Friday, April 1, 2016

Blog Entry 4

I've been learning a lot each week I go back to my internship site, and it's interesting to see how they are funded and how reliant they are on volunteers and donors to keep the organization running consistently. Lately, I've been doing outreach research for Dress for Success; they're having their annual fashion Gala in June where they have an opportunity to get funding for the organization. I have to look for businesses and products that might be a good fit to contribute to packages that my supervisors are listing as a silent and a live auction. This week I outreached to Boudin Bakery, the San Francisco Opera House, Outside Lands, SF Segway Tours and other businesses. Basically I'm asking them to donate gift certificates, services, tickets, etc.. to these packages that people will pay for to help gain funding for Dress For Success. It's quite tiring I'll admit, I get turned down a lot, sometimes they don't answer and I have to leave a voicemail, and then call back. Most if not all places do require a 501(c)3 form filled out, other places have strict rules when it comes to donating to non-profits. So it's been a challenge for me, I'm also not used to speaking on the phone to people and asking them to donate their products or services for free. I have to explain what non-profit I'm working for and tell them about the annual upcoming Gala, and have to ask if they would like to contribute to the auction packages all before they can hang up on me or cut me off. So. Much. Fun. Dress for Success also has a power walk coming up in May, so I've been doing outreach for that too. I've been getting more positive responses for the power walk. I'm outreaching to Safeways and Whole Foods markets for in-kind donations of fruits and gift cards and I don't know if it's because they are used to donating more often than the local businesses I've been reaching out to, or whatever reason it may be, most times I've spoken to someone over the phone, they've been very patient and nice.

There is me and another intern that does the outreach for Dress for Success, so it's not just me doing the calling and getting rejected. It does make me question the other ways this organization gets its funding. A lot of work is put into these events and takes months to prepare for. Each week I come in, the executive director also comes in and has a meeting with Amy, my main supervisor, and the other two full-time employees Godavri and Shay. Looking back on this month's readings, Andrea Smith talks about how large donors professionalize the foundations they donate to and that causes a negative impact on the organization that prevents effective social change. Dress for Success does tend to align itself with the NPIC model in the sense that there are only a few people doing most of the work, but also does its part in grassroots organizing. The people that reach out to the women who qualify to come to Dress for Success know the communities quite well from where they are from and can help them with directions to get to places around the city or the jobs they are interviewing for. It is demanding and arduous to get funding for Dress for Success, they recently integrated from paper to online database to keep better track of constituents, individual and large donors. This way they can continue to ask for donations and funding towards the organization, which I think can be helpful. Dress for Success can't be funded by the people it represents, mainly because the organization aides them in finding jobs to make a living to support themselves and their families. The organization gives back more to the women, and that's a good thing. I think they follow a good model of traditional and alternative strategies to obtain funding for the organization, but I do think there's always room for progressive improvement.

Blog Four

My intern has been pretty mellow. The phrasebook project begun and I was asked to communicate with each groups to see how they are doing with the first part of the project. Most people respond quickly but some responded sometime later. It was interesting for me to see the translations which I understand nothing of. Overall each group works independently and meeting the dead line for the first part of the project.

In this blog, I share what a single task that I was asked to performed stirred critical analysis of the organization's training program and how it changed overtime. I was asked to speak with a Mongolian woman who is currently attending the training program. My super feels that she might drop out of the training and she wants me to encourage her to stay in the training. My super said, she tries hard to make sure she feels included in the group, she feels that due to her English limitation she might drop out. I think it is not just her English is the issue but the setting of the training program.  As I mentioned before I attended the training two times, Spring 2012 and Spring 2015. The two training differ dramatically, in 2012, majority of the trainees were middle age immigrant women of color whose first language was not English. In 2015, majority of the trainees were U.S. born young college students of color who spoke perfect English. In 2012, trainees were encouraged to share personal stories which I believe helped trainees to bond and engage quickly than later in 2015, trainees were discouraged to share personal stories which I believe created distance between the trainees and distances the trainees from the activism and those whom to be "served". Now in 2016, the training continues to choose U.S. born young college students and immigrant women of color continues to decrease.

Recently, a friend referred to me as an Asian American and I told her that I am not an American, I am an immigrant and Mongolian. For a long time, I struggled with identity, to position myself in one of the social status categories "Am I just Mongolian? but I've lived in the states half of my lifetime,  Asian American? but I am not an American, I am Mongolian, Asian immigrant? This one is close but it arises my Mongolian identity, immigrant? Indeed I am." Asian American women and immigrant women of color (particularly those who identifies with the global south) experience life differently, however, both squeezed into 'women of color' which tend to project their struggles as same. I have no intention to play oppression olympics, only to address although racially these two groups of women fit under one category. White supremacy treats them differently. 

I called the woman, my super was right. She does feel unfit in the training and feels it's her English that's on the way. I am afraid not, when US born young college students enter the training, without acknowledging their privileges over immigrant women- they tend to objectify their experiences, overly enthusiastic about learning about the struggles of others, often inpatient when non-English speaking trainee speaks, and speak too fast and perhaps too. My conversation with the woman went well, I did indeed encouraged her to stay in the training, also it's perhaps not her English; the training covers quite unconventional concepts and even the native speakers have hard time grasping the concepts. I told her she can call me if she is uncertain of some concepts or terminologies in the training, I could share with her my understanding. I made sure to let her know that I am no expert.  I think, she will stay in the training. She already volunteers in a different organization, Cambodian organization but she said, Mongolians come to see her. She is a humble person.

I am even more intrigued about the change in the recruitment in the training; I hope it's not like it's easier to work with native speakers, or they prefer college degree over wisdom and lived experience.

Apolitical Is Still Political


                This week at my internship I finally scheduled a time to sit down with the lady ahead of the anti-bullying trainings to get more info on what they are all about. I asked about what their political praxis was and she confirmed to me what I had heard by another staff member that they opt for an apolitical framework because they do not want to be controversial or lose their grant funding. Although she did say again as another staff had mentioned that they do want to be eventually influencing policy changes and that that is hopefully where they are headed. Then I asked her if they plan to get into policy how they will prevent projecting themselves politically. She took a moment to think about it and said that she thinks there is a way to be involved without having to identify with either side of the fence as she put it.
                Of course I disagreed in my head but didn't want to say anything because she had to leave to the airport soon and was making the time to talk to me, and because it didn't feel like that would be the time and place to confront these issues. I don't know maybe it would be and ideally that's what I should have done. However it's hard when I also have to get feedback from them and potentially recommendations from them in the future. It becomes a questioning of like I don't know how confrontational I would want to be in that moment. There probably is an easier way to go about it like turn it on them by challenging what they're saying, like how do you think it's possible to be apolitical and that not affect the political climate?
                 I think from their standpoint they understand being apolitical in the sense that from an outside standpoint your politics are not known. But that's the thing to radicals we see that for the political standpoint it is, liberal. And whether or not you prevent your politics from being known, by not participating in politics you are still taking part in a political act. I think of a place like Switzerland which is neutral, and how this is nice and all but they are still at the mercy of the external political climate, and how if everyone is building bombs and at war, and if a country were to blow the whole world up then they still suffer from being "apolitical." Or I think of white supremacy and the silence around racism from white people and how even though this is a sort of opting out, it is actually still a violent move to make. 

Cultural Changes are not Systemic Changes


                I recently found out whether or not the anti-bullying trainings at my internship specifically address race, gender, sexuality, disability, class, etc. in the content of their trainings, and not to my surprise they don't. The lady I talked with said they address these aspects in a general manner throughout the trainings. She also mentioned they sometimes provide a training for students with learning disabilities when that is asked for. The main way that race and gender and these issues would end up being addressed it seems like is through federal law and that if it were an issue of bullying around race then their solution is to report it. While this is fine, obviously they could still address these issues in their trainings but then why I don't think they do is because they would have to get political. Their curriculum reminded me of the quote by Andrea Smith in the anti-violence reading when she goes "All too often, inclusivity has come to mean that we start with an organizing model developed with white, middle-class people in mind, and then simply add a multicultural element to it." This is a perfect depiction of how I think No Bully operates especially because it is a majority of white staff and located in the presidio.
                The lady gave me access to some binders of theirs with their programming in it for me to look through and get a better sense of how they train. On one page there were some bullet points that I found key to understanding the flaw of my internship site in their approach. I will list the first two which were the ones I found helpful.
·         "Bullying is generally a systemic problem."
·         "Systemic problems require systemic solutions i.e. a change of school culture."
This is the crucial piece of information that really connected the dots for me of where they are going wrong, that they do understand the issue as part of a larger systemic issue but fail to recognize what a real systemic change is. That they think a cultural change is a systemic change is the problem and undoubtedly hurting them in their work if they don't understand that cultural changes only clean up the mess and don't prevent the mess from happening. It also would be important for them to understand that policy changes don't automatically mean systemic changes either. For policy changes to work everyone has to be informed about the policy change and have the resources to put it into action. Then in another part of their program it reads "Systemic problems require systemic solutions. Hence the No Bully System ® which combines both indicated and universal actions." I thought it was kind of funny to me at least that because their trainings are a part of a system they think this is a systemic change. Again a system being implemented at the ground level from the people only and not from policy and institutions themselves will not create a systemic change. 

4th Blog Entry


My experience at my internship has been very insightful and interesting. I've been learning a lot about the dynamics that unfold within non-profit organizations. I've been able to see first-hand how HOMEY functions as a 501(c)3 organization and have also able to see how my supervisor interacts with the youth that she mentors. When it comes to funding and how this impacts HOMEY, it has been interesting to see how almost every aspect is shaped by funding. Funding has an impact on the amount of youth accepted into the youth leadership program at HOMEY, has an impact on the types of transportation available to get the youth to and from, has an impact on the kinds of food provided for the youth, and has an impact on the allocation of funds given to those working within HOMEY. Funding also shapes the politics of this organization. My supervisor has mentioned several times that interested funders frequently ask HOMEY to simplify their vision to a more single-issue approach. Apparently, funders see multi-issue organizing as too complex to really make a difference in the lives of high-risk youth of color. They would rather HOMEY focus on one issue affecting the youth. This reminds me of the readings that we did this week. It is clear that HOMEY has had to significantly alter the language of their work in order to better appeal to funders. 

Seeing my supervisor interact with the youth at HOMEY has definitely been an important and eye-opening thing to be able to witness. It has been eye-opening because I've been able to see first-hand how this particular organization applies their vision through both theory and practice. HOMEY is said to transform the lives of high-risk youth of color through inspiring them to not only choose a path of education, non-violence, and self-sufficiency, but also through encouraging them to strive for emotional, mental, and physical health. I think that HOMEY does all of this and so much more. As I mentioned in my first blog post, my supervisor does a great job at implementing a radical ethic of self-care into the youth she mentors. I can tell that she sees the youth as her equal and can also tell that she really makes an effort to use a bell hooks approach to mentoring the youth. She sees herself as always having a duty to guide and teach the youth, but also sees herself as always learning important lessons from their experiences and stories. She centers the voices of the youth she mentors into a model that recognizes what can be gained from their experiences and stories. She sees mentoring and teaching the youth as something that expands their consciousness and constantly talks about the importance of the youth reclaiming their history and voice through processes of decolonization that call for a return home. This non-hierarchical approach that she takes with the youth is definitely something that continues to work to her advantage. I can tell that the youth truly enjoy being in her presence. As soon as they walk through the door of the organization, an immediate shift in energy takes place. When they walk through the door of HOMEY, it is almost as if they are suddenly able to let their guards down, and be children in a communal space where they know they are safe from the violence ravaging through their communities. The relationships formed between my supervisor and the youth remind me of the readings for this week. Particularly, "Pursuing a Radical Antiviolence Agenda Inside/Outside a Non-Profit Structure, by Alisa Bierria. In this, she says that the process of re-centering a radical social justice agenda means realizing that inclusivity isn't enough. Inclusivity often overshadows the importance of centering the stories and voices of those who are most oppressed, which is why those working within the antiviolence movement at the time saw the need to re-center these experiences. Although I think the overall landscape of HOMEY could be altered in ways that center the stories and voices of high-risk girls of color who are seen as having a lower likelihood of experiencing both street and police violence, I think that my supervisor does a great job at trying to address and present this issue to the men working within the organization. The hard part is getting them to check their male-privilege long enough to enact actual changes. 

Blog Entry 4: Lots of Thoughts

      Hey everyone, I have been thinking recently about Galería de la Raza’s positionality alongside other nonprofit organizations, and how issues of funding, activism vs. service-learning and community accountability manifest in very specific ways that I sometimes miss. Speaking on the discourse over activism vs. service-learning we read in the articles for last class, I have noticed that Galería has some difficulty trying to find the steps to making volunteering more engaging and less passive. Many of the volunteers come to Galería for school credit, which as we learned from the Bickford and Reynolds article, complicates the relationship between volunteers and activism. Volunteering for school credit isn’t inherently bad, I myself started at Galería for this same reason. In fact, I think it’s a good gateway for further involvement in the organization, and my conversations with student volunteers has shown that it opens the doors to interests some students don’t even know they have. The current volunteer program has our volunteers gallery sitting or helping with events, both of which don’t always allow much engagement with the organization beyond helping set up for events or welcoming people into the space. Yet the volunteer coordinator always makes sure to ask regular volunteers if they have a project they would be interested in working on while they volunteer. I think this is their way of trying to have volunteers become more familiar with Galería’s history and goals, and I think it is a step to becoming less service-learning oriented, even though Galería volunteering may always have that characteristic to it. 
      What makes me think that service-learning will continue to be part of Galería de la Raza is the fact that it is an arts organization. It is hard to quantify or see for yourself the activism that is taking place within the space because the majority of it takes the form of art, rather than direct action (which I think is what a lot of people connect with activism the most). It isn’t like other organizations that offer services to people, instead we offer a physical space where one can find thoughts and life experiences similar to your own. When I read the articles for class, I sometimes find it difficult to see the connections between an organization that deals with very severe issues like sexual violence and an arts organization like Galería. But then I remember that we speak to those issues as well through the art chosen in each exhibition. Like our current exhibition where we are displaying photographs that remind us of the violence against female bodies that is still rampant within the U.S and Mexico border. So then I ask myself this question: who are the activists within this space? The artists? The staff? Both? I continue to try and find an answer to that question, but at the same time I challenge myself to deconstruct the way I personally think of activism. 

      Alisa Bierria mentions CARA’s move to recentering women of color rather than just including them and the issues they faced with state funding after this shift in politics. I thought this was interesting because I am not entirely sure that Galería has this issue since their whole history is about recentering art canon with Chicanx/Latinx artists. When I asked one of the staff if the foundation grants we receive ever put stipulations on Galería, they answered that besides restricting the use of the grants to specific programs, the foundation grants they have don’t try to limit Galería from showing specific politics. And working with them so far, I have noticed this as well. Coming up with future exhibitions has never been a case of “are we allowed to do this?” but instead more of “how can we shape this maybe controversial topic to allow discussion and involvement from the community?” But also because they are a nonprofit receiving most of their funding from foundation grants, there is a dependence on them that our director wants to work on decreasing so we emphasize more on fundraising. I think it’s possible for us to consider the option of making community fundraising a larger part of our funding because Galería has existed in the Mission for 45 years, and we have that legacy in the Latinx art community that reaches beyond the Bay Area. But at the same time, there are goals Galería has that won’t be able to be funded completely through community fundraising and we will need grants. Since we are still on the planning part of a lot of these goals (some of which will ultimately decide how Galería moves forward, whether in the Mission or some place else), we have not really touched on how these contradictions will be addressed within the group. 

The revolution will not be funded


During the past two weeks at Women and Girls Lead Global, in addition to writing and editing blogs I've been conducting research to map the various monitoring and evaluation tools that are being used in what I've been calling the international development scene. WGLG is considering using an information communication technology solution to measure their impact but given that most of their work involves funding independent filmmakers and organizing community film screenings with local partners I was at a loss to understand exactly what would be "measured". I don't want to suggest that  films or stories don't have an impact on people. I'm just not sure if what I learned about structural racism and cultural hegemony from Morrison's The Bluest Eye can be measured by a mobile based survey tool. One could see WGLG's mission of supporting films and organizing community screenings and discussions as tied to strategies of consciousness raising. This need to find measurable results is clearly connected to how projects like this receive funding. My supervisor and I have had a few conversations about it and between the eye rolls and shrugs of helplessness it is clear that like me she is equally annoyed by the absurdity of the situation. For instance, she had shared last years annual report with me at some point in the day, later she came over to my desk to discuss something and asked me "what pretty thing" I was reading. I told her it was the report she had shared with me and she laughed and said, "I haven't seen it since I made it last year". She said, "it was for them."

 WGLG has to frame their work in a language their funders understand- littered with words like behavior change, knowledge and attitude. To the extent that it operates within the NPIC it cannot ask for support for films and community screening programs without justifying their utility. Further, given the marginal position that the arts occupy in our imaginations of movements for change we can agree that for a film based initiative like WGLG revolution might indeed be out of the question. While I'm tempted to propose that my supervisor is able to use what Bierria calls doublespeak to secure funds for a program that might be doing some good work I wonder if we can disconnect it from her own desire to keep her job. But as someone who will be out in the "real world" trying to make a living with a WGS MA degree I'm not sure I'm in a position to judge her. It's easy to critique the "self interested" new generation of activists who want a paycheck for their work and have forgotten what it takes to run a revolution, but perhaps there is still space for us to acknowledge small acts of betrayal or one-upmanship over funders. This is not to say that radical work isn’t being done across the world selflessly by people, black lives matter and the recent student movements against casteist and classist state and universities in India are just a few examples of it. But perhaps there is a need to see the division between small acts of resistance and revolution as a little more porous.