I went to a campaign launch a couple of weeks ago, which lobbied for a bill demanding overtime pay for privately employed domestic workers. Honestly, it was a thrill for me to see this side of my organization’s work. Until this point, I didn’t realize what a small role our organization played in the progress of these workers’ rights, though it should have been expected; while our organization focuses on educating employers of what dignified, respectful and fair working conditions are, most of the lobbying and advocacy comes from the workers themselves. However small our nonprofit is, I still understand its role to be crucial. From what I’ve witnessed, the organization and its partners are effective in forming allies, encouraging endorsements, and educating those that directly impact workers through employment.
Still on the topic of the campaign, the gender representation makes me think a lot about Bojar’s article about women and volunteerism. I have yet to see a man at our organization, and I would say that less than 10% of the attendees at the campaign event were men. When I think about this gendering of work, it reminds me of Bojar’s argument about the undervaluing and perceived disposability of “women’s work.” WHY do these domestic workers have to work SO hard to get basic, fundamental labor rights? WHY are they especially excluded from labor protections? I understand Bojar’s article was written almost 20 years ago, but her assertion of women’s labor as undervalued and unworthy of visibility under white patriarchal capitalist hegemony still is very relevant today. Just as she implies, because of women’s history of “informal volunteering” and “volunteering on the job,” it’s as if this domestic work that primarily women of color have engaged in continues to be a social expectation unworthy of economic value (legible through their pay and rights, if that makes sense?). Which, to me, is fucked up because (again paralleling Bojar’s assertions) domestic work actually does directly affect the socioeconomic status of our country, contrary to the recognition it has been given (i.e. nannying for a business owner directly affects their availability of time to work and ability to balance, which directly affects their effectiveness as workers and agents in capitalism).
I don’t know, I suppose (like with all my studies in WGS) the more I learn, the more angry I become. Makes me feel less and less capable of making direct change. I’m sure others feel similarly about feeling smaller…and smaller...and smaller knowing more and more about power relations in our country. But I keep holding on to the hope that comes from active resistance, more voices being raised, and fighters refusing to submit and be complacent…just like our peers, educators, and fellow advocates. You all inspire me, but I do have these moments of insecurity and overwhelming discouragement.
Chelsea, thank you so much for posting this. I think many of us can empathize with the feelings you describe in your post. On the one hand, it sounds like you feel angry at the inequity and oppression you see around you. On the other hand, it sounds like you feel frustrated because you are unsure of how to address these issues. I honestly have no idea how to offer advice/tips on how to untangle the messiness and complexity of both of those thoughts/feelings, but I'll try my best. I think that the anger is totally warranted. Growing up in a messed up society is exhausting and oftentimes the urgency we approach activism with causes us to be frustrated at the current conditions we face--that's understandable. As far as thinking about what acts/forms of organizing are oppressive and yet resistant at the same time, I think this is a great point. Perhaps we can think about the ways in which we are all complicit all the time. That might cause us to feel disempowered and unable to effect any type of change, but for me it has also caused me to reflect on my actions and complicate them. This helps us to always strive for equality and it also helps us understand that organizing requires us to make decisions about who to serve/who to change/what to do to produce that change. Maybe we can therefore think about the decisions as the best we can do rather than the best. Therefore, maybe approaching your internship and telling yourself that this is the best you could do solely for this given moment might help release a lot of the tutorial sessions
ReplyDeleteChelsea -
ReplyDeletelike Chris, I have no easy answers for you.But I do know that action is better than an action, and knowledge is better than ignorance. The challenge is how we balance self-care, community organizing, political action, education, and harm reduction in our personal lives as well as in our politics. This is no easy task, but I think it's a worthwhile one to keep wrestling with. That's the best I have for you, except to add my appreciation for your engagement, and for "going towards" as opposed to ignoring or denying structural problems.