As some
one who is interested in feminist filmmaking I’m often hounded by the thought “what
must film do”?Among others, the films of Maya Deren, Julie Dash, Agnes
Varda, Chantal Akerman, Catherine
Breillat have in their own ways changed me. But the change has been inexplicable.
So even as I recognize the transformative potential of film I cringe a little
at the thought of films being used as a “tool for social change”. What is
social change? How does one measure it? How does one calculate the quality of
change? Are there certain kinds of films that are some how more amenable to
this project of change? The campaign I was to work on at ITVS wanted to “use
women’s stories to create social change”. As you can tell, I went into my first
day at work with a number of concerns about their vision. However given that
most media for development/change programs rely on educational programming I was
also curious to be part of a project that brought film and community work
together.
My first impression of ITVS was how well funded they seemed.
They had a large office downtown with almost 80 employees. Things were clearly
going well in the documentary funding business. My supervisor was quick to
welcome me and help me settle in. I was given a range of regional campaign
strategy documents to read while my supervisor and her boss went into a
conference call with their local partners in India, Jordan, Kenya, Bangladesh
and Peru. As I was looking through the documents I couldn’t help but think
about this transnational conference call happening in the other room. It was
9.30 am in San Francisco but what time was it in India, Jordan, Kenya,
Bangladesh and Peru? Late night? The language of the strategy documents
described their local partners as “stakeholders”, “collaborators”. In other
words they appeared to be equally invested in running the WGLG film screenings
in their regions. However, I couldn’t help but see this conference call as a
telling sign of the power dynamics in this partnership, where all their
regional partners had to make themselves available according to dictates of the
American work day.
After the call I was briefed about the social media strategy
of WGLG global. Over the course of the conversation it became clear that social
media numbers (followers, likes, re-tweets) are another indicator of social
change/impact not necessarily for the organization but for the funders. I
wonder what this requirement to have “measurable” impact even if its currency
is likes and double taps means for community work that is not visible in this
way? What about community work where “visibility” might come with the threat of
violence? What about community work that doesn’t have access to this new medium
of social media and the new language it requires.
My day ended with proofreading a discussion guide that is to
accompany a film that had been selected for community screening. I also edited
a blog entry that had been submitted to the WGLG team by one of the local
partners. While both the discussion guide and the blog included work by WGLG’s
regional collaborators, I left work that day thinking about the almost
invisible tyranny of “proper” English and professionalization.
Hi, Monica! You work with such a big organization! It sounds so interesting that there are a lot of people from different background working together.
ReplyDeleteI had a lot to think about reading your blog, especially visibility/invisibility and "proper" English because I often think about proper English language, too.
Hey Monica, it seems to me you enjoyed your first day at your internship. Hopefully you get a wide range of other tasks to do as well. It's great that you work with a large orginaization and that they work with people in other countries around the world.
ReplyDeleteKeep up the great work.
-Sheevena
Monica – your blog post reflects a thoughtful engagement with a lot of the subtle and overt power relations at play surrounding your organization. The conference call analysis particular resonated with me: when I was a graduate student, I was working on an international publishing project and remember lurching out of bed in the early hours of the morning to accept faxes coming in from Asia, etc ( I had been loaned a fax machine that, two decades ago, required the push of a button before faxes could come in… Technology in its infancy…). Around whose convenience international work gets done is a crucial question to ask!
ReplyDelete