Friday, April 29, 2016

No way out of the NPIC


On my last day working at Women and Girls Lead Global (WGLG), I mailed myself everything I had written/researched/proofread during my time there. I had been maintaining weekly folders of my work and, as I was going through them one by one I realized I hadn’t been able to do the things that I had been most excited about. On my first day there my supervisor had expressed interest in having me watch films and develop discussion guides for them and I was really looking forward to working on them. Not only are discussion guides central to facilitated community conversations that are at the heart of WGLG’s core work, they would have allowed me to bring together feminist film critique and praxis. From whatever little I have seen, the guides already do a fairly good job at arriving at critical and thoughtful discussion questions that try to unravel the structural reasons behind the issues addressed in the film.  The discussion guides offer a flexible and open-ended map for facilitators to talk about the films. They are framed in a way that offers the facilitators multiple starting points for a conversation about the film while leaving room for them to weave in the specific local context in which the films are being screened. In other words, they are the backbone of a program with the potential to do consciousness-raising work while negotiating the trappings of international funding and behavior change jargon. Needless to say, I was excited about the opportunity to do this work. And yet as I went through my work folders I found just one unfinished document with discussion questions about two short films. Throughout the weeks every time I started work on the discussion guide something else, something more urgent came along. The fact that I was asked to watch the films I was supposed to write the guides for, always at the end of work days, says something about how important or unimportant this work seemed to be for my supervisor. To be fair though these films weren’t part of their core curriculum yet. They were short films in Bangla commissioned by WGLG. In any case, other things like writing blogs about WGLG’s activities, doing research about monitoring and evaluation tools, developing and translating surveys etc were prioritized because they were all about proving the usefulness of WGLG’s work. In her piece, Ford-Smith writes about how international funding diluted the focus of Sistrens work. I think all this while I imagined that only small grass roots organizations would suffer from the impact of these demands. But as I look back, the amount of time I spent working on various things that in their own way measure the efficacy of WGLG’s work, I realize that even in a well funded organization like Independent Television Service project based funding derails the core of their work. It seems like if you’re working in a non-profit there is no way out of these demands, regardless of the size of the organization, diversity of funding or mission. This then is what it feels like to work in the NPIC, there is no way out. But I hope that there are small ways to subvert this paradigm. I still feel dissatisfied with my own work at WGLG, I wish I had more time to work on the discussion guides, I wish I had spent less time doing monitoring and evaluation research. But I really hope that the fact that I was doing all the impact evaluation related work meant that my supervisor was able to do something more useful.

1 comment:

  1. I Monica, your post is really great and has me feeling so many different type of ways. Mainly, though, I feel empathy because I can relate to the ways in which one might feel entrapped in a system that devalues community work for the sake of "productiveness." However, I do wonder that if there are ways out of this when people begin thinking about how to structure their non-profit organization. In other words, what if the community discussions were a central part of your organization? Rather than just one more thing. That way, it would be prioritizing the work you feel is most important for the community and that addresses the issues you want to change most directly. Perhaps even if you do center that in the organization, it will require the completion of other services that are more legible as "productive." However, at least you have made a conscious effort to prioritize what you feel is the most important work. In other words, I think that there are ways to subvert the traps of the NPIC but it must occur on a structural level of the organization rather than solely on an interpersonal level.

    ReplyDelete