Wednesday, April 27, 2016

Pillars

I wanted to talk about something that I have seen in my internship that bothers me a little. Although, Girls inc. believes in teaching girls to be Smart, Strong, and Bold young women, i feel that there could be some contradictions. It very hard for me to see that these young girls that I work with get very aggressive with one another. Employees from Girls Inc. that work for them have mentioned that “it's crazy how aggressive they get.” The girls are between first grade and fifth grade, and the younger girls are just as aggressive as the older girls. They seem to feed of one another. It's just very frustrating to see this happen, they are so young and need the support of each other. Girls Inc. does not allow for violence and has a very strict policy.  If a girl hurts another girls (amongst other things) she gets an individualized plan to help correct the behavior. The girls has to sign a contract with the director and she has to be evaluated everyday by her teachers, and if she does good she gets taken off, if she keeps doing the same thing she loses her spot with Girls Inc. The organization's works very hard to promote a safe life for girls and to help them succeed in their academic as well as emotional lives.

As much as Girls Inc. believes in teaching girls to love and support each other, there is some contradictions that occurs. During their literacy hours they do homework, read, and play games. These games that they play are to help their literacy grow and expand. The problem that I have found is that when they split them into groups to compete with one another, it creates tension. Yes, I am aware that some of it is normal and that all kids have a competitive side. But, knowing that it's already an issue with the girls why would they do something to perpetuate the issue. This made me think of the four pillars in the Spade piece, when I was looking at the Pillar of service. This pillar is about “work that directly serves oppressed people and helps stabilize their lives and promotes their survival, including work that provides critical services.”  It got me thinking, using this pillar we could assess are these games that they play promoting a safe space and stabilization? Next, I thought well how could they play games without creating competition. I think the first thing would be to give everyone a treat for trying and. Next eliminating direct competitive games, and replace it with smaller groups so it not two big groups fighting to win, but if it smaller groups more girls win. Or we could go as far as removing all “winning” games and stick to turn taking and getting prizes for participation and helping out, rather than just for the right answer. Just some ideas.

4 comments:

  1. Hey Danielle,
    Your thoughts and insights were really useful for understanding how Girls Inc functions as an organization. While I was reading through this post, all I kept thinking about was how gendered this idea of aggressiveness is. You mentioned that one of the employees at Girls Inc said, "it's crazy how aggressive they get." While I don't promote violence of any sort, I can't help but to think how different our reactions would be if it were two boys being aggressive with one another. It seems like our perceptions of aggressiveness are tied to this binarist view that girls aren't biologically wired to be aggressive. The comment made by the employee demonstrates this point. In thinking about what you mentioned, I definitely agree that more spaces need to exist where young girls support one another. Maybe having open conversations about why these young girls feel the need to lash out at one another? I think that talking about some of these things could be useful. It is really important that the employees try to incorporate these girls into their conversations about how to fix this problem. I know that you mentioned that when a girl physically harms another girl, an individual plan is created to fix the problem. As the situation you outlined showed, this isn't an individual problem so my guess would be that it should probably be addressed collectively Again, engaging in a collective dialogue could be really useful for these girls.
    - Sara

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Yeah I was going to say the same thing as Sara that the comment the worker made about aggression was clearly tied to the assumption that girls aren't aggressive. I also wonder if the worker's assumptions creates any aggression towards the girls and potentially allows them to feed off of that.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Danielle,
    This is so disturbingly interesting. It’s really so sad to imagine first graders growing up with that competitive mentality. I had some questions, though, who signs the contract? The kids? I am imagining kids in first and fifth grades as not old enough to understand what a “contract” might be. Or it is explained to them? Or it’s the parents who sign the contracts? Have you raised what you have noticed to your supervisor? I like that you have given a thought on how to introduce new games and maybe the idea of totally not having a “winning” game might work. However, be careful not to come across as someone who is introducing new rules. Maybe you could suggest/ brainstorm along with your supervisor games that foster collaborations, i.e. have the girls to work together instead against each other, games that make team members depend on each other. Maybe you could have a conversation with your supervisor but not come across as an “expert” or someone who knows better, as someone with a college education.
    Best.

    ReplyDelete