This past week at the TGI Justice Project forced me realize the intense tensions felt between trans black women advocating for gender equity and white people unable to critically examine their social location. The majority of the leaders in the core collective are trans black women. And because many of them experience violence from social structures based on their intersectional identities, "professional" activists oftentimes criticize them for their lack of formal education. Additionally, TGI Justice Project's critique on state violence disallows them from fully aligning themselves with organizations that rely on state violence. This leads to a distrust between various activist organizations. Although the form of distrust I mentioned above is insidious, last week I experienced a much more intense example.
As I was helping Janetta, the executive director of TGIJP, prepare some speaking points for a conference she will be attending, she expressed to me that a new article surfaced spreading rumors/gossip about TGI Justice Project. Specifically, Janetta was attacked in these articles.
The articles were regarding a past case with a white trans women who had recently been released from prison. Janetta had expressed to me that although she helped her as much as possible, the women in question reported to newspapers that the TGI Justice Project had not offered her any assistance. Janetta frustratingly told me that she did everything in her power to help her and that she felt betrayed. After trying to avoid the press, Janetta decided to make only one statement, "This is just an example of white people doing white people do." In effect, news articles reported that because TGIJP centers black trans women, it gives unfair advantage to them when offering services.
This experience painted a clear picture of how white people are still unable to center themselves in movements towards gender equity. The fact that someone felt TGIJP was prejudice/bias because they primarily serve trans black women is an example of how white supremacy oftentimes works within our movements, and attempts to co-opt them. Many organizations rely on a positive reputation to attract donors and grants. A news article such as the one that was posted caused many of our allies to e-mail us. They wanted to clarify the situation and produced unnecessary work. Janetta felt exhausted having to revisit this situation over and over again just to secure nobody lost trust with our organization.
As I continue in my internship, this experience helps me examine my own social location. It helps me see the privilege I have of being able to attend university, it helps me examine my male-bodied privilege, it helps me examine the ways in which I am complicit. It helps me see that it is important to teach people that when we center the people most effected by social structures, we solve the problems experienced by people who benefit from these systems. It helps me see the importance of intersectionality.
Yikes.
ReplyDeleteWhen you mentioned “a positive reputation” I thought of the scandal surrounding Yelp. Lately I’ve seen a few a few articles that have talked about the way Yelp perpetuates or assists in gentrification because white and otherwise privileged reviewers will sway a neighborhood toward having more gentrified businesses opened or defer business from a place for not performing to their standards (like saying the atmosphere of the shop is wrong, when really they mean they didn’t like people openly speaking Spanish). This same type of problem I still relevant to a non-profit, which draws the insidious nature of dominant power to focus. Also, it makes me think of the corporatization of non-profits, and how they are/ should be forces of good but still operate within a capitalistic society. Like, something one white person says shouldn’t discount the work of an entire organization but it does because they have the power in that conversation. Does anything I’m saying make sense?
Anyway, I'm glad that you are able to grow from this experience.
Yikes, indeed. And yes, this is another example of the personal and institutional costs of white supremacy on the micro and macro levels. I am so sorry to read of this, though not - alas - surprised.
ReplyDeleteI guess what one could say to that white person is if they and the black woman went to multiple organizations for service assistance, which one would likely get more care and attention? Yes in centering a particular group they are going to have more attention given to them that is the nature of equity, but the point should be that it white people are still the unacknowledged center of any given service organization.
ReplyDelete