Hey everyone,
A few weeks ago I interviewed a few of the counselors to see what they thought should be included in the training I'm helping with and they gave me some really helpful incite and ideas. They both felt as though there should be an inclusion of personal experience in the presentation to help engage those who attend the training. I agree with them and do think it would be helpful to have someone with lived experience talk and so I expressed this with my supervisor. Although she said she liked the idea she kind of dismissed it this past week when we checked in about the training and our next goals. She told me that the training were doing is more of a general training and will be a lot shorter. We hadn't previously talked about the length of the training and I was disappointed and a little frustrated that we aren't listening to what the counselors are saying they need in a training around creating a safe space for LGBT callers and texters. We also created a survey for all the counselors of CSS to check in about what they know and what they want to know. As of now it feels as though my supervisor is wanting to create something short and is going to have others present it. A part of me is questioning what I'm even doing there if she's not wanting to go more in depth.
Not only that, but I don't like the idea of having my name attached to a training that isn't something I completely agree with. She listens to a lot I have to say, but I don't fully feel as though she's on the same page as me. It's kind of difficult to work with a cisgendered straight woman on a training surrounding LGBT safety, as a bisexual woman. I feel as though personal experience is vital in the training, as do other LGBT members of the CSS community, yet my supervisor won't include it. Apparently, there are organizations that come in at times to do similar trainings, but we have heard they are boring and not engaging.
Is it a financial issue to make it shorter/not include lived experience? (more likely)
Does my supervisor not agree with or trust my knowledge of the topic? (less likely/ me getting in my head about it)
Also, if it's going to be a shorter presentation and training, what do we include and what do we leave out? Bleh..
All of this is making me think of hierarchy in organizations and internships/community service learning. As well as privilege in these environments and interactions.
What type of training are you preparing for? Are you responsible for the whole thing or just a certain part of it? Personal experience was a good idea, I have to agree there. It is always good to have that voice of someone that's actually lived through what your teaching others. Why would your supervisor agree to something she never intended to follow up with? What in your opinion is your supervisor more concerned about in this situation? If the training is to improve their services why wouldn't you? Sounds like your supervisor just wants to keep everything at a comfortable level and not really go deep into issues at hand (stretch the surface). They don't want to stir the pot anymore than needed. Do you feel because she is cisgenered she is closed minded on certain things because she can't understand fully the needs of the LGBT community? I don't think it would be a finical hardship to hire a member of the LGBT community to be in such a position, it would properly benefit the organization even more. The person will actually know what is going on at the core of certain situations. I think she does listen to you, but because you don't have any "titles" yet to your name or position you are not really taken that seriously. Sorry too hear that though, everyone's voice should be valued.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry to hear you're having these difficulties with your supervisor. I agree that a training about creating safe spaces for LGBTQ callers shouldn't try and limit itself to include only some information. Your question of what do you include and leave out makes me think of the Mananzala and Spade article. I think a big part of their critique of the LGBTQ movement is the valuing of some information and activism (specifically on issues white gay and lesbian folks are impacted by) over others (issues affecting trans people and people of color). You've mentioned that you have spoken to your supervisor, but if they are not on the same page as you on this project (which to me seems like a very important project to be on the same page about) is there anyone else you can talk to? I hope it works out.
ReplyDeleteHey Samantha,
ReplyDeleteThank you for voicing the difficulties you are facing within your organization. It helps to highlight how problematic it can be when those in charge have completely different experiences from those they are seeking to support. I think you made the right choice in providing your input about the situation. I think that regardless of whether or not your supervisor responds to your input, it is important that you voice your thoughts and ideas because they are valid. Don't let her inability to see the value of your input make you feel like it isn't important. The issues that you're facing remind me of the Bierria reading. It is clear that a re-centering of the stories and voices of LGBT folks is needed in order to create the kind of training you stand behind. Being critical of this is important. Now all we gotta do is get your supervisor on board! I'll be sending positive energy your way!
- Sara
Samantha,
ReplyDeleteIt sucks that your super dismisses your contribution to the project, as well as the two people that you had interviewed. However, if the organization's approach is survivor-centered, sharing personal stories with callers need to be thoughtfully placed. Sometimes, the counselor's story could minimize the caller's struggle or could project that it's not just you- others people experience the same thing which could again minimize the caller's current struggle. Although sharing personal stories could be helpful, it's hard to implement it to the training...if the training program suggests it's helpful and okay to share personal space then perhaps trainees will often share their or someone else's stories with the caller...
Today in class, April 1st, you shared that it's been challenging to work with people who are/might be suicidal. It also sounded to me that you're carrying some of your work around and it's been affecting you (even a thought of suicide). I am glad you are aware of this and taking care of yourself, however, if it is too much I think it's best to take some time off. Secondary trauma is real, Bierra's piece sort of denied it but it is real and I myself had experienced it. I just wanted to let you know that.
Take care,
Hi Sam,
ReplyDeleteThe situation with your supervisor sounds frustrating. I am sorry you are having a hard time. I guess when we were discussing the coping strategies in class, and we mentioned communication, we forgot to address what can we do when communication fails? When even after several attempts the situation still does not change? I wish I could offer advice on how to go about this, but all I can suggest is do not take it personally, it is not about what you know or what you do not. She might be doing all that to remind herself that she has authority over you ( you know the politics of hierarchy). Just take a deep breath, and do what you need to do. Hang in there; it is almost over.
Take care.