Hi all!
A little late here. I have actually been completing a fellowship with the deport defense team at Dolores Street Community Services since last May, but have been able to increase my hours to work on a set of different tasks for the 698 course. Prior to this January, my tasks ranged from overall support for the attorneys, form filing, translation of documents, interpretation at asylum interviews, and country condition research to support asylum applications. While my tasks varied, they were mainly involved working with the cases of children who have been identified by the court as unaccompanied minors, or minors that entered the United States without their parents, and are therefore in placed in the primary dockets of the immigration court. As part of the added weekly hours, I have now gotten the chance to work on the asylum cases of adult women who are also on this docket, but whose cases are being reviewed by the immigration judge (IJ), rather than an asylum officer as was the case for the children.
While the process of filing and preparing for asylum is fairly similar, the experience of working women survivors of many violences is much different.
I have found it particularly difficult to ask women to share very intimate and traumatic experiences from their past, some of which they had not shared with other individuals or had not completely addressed at all.This retellings of violence is the beginning of a long process in which the client relives her trauma by in front of several different individuals (legal service provider, mental health evaluator, immigration judge or officer ..etc), a process in which her story is scrutinized and picked apart in order to determine her eligibility for asylum. I have learned that most of the cases involving women survivors of domestic and sexual violence are grouped under the category of “particular social group” which can range from “Married women in Guatemala who are unable to leave their relationship” to “Women/girls in El Salvador without adequate protection from male abusers” both of which have been accepted by the IJ in cases I’ve collaborated with this office. I was troubled with the way our clients experiences were reduced to a victim framework in order to be recognized by the court, I was to a point relieved to learn that the attorneys felt this way too, but they also noted that we were unfortunately working within an outdated and unfair system that wants just that.
Not too long ago, I was able to sit in a client’s individual court hearing for the first time. I had spend a significant amount of time drafting her declaration together with her, putting together relevant country condition research to support her claim, as well as reaching out to family member in her home country for letters of support, all of which were submitted to the court in advance. It was a great relief to witness her being granted asylum and seeing her emotional celebration with her children who were also granted. At that moment, I hoped that besides her new status, she could take with her the knowledge that she had overcome yet another obstacle in her life, highlighting not her victimhood but her strength.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe experience you are getting from your internship sounds very profound! That seems intense to be privileged to hear women's most intimate traumatic stories. It is a shame I agree that we force people to claim this victimhood status. It should really be about setting up qualifications for what is determined bad enough to receive asylum or those just in need of it and asking for it, rather than having to project the issues and problems onto the person. Like it shouldn't matter for them to be seen as a victim,if they are affected deeply by some crisis or fit the qualifications for what is determined as such. It can't be objectively determined how one might be negatively processing something that's happened to them, if the event or crisis is not deemed worthy enough for asylum. That's really great that you were able to see that woman's strength underneath her being reflected as a victim. It means you are likely to make people feel comfortable in sharing their stories and experiences with you and your group.
ReplyDeleteAndrea: This does seem like very intense work, as Lisa also comments. I'm glad you are able to speak to others in your office about the "victim framework" and that there is a shared awareness of its limitations. Might there be a way for you to have similar conversations about the multiple narrations required of the women seeking asylum, and anything your office could do to ameliorate the structural violence in some way, small or large?
ReplyDelete