think of my time at Dress for Success so far; I've had two clients that I've had to "personal shop" for. A personal shopper is usually a volunteer, and their duty is to pick the outfits for the clients to try on, as well as the shoes, accessories and purse. Both of the clients I had said "I feel like a million bucks!" after their appointment, and it was such an overwhelming feeling of happiness I felt to see such happiness in these women. No matter what circumstances we are under, there is always a silver lining somewhere, and it felt so great to have been able to make someone feel like a million bucks. That's the thought I had as I read Reagon's article. It's not fulfillment that should define coalition work, but the awareness, the consciousness, the knowing that THIS is worthwhile to individuals lives because we all belong here, and we all deserve the opportunity to make our world as big as we can.
After reading Bickford and Reynolds article Activism and Learning: Volunteerism as Acts of Dissent, their take on students writing journal entries and reflecting about their experiences does make one
 question deeper as to Why are we doing this? The opportunity to expand our critical consciousness
and contribute to social change are more than just the experiences, but reflecting on those experiences. A part that stuck out to me in their essay, was their focus on the goals of consciousness raising (CR), saying, "CR's goals extended beyond shared experiences; its force lay in uncovering and analyzing structures of oppression so that effective action for change could occur," (240). Crucial change doesn't happen over night, and as the authors also say, "activism is a process". It is imperative to analyze EVERYTHING around why activism is so vital. How boundaries, and politics of space play a part; who is in control and who is being controlled? Questions answered, raising consciousness and creating social change.

Friday, February 26, 2016

Between negotiation and resistance- a vision of women's agency




Over the past few weeks I got more deeply involved in the work that Women and Girls Lead Global (WGLG) is doing. I edited and re-wrote a number of blogs about the activities of their community engagement partners in Bangladesh and Jordan. I finally had the opportunity of watching one of the films they’ve been using in their community screenings, mostly because I was proofreading the discussion guide for that film. Discussion guides are an important part of the film-based curriculum for community engagement that WGLG uses. They are developed in conversation with their local partners and I was surprised at the vision of agency one of them proposes. The discussion guide in question was for a documentary about girls’ education in Casablanca, where the state has trained women to work as Morchidat (official Islamic spiritual guides). Their mandate is to offer guidance around living an “ethical” and compassionate life while supporting the state’s efforts to encourage girl’s education and tackling domestic violence. The Morchidat seem to draw their credibility not just from their official training but from their gendered position, as motherly advisers, or as women who seem to have some special access to spirituality and compassion by virtue of being women. They seem to promote girl’s education, often in marginalized communities, while working within the logic of gendered norms. For instance, they argue that fathers should commit to educating their daughters because being caring by nature (by virtue of being girls) they will continue to support their families once they start working. The discussion guide recognizes this move as a strategic decision and prompts the facilitator to ask the community audience in Jordan about strategies they have used to convince their families about girl’s education.


The film as well as the discussion guide can be read as a reinforcement of problematic patriarchal norms. Where girls should get educated because they will take care of their families, because they are caring or nice etc. They can be critiqued for positioning the Morchidat as empowered women “saving” girls while completely overlooking the privileged class position they occupy. The discussion guide can be faulted for working on an assumption that a film made in the context of Casablanca would automatically be relevant to communities in Jordan because of a “religious” connection. Even as I have many critiques about the film and the discussion guide I am still interested in the complicated vision of women’s agency they offer, where agential action is not always tied to explicit resistance, where it can mean a negotiation with structures of power. In fact, agential action by women can emerge even in the act of re-enforcing norms.

In the end, I am still trying to understand what it means for WGLG to support and screen a film that explicitly positions itself as tied to a "tolerant/compassionate" vision of Islam.Tolerant/compassionate in opposition to what?  I wonder if WGLG would ever support a film critical of the impact of US foreign policy on women's lives across the world.  
    

Age and Technology at TGIJP (Blog Post #2)

As I detailed in my first post, I felt that there were very little skills I would be able to offer the veteran activists and organizers at the TGI Justice Project. But these past two weeks have given me the opportunity to learn many new skills as well as share my own skills with the staff. Particularly, I am very involved in helping develop the technological skills of the team.
Although the tasks I complete while I am at TGIJP range, many of my tasks consist of computer work. I send outreach e-mails, enter information on our database, help update the website, upload pictures online, produce manuals, and edit/reformat many of the materials we prepare for trans women inside prisons. I focus on these tasks because according to Janetta, the executive director, I am one of the few activists on the team that began organizing when e-mailing and online work was necessary. Before, according to her, technology was important but not necessary. Now she feels that without advanced technological skills, it is extremely difficult for collectives to function. So, rather than purely completing these tasks for the organization, I write manuals/instructions on how to complete these tasks. I send these instructions to the rest of the organization so that in the future everyone could complete these tasks.
There is a certain ageist mentality among organizers that there should be a clear division between "new" activists and "old" activists. New activists complain about how old activists are not up-to-date or that they're from a different generation; old activists complain about how new activists do not have the experiences they do and are thus less equipped to handle activist work. My time so far at the TGI Justice Project has reflected a collaboration between "new" and "old" where knowledge continues to transfer from generation to generation. We all acknowledge that we hold different experiences and knowledge. But rather than see that as an irreparable disjuncture, we try our best to learn from one another. My experience thus far has helped me unlearn ideas of age that claim that "old" people are inherently ignorant or unable to learn as quickly. Rather, I'm walking away from this internship with an understanding that younger and older activists have many things to learn and give.