On
Thursday, April 14, 2016, I attended a San Francisco Police Department
(SFPD)/Youth Community Relations Forum. It was held at Leadership High School.
The forum is a collaborative initiation by San Francisco Police Department, Mo’Magic,
San Francisco Police Commission, and the San Francisco Human Rights Commission.
This was the fourth forum of the ongoing youth and police community forums that
started in 2015. Since then, various stakeholders have been helping build
community relations between young people and San Francisco police officers. The
idea to host conversations between SF police officers and youth was born out of
a summer program called The Community Safety Initiative, a program of Mo’Magic.
Youth believed it would be great to have discussions with police officers about
community policing and the ways in which to better work together, and these
forums are often youth led. This forum is one of the projects the HRC
overlooks, and from these conversations, the HRC can make recommendations on
how to improve policies that affect the relationship between the community and
the SFPD.
In
attendance was mostly high school students of color who shared opinions about
their experiences within their communities and offered ideas on how police
officers can better interact with youth in multicultural neighborhoods of San
Francisco. The police officer
(surprisingly people of color also) who were present also expressed their
concerns and reminded us even though they are always viewed from a place of
“power”, they are part of the community. This forum reminded me so much of the
last one I attended in March in Oakland, though it was on a larger scale than
this forum, it was addressing the same concerns (my second blog). The same
concerns came up, and just like the Noble Forum, the theme in this one also was
how can communities build better relationships with the communities they serve.
We broke into groups of five and had
to brainstorm around the question of what are the barriers between police and
community relations?
People
spoke up and shared their thoughts, experiences, and grievances which ranged
from racial profiling, the hierarchical relationship between police officers
and the community, the disconnect – how police officers are not familiar with
communities they are policing. Lack of respect, communication, transparency,
accountability, communication, empathy, and time (police officers need to take
a chance to get to know their communities) were among the pressing issues that
came up. The concerns and ideas that were shared are to help the HRC in
implementing and recommending to the SF Police Commission how to improve the
strained relationship between the community and police officers.
My
questions about this Youth Forum are the same issues I was pondering on after
the Noble Forum. If these forums started last year, how does the HRC create
policies from the recommendations that come out from these forums? How does it
hold the SFPD accountable? How do both the SFPD and HRC measure whether these
forums have a positive impact?
How can we measure change when cases
of police brutality in SF are still ongoing (like the recent case of a homeless
man who was shot by the police)? If Chief Suhr is saying he is reworking the
department through different pieces of training and other mechanisms, why are
there still cases like the recent one? Throughout my blogs, I have been
wondering and raising similar questions and am mostly concerned with the
limitations of praxis and asking if policies are effective as they look on
paper. Next week is my final day at my internship site, and I still do not have
answers to half the questions I have been posting. I will, however, reflect on
them all on my final blog.
No comments:
Post a Comment