Friday, April 1, 2016

The revolution will not be funded


During the past two weeks at Women and Girls Lead Global, in addition to writing and editing blogs I've been conducting research to map the various monitoring and evaluation tools that are being used in what I've been calling the international development scene. WGLG is considering using an information communication technology solution to measure their impact but given that most of their work involves funding independent filmmakers and organizing community film screenings with local partners I was at a loss to understand exactly what would be "measured". I don't want to suggest that  films or stories don't have an impact on people. I'm just not sure if what I learned about structural racism and cultural hegemony from Morrison's The Bluest Eye can be measured by a mobile based survey tool. One could see WGLG's mission of supporting films and organizing community screenings and discussions as tied to strategies of consciousness raising. This need to find measurable results is clearly connected to how projects like this receive funding. My supervisor and I have had a few conversations about it and between the eye rolls and shrugs of helplessness it is clear that like me she is equally annoyed by the absurdity of the situation. For instance, she had shared last years annual report with me at some point in the day, later she came over to my desk to discuss something and asked me "what pretty thing" I was reading. I told her it was the report she had shared with me and she laughed and said, "I haven't seen it since I made it last year". She said, "it was for them."

 WGLG has to frame their work in a language their funders understand- littered with words like behavior change, knowledge and attitude. To the extent that it operates within the NPIC it cannot ask for support for films and community screening programs without justifying their utility. Further, given the marginal position that the arts occupy in our imaginations of movements for change we can agree that for a film based initiative like WGLG revolution might indeed be out of the question. While I'm tempted to propose that my supervisor is able to use what Bierria calls doublespeak to secure funds for a program that might be doing some good work I wonder if we can disconnect it from her own desire to keep her job. But as someone who will be out in the "real world" trying to make a living with a WGS MA degree I'm not sure I'm in a position to judge her. It's easy to critique the "self interested" new generation of activists who want a paycheck for their work and have forgotten what it takes to run a revolution, but perhaps there is still space for us to acknowledge small acts of betrayal or one-upmanship over funders. This is not to say that radical work isn’t being done across the world selflessly by people, black lives matter and the recent student movements against casteist and classist state and universities in India are just a few examples of it. But perhaps there is a need to see the division between small acts of resistance and revolution as a little more porous. 

1 comment:

  1. Hi Monica, I like this post and the way you describe your organizations ways of securing funding while "justifying utility". I think this is important because it brings up the concept of dual identities that some non profits have to perform in order to still remain relevant and fundable to donors, local governments, and private sources. It is a difficult task as I belive this has to the potential to obscure and limit the efforts of the organizations.

    ReplyDelete