I did not go to my
internship site this week, I was (and still am) sick with a cold, and so I am
doing a lot of self-care, just resting and eating a lot. Our last class (April
1st) got me thinking about the conversation I had with my supervisor about the
NGOs that the HRC fund. As a government agency, HRC gets its funding from the
city and county of SF; that is through tax revenues. It was interesting to
learn how they prioritize to whom they give grants and how the Mayor allocates
funds for each government agency. As we read the Bierria piece, just like how
CARA had to apply for the RFP to be funded, the HRC follows the same protocol.
They publish the RFP and solicit applications from NGOs. They decide to whom to
award the grant based on the NGO that somehow fits into their scope of work and
will meet their demands and further report back to them the outcomes and how
the grant was used.
And so I am thinking,
this is a state initiative, what do they (HRC) want from the organization they
are currently funding and how do they measure impact? What do these NGO’s have
to compromise to receive this money from the HRC? Currently, the HRC has given
grants to five different NGOs who provide health services, education, and
sensitivity training, mostly to transgender people. I then realized that they may choose to fund
organizations such as social service providers as opposed to radical policy
advocate collectives/ NGOs. My supervisor’s mention of the Mayor’s priorities
when allocating funds and preparing the budget for government agencies reminded
me of one of our class discussions regarding how state funding is often
neoliberal-driven. He said, should there be budget cuts, funds for social
justice, i.e., LGBTI will be the first to be reduced, and the police force,
transit, and other sectors will take priority – neoliberal framework rather
contributes to entities that generate more income and “safety.”
One last thing that is still
lingering in my mind is the question of how we, as scholars and activists we
can critique the NPIC while working within it. It makes me question my
implications. I am for and about social justice, but the thought of making a
career out of doing the work that I love is not far-fetched… so as we are
finding ways of dismantling the NPIC culture, I suppose we should also look
within ourselves – how are we both perpetuating while against it.
Hi! I hope you get well soon. It seems like everyone is sick right now. Your post was really interesting because it so directly related to the readings in class. I don’t know that much about the funding of the organization I’m working with, so I wouldn’t be able to do the analysis that you have with yours. I’ve also though a lot about my future possibly working in the non-profit sector. I once worked at a for-profit years ago that had a social justicey mission, and they said that registering as a non-profit would’ve restricted their work more. At the time I tucked that knowledge away and never followed through with researching it, but now I wonder how much truth was to that. Or, at least, how much of a difference there is between the NPIC and for-profit companies with the intention of doing good.
ReplyDeleteHello, Thank you for your post. I really liked your post, very clear and to the point. I think its really cool that you got to find out in detail the situation with the funding. I learned from the CFO of my organization, but we did not have time to get into details. She just informed that we get funded from three places. Government, city, and private donations including big business. So I feel like my organization might fall into the NPIC. I have never thought about what could I possibly do to help the situation? I guess maybe its because I feel that its to big for me to tackle or that I didn't not focus on because I don't plan on going into the non profit for my career. But, who knows I may end up doing that and then I will really have to pay attention.
ReplyDelete