Friday, March 18, 2016

Blog #3



For the past week, I have been feeling useless and getting bored with just going to my internship site and only doing research. I am not saying the project I am working on is irrelevant but it can be discouraging to be stationary and sit in one place and do the same thing over and over again. It is rather isolating, too. I knew when I accepted this internship that it would be a different experience altogether because of the nature of the work that the HRC does, which is research and policy analysis and not have much direct contact with the community. I wanted to get a sense of how the state does reach the decision that a certain policy should be implemented and who is involved in making sure that the policy is correctly implemented, and whether it is what the community needs. However, when I went in this week, I was so excited to know that we would be attending a conference in Oakland.
My supervisor and I went to Oakland to attend The Noble Forum on 21st Century Policing. It was a dialogue, and had four different panelists: the Community Advocates panel which included NGOs and Civil Right lawyers, the Chief of Police panel which included chief officers from San Francisco, Oakland, Highway Patrol and Bart Police, the Policy Oversite panel which included the Oakland Citizen’s Police Board, San Jose Independent Police Auditor and the San Francisco Director of the Office of Citizen Complaints, and finally the 21st Century Pillar panel which included professors, police captains, and psychologists. There are three panels that stood out for me which raised concerns and further complicated this fractured relationship between law enforcement and the community. The Community Advocate panel which was comprised of community leaders and advocacy groups expressed their grievances, and exposed the disconnect between the community and law enforcement and how it is affecting them on a daily basis. Second, the Chief of Police panel was tackling the challenges they are facing applying the 21st century recommendations in their respective counties through rigorous different trainings of police officers. My question after they presented was how can we safely say that police officers are applying this training when they go to communities? How do we know these trainings are effective where people are still protesting against law enforcement misconduct? And of course people will continue to complain because policies that are meant to protect them are failing them. Then lastly, the Policy Oversite panel discussed how to access community rights and how they are of service to the communities. One of their missions, mentioned by the panelists was that they investigate community complaints/ grievances and provide policy recommendations to the Police Commissioners. They continued to stress that police officers who are violating laws and policies should be held accountable. So the question is, if the group is not able to hold the police officers accountable then how can communities hold them accountable?

The goal of this forum was to discuss ways of building community and law enforcement relationships using the 21st-century policy recommendations set forth by the Department of Justice. In the audience were community members, students, police officers, other government agency representatives, faith-based organization representatives, and professors. The Human Rights Commission had to attend because as a government agency, we were there to critique, observe and see how this strained relationship between these different counties communities and law enforcement can be revived. Some of the outreach programs between San Francisco Police Department (SFPD) and surrounding communities are initiated by HRC. So we were at the forum also to evaluate what can be done better to improve these programs. We were also there to see whether these counties were indeed complying with the 21st-century recommendations, and more than anything else, we were there to listen to communities’ grievances and how to better assist.

The main themes that I took out of the forum was that police do not trust black and brown people, and black and brown people do not trust the police. The question that kept coming up was what kind of policies can be put in place to bridge this trust issue? What system/policy can be put into action to acknowledge historical legacies of segregation, oppression, and racial inequalities? There need to be policies that actually deal with deep rooted systematic issues. On the other hand, communities do not necessarily want more policies; they want accountability, they want transparency, they want their voices to heard, to be treated with respect and dignity, and more than anything else, to feel safe! Policies that are ambiguous, for example; police officer’s ability to use force when they feel they are in imminent danger, allows them to justify shooting somebody when they could have defused the situation in another way. How scared can a police officer be that he can shoot an unarmed (possibly with mental health issues) person 28 times? I was just left wondering why it is so difficult for police departments to reform themselves despite trainings, protests, and community engagement? Why is it so hard? Why is it so hard to bridge this gap between community and law enforcement? This disconnect between law enforcement and the community makes me think of the limitations of praxis, and questioning whether we can take what we learn in the classroom and apply it to our daily life. If the police are trained a certain way to respond to mentally ill people, if they are trained when and how to use force, and are trained to be conscious and be respectful and treat community members with dignity, why is police brutality still so prevalent? 
 

Blog 3


Hi! I had an encounter with my internship the other day that really made me think about the Resilience piece read for class. That reading was really was really upsetting for me because it shifted the blame of social problems towards the marginalized communities themselves. When, like, that’s not the case. The emphasis on the need for more resources was really important because that’s what is needed (not blame or a change in mentality).



Anyway, I’m interning at Hand in Hand, which is the Domestic Employers network. We’re working to pass SB1015, which is a bill that will make overtime a permanent right for domestic workers. Domestic workers are nannies, personal care attendants, housecleaners, and more. The organization I’m working with partners with domestic workers, who make up the majority of the people in this movement, but we specifically center on the employers of domestic workers who are in support of the bill. So, parents who support overtime for their childcare workers or people who want their gardener to have fair pay.



When I draw upon these images of employees and their employers, it is easy to view the employers as being privileged (in terms of wealth and class). Images of disabled people who are parents and rely on access to childcare or housecleaners typically aren’t the first people who come to mind. I’ve mostly been interacting with disabled people and their testimonials. Last week, I read a testimonial from a disabled woman who relied on childcare for 25 years. I’ve met her before and I didn’t even know she was old enough to have an adult child. It put my own seat of privilege and how that changes the way I view people into a little bit more perspective.



That’s just an observation. The interaction I had that has been troubling me is when I met with a woman earlier this week to record her testimonial for her. She has a bachelor’s degree (double major) from UC Berkeley, and much of her testimonial referenced her time as a student and the way attendant care allowed her independence and the ability to pursue higher education. One story she shared was of studying abroad, and while she was able to participate in the program because of her personal care attendant it was a very stressful situation. She had trouble socializing with other people in the program because they didn’t understand her disability. On the trip, she only had the support of one attendant, so it was very stressful and they often argued.



At the end of the story, I suggested that this would be a good time to plug her support of the bill and for rights of domestic workers because that situation probably would have been easier to navigate. At least with her attendant, if she hadn’t needed to rely on one person for round the clock care or if that person had been paid overtime it may have been less stressful. Then, the person I was interviewing said she wouldn’t be able to afford having a second attendant and she would not be able to afford overtime care. So, I was helping her organize her thoughts around and recording her testimonial in support of a bill that would limit her access to care. The person was adamant about her support of the cause and the bill and I didn’t want to question her, but it made me very uncomfortable. I felt like I was being complicit in the erasure of her needs?



I don’t know. I thought of the piece that centered on how Resilience was supposed to be the answer for social problems, but it’s not. I was interviewing this very resilient and accomplished woman, but this bill would make it much more difficult for her to access care. At home she can employ multiple attendants, in theory, without paying overtime but she told me she can’t currently afford that either. It feels like we’re finding the solution to one problem while completing ignoring another (and making it worse). There aren’t enough resources available. There isn’t funding available for people who need assistance and support to survive, yet we’re advocating for it to be more expensive. I feel like by supporting my internship and the cause of its organization, I am contributing to society becoming even more difficult to navigate for some people. Domestic workers do deserve overtime pay and fair pay, but employers who rely on support of domestic workers also deserve to have access to and afford assistance.

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Blog 3: Appreciative and Angry

I went to a campaign launch a couple of weeks ago, which lobbied for a bill demanding overtime pay for privately employed domestic workers. Honestly, it was a thrill for me to see this side of my organization’s work. Until this point, I didn’t realize what a small role our organization played in the progress of these workers’ rights, though it should have been expected; while our organization focuses on educating employers of what dignified, respectful and fair working conditions are, most of the lobbying and advocacy comes from the workers themselves. However small our nonprofit is, I still understand its role to be crucial. From what I’ve witnessed, the organization and its partners are effective in forming allies, encouraging endorsements, and educating those that directly impact workers through employment.

Still on the topic of the campaign, the gender representation makes me think a lot about Bojar’s article about women and volunteerism. I have yet to see a man at our organization, and I would say that less than 10% of the attendees at the campaign event were men. When I think about this gendering of work, it reminds me of Bojar’s argument about the undervaluing and perceived disposability of “women’s work.” WHY do these domestic workers have to work SO hard to get basic, fundamental labor rights? WHY are they especially excluded from labor protections? I understand Bojar’s article was written almost 20 years ago, but her assertion of women’s labor as undervalued and unworthy of visibility under white patriarchal capitalist hegemony still is very relevant today. Just as she implies, because of women’s history of “informal volunteering” and “volunteering on the job,” it’s as if this domestic work that primarily women of color have engaged in continues to be a social expectation unworthy of economic value (legible through their pay and rights, if that makes sense?). Which, to me, is fucked up because (again paralleling Bojar’s assertions) domestic work actually does directly affect the socioeconomic status of our country, contrary to the recognition it has been given (i.e. nannying for a business owner directly affects their availability of time to work and ability to balance, which directly affects their effectiveness as workers and agents in capitalism).

I don’t know, I suppose (like with all my studies in WGS) the more I learn, the more angry I become. Makes me feel less and less capable of making direct change. I’m sure others feel similarly about feeling smaller…and smaller...and smaller knowing more and more about power relations in our country. But I keep holding on to the hope that comes from active resistance, more voices being raised, and fighters refusing to submit and be complacent…just like our peers, educators, and fellow advocates. You all inspire me, but I do have these moments of insecurity and overwhelming discouragement.

Friday, March 11, 2016

Blog Entry 3

This week at my internship site was very busy, the organization has been preparing for their annual Power Walk event which is coming up in May, and all three of the full time staff have been stressed out trying to get everything together. So I'm helping with the outreaching for sponsors and possible in-kind donors that can contribute to the event. There is also a pop-up shop event coming up as well, and as more and more donations come in, myself and the volunteers sort through the clothing and separate what we can use in the boutique for clients, and what can be used for the pop-up shop. The more I gain experience at Dress for Success, the more I come to notice that this type of work is never really boring; there is always something to do. This week my work consisted of: sorting through donations and separating what could be used for the pop-up shop event, what could be put in the boutique and what could go to goodwill; we also received 10 boxes of clothing from the store Talbots and I had to sort through those donations, and tally each item of clothing. I also handled 2 more clients; one was able to find a complete interview outfit and she was very excited to show her husband. The other client was a little more difficult to find a full outfit for; the organization is quite low on bigger and plus size clothing, so blouses are limited and we weren't able to find a top for her. What I really like about my internship site is that they are very accommodating to the clients and always try to make them feel as comfortable as possible. We were able to negotiate that the client who couldn't find a top this time around, could come back for her second suiting and get 2 blouses when she returns. I enjoy my tasks every week, and although it can be quite hectic some days, it is very fulfilling and I'm happy that I am able to work first-hand with clients, volunteers and donors in this environment.

Working for a non-profit and reading our course readings for the semester, it has made me think more critically about the non-profit industrial complex and how its inner-workings are structured and used. In Dean Spade and Rickke Manazala's essay, The Nonprofit Industrial Complex and Trans Resistance, they focus on a point about the contrast of social justice work with survival services and organizing. They state, "Instead of survival services being a point of politicization, a locus from which people can connect their immediate needs to a community-wide issue of injustice or maldistribution, services are provided through a charity or social-work model that individualizes the issues to the particular client and too often includes an element of moralizing that casts clients as blameworthy for their need," (Manazala, Spade 5). This particular sentence made me think about the work I do with the clients at Dress for Success and how the services they provide does in fact put them in a position where they are individualized; they cannot come with their case manager, or any friends or family members when they get suited, and not that they are cast as blameworthy for their need for a professional outfit, but that they are portrayed in such way because there is such limited information on each person, they are cast more as a number than a person. Also, the hierarchies within the non-profit is to be considered. Spade and Manazala point out that, "organizations operate on typical hierarchal models of governance, with decision making coming from the top down, including board members and senior staff who are even more likely to be White, wealthy and have graduate-level educations," (Manazala, Spade 9). The more I learn about the non-profit industrial complex, the more I link this knowledge to my own experience as an intern and how my work and this organization impacts our society and its structure.

Racism Within the Movement

This past week at the TGI Justice Project forced me realize the intense tensions felt between trans black women advocating for gender equity and white people unable to critically examine their social location. The majority of the leaders in the core collective are trans black women. And because many of them experience violence from social structures based on their intersectional identities, "professional" activists oftentimes criticize them for their lack of formal education. Additionally, TGI Justice Project's critique on state violence disallows them from fully aligning themselves with organizations that rely on state violence. This leads to a distrust between various activist organizations. Although the form of distrust I mentioned above is insidious, last week I experienced a much more intense example.

As I was helping Janetta, the executive director of TGIJP, prepare some speaking points for a conference she will be attending, she expressed to me that a new article surfaced spreading rumors/gossip about TGI Justice Project. Specifically, Janetta was attacked in these articles. 

The articles were regarding a past case with a white trans women who had recently been released from prison. Janetta had expressed to me that although she helped her as much as possible, the women in question reported to newspapers that the TGI Justice Project had not offered her any assistance. Janetta frustratingly told me that she did everything in her power to help her and that she felt betrayed. After trying to avoid the press, Janetta decided to make only one statement, "This is just an example of white people doing white people do." In effect, news articles reported that because TGIJP centers black trans women, it gives unfair advantage to them when offering services.

This experience painted a clear picture of how white people are still unable to center themselves in movements towards gender equity. The fact that someone felt TGIJP was prejudice/bias because they primarily serve trans black women is an example of how white supremacy oftentimes works within our movements, and attempts to co-opt them. Many organizations rely on a positive reputation to attract donors and grants. A news article such as the one that was posted caused many of our allies to e-mail us. They wanted to clarify the situation and produced unnecessary work. Janetta felt exhausted having to revisit this situation over and over again just to secure nobody lost trust with our organization. 

As I continue in my internship, this experience helps me examine my own social location. It helps me see the privilege I have of being able to attend university, it helps me examine my male-bodied privilege, it helps me examine the ways in which I am complicit. It helps me see that it is important to teach people that when we center the people most effected by social structures, we solve the problems experienced by people who benefit from these systems. It helps me see the importance of intersectionality.