Friday, March 18, 2016

Blog 3


Hi! I had an encounter with my internship the other day that really made me think about the Resilience piece read for class. That reading was really was really upsetting for me because it shifted the blame of social problems towards the marginalized communities themselves. When, like, that’s not the case. The emphasis on the need for more resources was really important because that’s what is needed (not blame or a change in mentality).



Anyway, I’m interning at Hand in Hand, which is the Domestic Employers network. We’re working to pass SB1015, which is a bill that will make overtime a permanent right for domestic workers. Domestic workers are nannies, personal care attendants, housecleaners, and more. The organization I’m working with partners with domestic workers, who make up the majority of the people in this movement, but we specifically center on the employers of domestic workers who are in support of the bill. So, parents who support overtime for their childcare workers or people who want their gardener to have fair pay.



When I draw upon these images of employees and their employers, it is easy to view the employers as being privileged (in terms of wealth and class). Images of disabled people who are parents and rely on access to childcare or housecleaners typically aren’t the first people who come to mind. I’ve mostly been interacting with disabled people and their testimonials. Last week, I read a testimonial from a disabled woman who relied on childcare for 25 years. I’ve met her before and I didn’t even know she was old enough to have an adult child. It put my own seat of privilege and how that changes the way I view people into a little bit more perspective.



That’s just an observation. The interaction I had that has been troubling me is when I met with a woman earlier this week to record her testimonial for her. She has a bachelor’s degree (double major) from UC Berkeley, and much of her testimonial referenced her time as a student and the way attendant care allowed her independence and the ability to pursue higher education. One story she shared was of studying abroad, and while she was able to participate in the program because of her personal care attendant it was a very stressful situation. She had trouble socializing with other people in the program because they didn’t understand her disability. On the trip, she only had the support of one attendant, so it was very stressful and they often argued.



At the end of the story, I suggested that this would be a good time to plug her support of the bill and for rights of domestic workers because that situation probably would have been easier to navigate. At least with her attendant, if she hadn’t needed to rely on one person for round the clock care or if that person had been paid overtime it may have been less stressful. Then, the person I was interviewing said she wouldn’t be able to afford having a second attendant and she would not be able to afford overtime care. So, I was helping her organize her thoughts around and recording her testimonial in support of a bill that would limit her access to care. The person was adamant about her support of the cause and the bill and I didn’t want to question her, but it made me very uncomfortable. I felt like I was being complicit in the erasure of her needs?



I don’t know. I thought of the piece that centered on how Resilience was supposed to be the answer for social problems, but it’s not. I was interviewing this very resilient and accomplished woman, but this bill would make it much more difficult for her to access care. At home she can employ multiple attendants, in theory, without paying overtime but she told me she can’t currently afford that either. It feels like we’re finding the solution to one problem while completing ignoring another (and making it worse). There aren’t enough resources available. There isn’t funding available for people who need assistance and support to survive, yet we’re advocating for it to be more expensive. I feel like by supporting my internship and the cause of its organization, I am contributing to society becoming even more difficult to navigate for some people. Domestic workers do deserve overtime pay and fair pay, but employers who rely on support of domestic workers also deserve to have access to and afford assistance.

3 comments:

  1. Have you been able to discuss these contradictions and difficulties with others at your internship? These are issues that I know members of H-in-H thinks about a lot!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Elizabeth- I think about these kinds of contradictions a lot as well. It also makes me uncomfortable just because to me it sometimes feels like we are valuing issues that impact some people over others that also have a huge negative impact on lives. Maybe this is something all activist work struggles with. But what that shows me is that the system in place now doesn't work. It's not just that personal care attendants are receiving less pay than they deserve, but it's also that the government has devalued the lives of disabled folks so much that they aren't receiving the aid they need to survive and pay a decent wage to their personal care attendants. I don't know if there's a perfect answer to this situation, but I think it's something that does need a lot of discussion. And like Professor Cohler mentioned, maybe reach out to others at your internship site and discuss these issues with them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Elizabeth! Your post was very interesting to me and I can definitely see how frustration plays a part of your position. On the one hand, overtime pay for domestic workers is very understandable and should be put into law. On the other, the people who rely on domestic work may not always be in the position to afford that extra pay, like you explained. I feel like you are making a difference, even if it does come at a cost, and that is a part of life. Hopefully there can be some sort of exception to those who rely on domestic workers but can't afford the overtime pay. Or maybe it can be handled situationally, but that can also turn messy. The lack of resources is very problematic, and that will take even more work to get the extra support, but taking things one day at a time is how bigger things get accomplished. Thanks for sharing! It's a great discussion topic!

    ReplyDelete