Friday, April 1, 2016

Blog Entry 4: Lots of Thoughts

      Hey everyone, I have been thinking recently about Galería de la Raza’s positionality alongside other nonprofit organizations, and how issues of funding, activism vs. service-learning and community accountability manifest in very specific ways that I sometimes miss. Speaking on the discourse over activism vs. service-learning we read in the articles for last class, I have noticed that Galería has some difficulty trying to find the steps to making volunteering more engaging and less passive. Many of the volunteers come to Galería for school credit, which as we learned from the Bickford and Reynolds article, complicates the relationship between volunteers and activism. Volunteering for school credit isn’t inherently bad, I myself started at Galería for this same reason. In fact, I think it’s a good gateway for further involvement in the organization, and my conversations with student volunteers has shown that it opens the doors to interests some students don’t even know they have. The current volunteer program has our volunteers gallery sitting or helping with events, both of which don’t always allow much engagement with the organization beyond helping set up for events or welcoming people into the space. Yet the volunteer coordinator always makes sure to ask regular volunteers if they have a project they would be interested in working on while they volunteer. I think this is their way of trying to have volunteers become more familiar with Galería’s history and goals, and I think it is a step to becoming less service-learning oriented, even though Galería volunteering may always have that characteristic to it. 
      What makes me think that service-learning will continue to be part of Galería de la Raza is the fact that it is an arts organization. It is hard to quantify or see for yourself the activism that is taking place within the space because the majority of it takes the form of art, rather than direct action (which I think is what a lot of people connect with activism the most). It isn’t like other organizations that offer services to people, instead we offer a physical space where one can find thoughts and life experiences similar to your own. When I read the articles for class, I sometimes find it difficult to see the connections between an organization that deals with very severe issues like sexual violence and an arts organization like Galería. But then I remember that we speak to those issues as well through the art chosen in each exhibition. Like our current exhibition where we are displaying photographs that remind us of the violence against female bodies that is still rampant within the U.S and Mexico border. So then I ask myself this question: who are the activists within this space? The artists? The staff? Both? I continue to try and find an answer to that question, but at the same time I challenge myself to deconstruct the way I personally think of activism. 

      Alisa Bierria mentions CARA’s move to recentering women of color rather than just including them and the issues they faced with state funding after this shift in politics. I thought this was interesting because I am not entirely sure that Galería has this issue since their whole history is about recentering art canon with Chicanx/Latinx artists. When I asked one of the staff if the foundation grants we receive ever put stipulations on Galería, they answered that besides restricting the use of the grants to specific programs, the foundation grants they have don’t try to limit Galería from showing specific politics. And working with them so far, I have noticed this as well. Coming up with future exhibitions has never been a case of “are we allowed to do this?” but instead more of “how can we shape this maybe controversial topic to allow discussion and involvement from the community?” But also because they are a nonprofit receiving most of their funding from foundation grants, there is a dependence on them that our director wants to work on decreasing so we emphasize more on fundraising. I think it’s possible for us to consider the option of making community fundraising a larger part of our funding because Galería has existed in the Mission for 45 years, and we have that legacy in the Latinx art community that reaches beyond the Bay Area. But at the same time, there are goals Galería has that won’t be able to be funded completely through community fundraising and we will need grants. Since we are still on the planning part of a lot of these goals (some of which will ultimately decide how Galería moves forward, whether in the Mission or some place else), we have not really touched on how these contradictions will be addressed within the group. 

2 comments:

  1. I think what would be helpful for volunteerism would be for organizations to outline what they want from their volunteers as a way to better direct us as volunteers, but also make the use of volunteers for organizations more effective.
    For your question about activism, in a class of mine we have been talking about it in opposition to organizing and that activists don't really challenge power but use up their energy protesting their ideas whereas organizers make campaigns happen, have demands, and challenge power. So organizers are still activists but not all activists are organizers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You and Monica both grapple with the impact of arts organizations in relationship to social change, and community organizing. You might want to look at her previous entry for some shared thoughts on this issue.

    ReplyDelete