Over the past few weeks I got more deeply involved in the
work that Women and Girls Lead Global (WGLG) is doing. I edited and re-wrote a
number of blogs about the activities of their community engagement partners in
Bangladesh and Jordan. I finally had the opportunity of watching one of the
films they’ve been using in their community screenings, mostly because I was
proofreading the discussion guide for that film. Discussion guides are an
important part of the film-based curriculum for community engagement that WGLG
uses. They are developed in conversation with their local partners and I was
surprised at the vision of agency one of them proposes. The discussion guide in
question was for a documentary about girls’ education in Casablanca, where the
state has trained women to work as Morchidat (official Islamic
spiritual guides). Their mandate is to offer guidance around living an
“ethical” and compassionate life while supporting the state’s efforts to
encourage girl’s education and tackling domestic violence. The Morchidat
seem to draw their credibility not just from their official training but from
their gendered position, as motherly advisers, or as women who seem to have
some special access to spirituality and compassion by virtue of being women.
They seem to promote girl’s education, often in marginalized communities, while
working within the logic of gendered norms. For instance, they argue that
fathers should commit to educating their daughters because being caring by
nature (by virtue of being girls) they will continue to support their families
once they start working. The discussion guide recognizes this move as a
strategic decision and prompts the facilitator to ask the community audience in
Jordan about strategies they have used to convince their families about girl’s
education.
The film as well as the discussion
guide can be read as a reinforcement of problematic patriarchal norms. Where
girls should get educated because they will take care of their families,
because they are caring or nice etc. They can be critiqued for positioning the
Morchidat as empowered women “saving” girls while completely overlooking the
privileged class position they occupy. The discussion guide can be faulted for working
on an assumption that a film made in the context of Casablanca would
automatically be relevant to communities in Jordan because of a “religious” connection.
Even as I have many critiques about the film and the discussion guide I am
still interested in the complicated vision of women’s agency they offer, where
agential action is not always tied to explicit resistance, where it can mean a
negotiation with structures of power. In fact, agential action by women can emerge even in
the act of re-enforcing norms.
In the end, I am still trying to understand what it means for WGLG to support and screen a film that explicitly positions itself as tied to a "tolerant/compassionate" vision of Islam.Tolerant/compassionate in opposition to what? I wonder if WGLG would ever support a film critical of the impact of US foreign policy on women's lives across the world.
The concept of educating girls "within the logic of gendered norms" is very interesting to me. Is it doing more harm than good? I suppose not, because the girls are getting an education. It's a blessing in disguise, I guess?
ReplyDeleteIs there a space at the organization for you to ask these questions?
ReplyDelete