Friday, April 1, 2016

Cultural Changes are not Systemic Changes


                I recently found out whether or not the anti-bullying trainings at my internship specifically address race, gender, sexuality, disability, class, etc. in the content of their trainings, and not to my surprise they don't. The lady I talked with said they address these aspects in a general manner throughout the trainings. She also mentioned they sometimes provide a training for students with learning disabilities when that is asked for. The main way that race and gender and these issues would end up being addressed it seems like is through federal law and that if it were an issue of bullying around race then their solution is to report it. While this is fine, obviously they could still address these issues in their trainings but then why I don't think they do is because they would have to get political. Their curriculum reminded me of the quote by Andrea Smith in the anti-violence reading when she goes "All too often, inclusivity has come to mean that we start with an organizing model developed with white, middle-class people in mind, and then simply add a multicultural element to it." This is a perfect depiction of how I think No Bully operates especially because it is a majority of white staff and located in the presidio.
                The lady gave me access to some binders of theirs with their programming in it for me to look through and get a better sense of how they train. On one page there were some bullet points that I found key to understanding the flaw of my internship site in their approach. I will list the first two which were the ones I found helpful.
·         "Bullying is generally a systemic problem."
·         "Systemic problems require systemic solutions i.e. a change of school culture."
This is the crucial piece of information that really connected the dots for me of where they are going wrong, that they do understand the issue as part of a larger systemic issue but fail to recognize what a real systemic change is. That they think a cultural change is a systemic change is the problem and undoubtedly hurting them in their work if they don't understand that cultural changes only clean up the mess and don't prevent the mess from happening. It also would be important for them to understand that policy changes don't automatically mean systemic changes either. For policy changes to work everyone has to be informed about the policy change and have the resources to put it into action. Then in another part of their program it reads "Systemic problems require systemic solutions. Hence the No Bully System ® which combines both indicated and universal actions." I thought it was kind of funny to me at least that because their trainings are a part of a system they think this is a systemic change. Again a system being implemented at the ground level from the people only and not from policy and institutions themselves will not create a systemic change. 

1 comment:

  1. You are really grappling with the limits of your organization's culture here. I appreciate your careful readings of what No Bully says they are doing, and what you actually see being implemented.

    ReplyDelete