Friday, March 4, 2016

Second Blog



On February 17th, my supervisor and I attended a parents meeting at St. Ignatius College Preparatory High School. The Human Rights Commission received an invitation from the African American and Latino Parents Association (AALPA) following the race-themed “wigger” party which 14 white students who were part of it were suspended. The party took place at Stern Grove Park. A wigger party defined as “a slang term combining white and the n-word, it refers to a white person who adopts mannerisms and clothing seen as racially stereotyping of African Americans” (CSB news). HRC was invited to observe if it can intervene following the wigger party after several calls from the parents to close Stone Grove Park after 10 pm to avoid more racialized parties like this or any other race-related incidents. The meeting opened with a video of the school’s assembly where the student president and the leader of the Black Student Union shared their thoughts about the incident, a possible way forward. The girl from the Black Student Union emphasized on love as resistance. While the student president touched on how she is making it her mission to start conversations that will make white people aware of their privileges. Is it the responsibility of black people to educate white people about racism and white privilege? The school’s principal, Patrick Ruff also delivered a keynote acknowledging that racial issues are not something new in the school, and they are trying different avenues to address these problems. He mentioned how the school had started conversations about diversity, love and respect for differences. 

The floor was then opened for discussion, for parents to share their thoughts and views, and these were parents of color sharing how their children were affected by the incident, noting how there is more that needs to be done by the school to balance the racial ratio. So, now the question is, can HRC be of any assistance in this matter? Can the Commission propose laws and possibly a policy that bans people from being at Stone Grove after 10 pm? Can the government make these changes? After the meeting, I had a fascinating conversation with my supervisor on the relationship between law and practice, the question of laws not always translating into practice. I asked her how will the law/ policy stop these parties from happening? If they are not happening at Stern Grove, I am pretty sure they are happening elsewhere. Also, for e.g.: people can file claims with the HRC if they feel they are discriminated based on their race, but to what extent can a person prove that they did not get a job because of their race?  It is the same constitutional protection awarded by the South African government, protecting its citizens from discrimination on race, gender, sexual orientation, etc., but hate crimes are spiraling out of control, and the government is complicit. So, to what extent can we say policies are effective? To who do they apply to? Who do they protect or seek to serve? I am hoping by the end of my time at HRC I will be able to answer some of these questions.

1 comment:

  1. Hey Sam! Your post really brings out some questions I've been thinking about too. I'm usually on your side of the boat, in that the organizations I worked for in the past advocated mostly through policy and the criminal legal system. TGIJP is one of the first orgs I am working with that does not over rely on policy. But I oftentimes think about the ways in which both policy and abolitionist movements can work together, but that's a REALLY hard line to straddle. Because when you think about it, the above law about putting a curfew on Stern Grove will probably produce more violence. People are gonna be there past 10 PM anyway, and so the law would I think negatively impact a lot of people. But at the same time, I know of many laws that help people in feeling more protected. It's a really hard question you're asking, but I think there's place for legal advocacy within radical movements if it's done smartly. For example, I would be down for a law that gives trans prisoners rights to hormones, even if that means reform rather than abolition. As long as that decision is followed up with abolitionist efforts.

    ReplyDelete