My work as
an intern commenced early January. I had to prepare a budget PowerPoint
presentation for my supervisor on the very first day, a task that felt like
being thrown at the deep end and took me the entire day to accomplish. I went
back home thinking ‘I am not going back there.' My prior work experiences have
all been boots on the ground, being on the streets and mobilizing people. I had
chosen the Human Rights Commission for two main reasons: I wanted to
familiarize myself with policy work and law implementation and to get hands on
experience how laws are formulated and better understand where the gap occurs
when they do not translate into practice. Second, I have always worked with
NGOs and always been critical of the failures of the government and how it only
seeks to protect its interests. HRC’s mission is to protect and promote human
rights for all, and I wanted to experience this first hand, to see for myself
how the commission works with communities on issues of inequalities and
discrimination and how it recognizes and rises to its failures and limitations.
I spent the first two weeks familiarizing myself with the work done by the HRC,
attending staff meetings and community meetings which gave me a real sense of
who they work with and how they collaborate with communities. I am currently
working on a project called Housing and Search Policies for Transgender and
Nonconforming prisoners.
This has
been an ongoing project for the past two years. It is a coalition of various
NGOs that advocate Transgender rights. The NGOs involved have been working on
developing a housing policy that respects gender identity of all prisoners. They
urge the San Francisco Sheriff Department to revise policies that address the
important housing and programming needs for transgender and non-conforming
prisoners. There are however issues of miscommunication and different working
strategies amongst the NGOs and HRC was brought on board as a mediator.
One-half of the coalition seeks to pursue a more radical approach because trans
women of color continue to be highly criminalized and when incarcerated are
vulnerable to violence, so they want the Sheriff to take prompt action. The
other half is more interested in reviewing other related options, like revising
the already drafted policy and have a dialogue with Sheriff and the Chief Legal
Counsel. What is at stake here is that the more the coalition remains divided,
the lesser chances of this policy being passed and implemented. HRC has a task
of overseeing how this policy can be smoothly carried out with both sides
reaching a consensus. While working on this project, few questions came to my
mind: how can HRC be involved and not be biased (it is a government agency
after all); How can the HRC bypass be entangled in political
disputes/conflicts? I will be working on this project until the end of my
internship, meeting with these organizations and thinking through the limits
and dangers of coalition building. And further thinking of how they can work
together beyond their differences? What strategies can be employed to ensure
that the common goal is met? This experience reminds me of Reagan's
articulation that coalitions should not be a place of comfort.
Sam, I really appreciate the connection you make between Reagon's discussion of coalitions not being a space of comfort and the difficulties of finding a common ground and vision for change between organizations with different visions. There seems to be a gap between radical visions of change and softer "reformist" positions of the various NGOS working on the project you’re supporting . This reminded me of Molyneux’s categorization in Mobilization without Emancipation where "strategic interests" are deductively produced from a broader analysis of oppression and "practical interests” emerge from concrete conditions. It is so tempting to put the NGO’s you speak of in one box or another. Something about this split rings false, reformist position’s proximity to “concrete conditions” make radical critiques appear disconnected from reality somehow. I suppose this is what coalition work looks like, where one has to “ team up with somebody who could possibly kill you”. I wonder if this means that in coalition work no one is ever fully satisfied with the outcome. Or in Reagon’s words “you don’t get fed a lot in coalition. In a coalition you have to give...”
ReplyDeleteI'm interested in how this government agency relates to other branches of the government, as well as how it interfaces with nonprofit organizations that share similar missions. Your discussion of the split in the organization over the project you're working on provides a strong context for thinking about coalition as you and Monica reflect here. I look forward to learning more.
ReplyDelete