For the past week, I have
been feeling useless and getting bored with just going to my internship site
and only doing research. I am not saying the project I am working on is
irrelevant but it can be discouraging to be stationary and sit in one place and
do the same thing over and over again. It is rather isolating, too. I knew when
I accepted this internship that it would be a different experience altogether
because of the nature of the work that the HRC does, which is research and
policy analysis and not have much direct contact with the community. I wanted
to get a sense of how the state does reach the decision that a certain policy
should be implemented and who is involved in making sure that the policy is
correctly implemented, and whether it is what the community needs. However,
when I went in this week, I was so excited to know that we would be attending a
conference in Oakland.
My supervisor and I went
to Oakland to attend The Noble Forum on 21st Century Policing. It was a
dialogue, and had four different panelists: the Community Advocates panel which
included NGOs and Civil Right lawyers, the Chief of Police panel which included
chief officers from San Francisco, Oakland, Highway Patrol and Bart Police, the
Policy Oversite panel which included the Oakland Citizen’s Police Board, San
Jose Independent Police Auditor and the San Francisco Director of the Office of
Citizen Complaints, and finally the 21st Century Pillar panel which included
professors, police captains, and psychologists. There are three panels that
stood out for me which raised concerns and further complicated this fractured
relationship between law enforcement and the community. The Community Advocate
panel which was comprised of community leaders and advocacy groups expressed
their grievances, and exposed the disconnect between the community and law
enforcement and how it is affecting them on a daily basis. Second, the Chief of
Police panel was tackling the challenges they are facing applying the 21st
century recommendations in their respective counties through rigorous different
trainings of police officers. My question after they presented was how can we
safely say that police officers are applying this training when they go to
communities? How do we know these trainings are effective where people are
still protesting against law enforcement misconduct? And of course people will
continue to complain because policies that are meant to protect them are
failing them. Then lastly, the Policy Oversite panel discussed how to access community
rights and how they are of service to the communities. One of their missions,
mentioned by the panelists was that they investigate community complaints/
grievances and provide policy recommendations to the Police Commissioners. They
continued to stress that police officers who are violating laws and policies
should be held accountable. So the question is, if the group is not able to
hold the police officers accountable then how can communities hold them
accountable?
The goal of this forum
was to discuss ways of building community and law enforcement relationships
using the 21st-century policy recommendations set forth by the Department of
Justice. In the audience were community members, students, police officers,
other government agency representatives, faith-based organization
representatives, and professors. The Human Rights Commission had to attend
because as a government agency, we were there to critique, observe and see how
this strained relationship between these different counties communities and law
enforcement can be revived. Some of the outreach programs between San Francisco
Police Department (SFPD) and surrounding communities are initiated by HRC. So
we were at the forum also to evaluate what can be done better to improve these
programs. We were also there to see whether these counties were indeed
complying with the 21st-century recommendations, and more than anything else,
we were there to listen to communities’ grievances and how to better assist.
The main themes that I
took out of the forum was that police do not trust black and brown people, and
black and brown people do not trust the police. The question that kept coming
up was what kind of policies can be put in place to bridge this trust issue?
What system/policy can be put into action to acknowledge historical legacies of
segregation, oppression, and racial inequalities? There need to be policies
that actually deal with deep rooted systematic issues. On the other hand, communities do not necessarily want more
policies; they want accountability, they want transparency, they want their
voices to heard, to be treated with respect and dignity, and more than anything
else, to feel safe! Policies that are ambiguous, for example; police officer’s
ability to use force when they feel they are in imminent danger, allows them to
justify shooting somebody when they could have defused the situation in another
way. How scared can a police officer be that he can shoot an unarmed (possibly
with mental health issues) person 28 times? I was just left wondering why it is
so difficult for police departments to reform themselves despite trainings,
protests, and community engagement? Why is it so hard? Why is it so hard to
bridge this gap between community and law enforcement? This disconnect between
law enforcement and the community makes me think of the limitations of praxis,
and questioning whether we can take what we learn in the classroom and apply it
to our daily life. If the police are trained a certain way to respond to
mentally ill people, if they are trained when and how to use force, and are
trained to be conscious and be respectful and treat community members with
dignity, why is police brutality still so prevalent?
Hi Sam, The questions you posed are really complex. How can communities trust the police when there has been so much violence imposed on them by the police (those who are supposed to "protect" us) I really like when you mentioned how the police need policies that deal with deep rooted systematic issues but the communities that are policed the most do not want more "policies". As you said,they want their voices to be heard and to actually feel safe.
ReplyDeleteI wish I had some answers but I do not. When reading your questions, what I think of is the need for communities to protect each other. I think our society has been broken down by so many various factors that a sense of community is lacking everywhere. With breakdown in communities comes the over reliance on police and the ability for police presence to grow. I also think reliance on surveillance and police has directly led to breaking down community(ies) Our society has become so militarized. There is an over reliance on blame and punishment and fearing strangers, enemies, etc. This is the kind of dialogue that breaks down a sense of community and allows for the increase in surveillance which historically has always targeted people of color and low income communities. People are criminalized and then used as examples to increase surveillance and police presence. It is an awful cycle, but I think starting with reducing police forces in society and using money towards more uplifting parts of society is the only way we can move away from the situation we're currently in.
You ask important questions about praxis here, as well as about how historical relationships between communities of color in the state might be transformed.
ReplyDelete