Friday, February 19, 2016

Intro and First Week

I chose an internship at Hand in Hand: The Domestic Employers Network. Their purpose is to advocate for respectful and fair working conditions, which shows up as community outreach, lobbying, campaigning, etc. My understanding is that public policy protects laborers with the exception of domestic work, which would include those in housecleaning, home attendance, and nannying. This means that things that I’ve unknowingly taken for granted in my almost ten years of employment, like overtime pay and human resources protection, are not granted to domestic workers. I took this internship because it made me uncomfortable. I have naturally been drawn to work surrounding sexual trauma and youth outreach, so that is primarily where my knowledge lies. The fact is I know nothing about employment policies or how campaigning and lobbying works. Since majority of the employees I work with are undocumented women of color, and I had just recently written a paper about immigration detention centers as sites of the PIC, I was all the more interested in learning more.

My first week has been interesting. My first day was at a campaign meeting where they discussed HiH’s involvement in upcoming events and the domestic worker rights legislative campaign. It was cool to see their way of organizing, figuring out ways to move forward with domestic workers’ rights, both at the legislative level through lobbying and the community level through trainings. My tasks so far have not been super significant, as my supervisor wants me to learn more about the organization and essentially train a bit on what they do. My tasks have been things like meeting preparation (creating folder packets for upcoming meetings), taking down the agenda, data entry, and phone banking.

After the first week, I’d have to say I’m a little conflicted with what I’m a part of. While it is a great mission to fight for the rights of domestic workers, it troubles me to think that if the legislation gets passed that they have worked years to bring to fruition—that means agencies will both monitor employer compliance and enforce policy if they refuse to comply. What does “enforcement” look like? If the primary population of employees is undocumented, I keep telling myself that this compounds their risk of deportation. Considering my research on the increasing number of immigrant detainees as lucrative bodies for the prison industrial complex, it troubles me that already-vulnerable people are made even more vulnerable to detainment and eventual deportation.

The mission states that the network is “grounded in the conviction that dignified and respectful working conditions benefit worker and employer alike.” For some reason, a scenario keeps recurring in my head: if an employer refuses to comply, can’t they easily threaten their employee with deportation? So how would passing legislation “benefit worker and employer alike”? I feel that the PIC and deportation are the very things that have enabled employers of domestic workers to veil the very things that HiH is trying to fight against: unfair pay, unpaid overtime, sexual harassment, unsafe working conditions, etc. I am honestly not confident that new public policy will actually change those things, especially considering what enforcement would look like. If anything, it may make matters worse for the lives of the primary subjects.

I remember learning a couple of years ago about how the marketing of “save the sexually trafficked!” actually, for mostly all cases of undocumented immigrant sex workers, worked against them and led to deportation to living conditions that they were trying to be freed from in the first place. Instead, this “saving” benefited U.S. deployment of racist and heteropatriarchal imperialism (and conveniently fed into colonialist and savior discourses). I guess my main fear, despite the good intentions of the organization, is to be an agent in something that would cause more problems for workers in the long run.

2 comments:

  1. Hey Chelsea,
    I am writing to this a bit late because I completely forgot we were supposed to comment in addition to posting. But I really appreciate your post so better late than never.
    I also find myself oftentimes thinking about the ways in which laws function as a way to create more criminalized subjects and how oftentimes feels like I'm making a devils' bargain with public policy.
    Where is your organization advocating for this policy to be passed? Nation-wide? Locally? State level? The reason I ask is because, from what I remember, certain districts/cities have different policies regarding deportation. I think they're called sanctuary cities. I wonder if this will help decrease the amount of deportations that may occur because of this law.
    Also, have you tried asking somebody in your organization this question? I know it would be really awkward, but as we know, coalitions can be tough spaces with friction. Perhaps bringing up this concern at your organization will provide you with some clarification. And if after knowing this information your coalition does not critically engage, that might be helpful for you to.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Chelsea,

    Your concern about becoming an agent in something that renders the community you work with more vulnerable than ever, resonates with me deeply. I’m a little wary of calls for more regulation even if it is often framed as a way of benefiting communities, mostly because vulnerability is unequally distributed. So the question isn’t simply whether the new legislation will benefit domestic workers but which domestic workers will be able to benefit from it and what will be the cost of the increased scrutiny that this regulation will create. I was also wondering what new demands this legislation will create in terms of professionalization?

    Within this new legislation is there a provision that allows undocumented workers to report unfair pay, unpaid overtime, sexual harassment, unsafe working conditions without fear of being deported?


    ReplyDelete