Before I begin, I wanted to say I appreciate Laura's most recent post because it is a nice contrast to what I will talk about. Her post is entitled "Reflections on CCWP's commitment to those most affected by the PIC," and the part that particularly resonated with me is when she says "My frustrations in the beginning and feeling like I wasn't sure where I could help have now made me see that what makes CCWP so special is that they truly are grassroots and try to center those most affected by the PIC in everything they do. There is no centralization, no Executive Director, or no hierarchy. "
Especially considering the pieces by Bierra, Mananzala and Spade, they really speak about centering social justice work around those that are most affected by the issue to which the organizations are addressing. After reading these articles, and as I noted in my Response #2 paper, this really made me think about the effectiveness of Hand in Hand. Again, this organization is a domestic employers network, which means that they have taken on approaching the employer side of the domestic workers' rights movement. The organization, itself, I believe has great values and are very intentional in the ways they educate and inform employers of fair employment practices, such as providing workshops and free resources. However, referring back to Laura, I, too, was frustrated trying to find my place in the organization, as I am neither an employer nor an employee of domestic work. And I, too, believe Hand in Hand tries to be a grassroots organization.
But I want to think more about re-centering their work, "center those most affected" by the absence of fundamental domestic worker rights--and think more about whether or not Hand in Hand actually does this. It is true that Hand in Hand is run by employers, which would make sense for a domestic employers network. It is also true that employers, themselves, experience discrimination and oppression as most, for example, are seniors or differently-abled. However, I would argue that "those most affected" are the employees themselves. If they have workshops on "best employment practices," I'm curious as to why employers--not employees--run these workshops. I'm curious as to why there is not an equal ratio of employees at the monthly meetings as there are employers. I would think that employers would be better informed if there was input from workers, those who experience the most disenfranchisement in this issue.
My supervisor is very open, so I'm hoping to have a discussion with her to learn more about their intentions and reasons for operating the way they do. For example, I would want to know why Hand in Hand doesn't exist as a branch or team within a domestic workers coalition, but as a separate entity. How do they calculate the efficacy of their work by being run by employers? Things for me to think about.
Chelsea,
ReplyDeleteIt sounds like the workshops are run by employers for employers and the focus of the workshop is the fundamentals of domestic workers right. I wonder what they actually cover at the workshops, do they cover meal breaks, paid time off, sick days, health insurance, wage and etc.,? If that is the case, it makes sense for the employers to run the workshop to meet with local and state regulations. I agree with you on including employees, however, who should pay for them to attend the workshop, who should pay for them to prepare for the workshop? How should Hand in Hand recruit employees to attend the workshop? Employers, on the other hand, are business owners, they presumably earn much more than the employees and the workshops are investment for the employers. I may have misunderstood your concern but I am curious how bringing in employees will benefit the workshop when employers are not separate entities with their own regulations from the local and state regulations.
I think that “How do they calculate the efficacy of their work by being run by employers?” Is a very good question. Best of luck to you.
Hey Chelsea,
ReplyDeleteI think you hit the nail on the head when you said that "centering those most affected" would mean centering the stories and voices of employees rather than employers. I agree that employees are the most exploitable because of the way in which hierarchies operate. I also think it would be beneficial and valuable for employers to listen to employees in order to foster an open dialogue about the absence of domestic worker rights. This type of dialogue could happen in those workshops you were talking about. It will be interesting to see what your supervisor says about why Hand in Hand operates the way that it does.
- Sara