Friday, March 18, 2016

Space matters

March 18 2016

This week I have been able to get some more insight on the dynamics of the organization I am interning in. The organization houses 6 different programs that range from the direct legal services that my program does, to education and advocacy for tenants rights in the mission. The building is two stories, relatively small, and with nine separate offices that are shared between two to four people. The offices are split between two floors, the downstairs offices are occupied by the shelter managers, la colectiva de mujeres, mission SRO collaborative, and the day laborer program, while the upstairs offices belong to the director of the organization, the accountant, and both legal programs. When I first started, someone in my program had made a joke about how the tenants rights staff never invited our program out because they referred to us as “upstairs people” I realized that I had also previously heard some on the staff call us “lawyer” people in casual conversation which I did not think twice of at all. On moving day, two of the “downstairs” programs moved offices with the accountant, and while doing so they jokingly said, “look we are upstairs people now”. Seemingly benign comments are signs of an otherwise unspoken hierarchy that can be manifested in space. While the space that legal programs occupy is not much larger than those of the offices downstairs, there is overall understanding that being above is good or “better”. The politics of space can encompass simple things as arrangement of offices, and who gets to occupy them is then understood in terms of their value to the organization or their credentials. I had not given such ideas much thought until I began thinking about the different types of services that are provided by this non profit. The programs downstairs are primarily mobilizers, they are organizers, activists, and mostly members of the same communities they target. They hold weekly educational workshops as well as coalition meetings in the shared “vvc” space downstairs. While attorneys from the deportation defense program are very much active advocates of the communities they serve, they are primarily concerned with the individuals they are able to represent.


From the interactions I have had with other members of my program as well as other staff, I have started to understand how the activities of each program shape such program’s overall “place” in the organization. While the activists work is very much necessary and valuable, it is viewed as a more radical form of service than that of the attorneys. It is also important to note the distinction between the individuals that are part of the activist work in contrast to the legal service team. While this may not be the case for all attorneys, the attorneys of my program all come from a middle class, upper middle class background; they are either white or second and third generation children of immigrants while their target community is very low income, undocumented folks. All of the “downstairs” programs are staffed by previously homeless individuals and members of the same communities they organize. Bickford and Reynolds make a similar distinction between service learning and activist work, “It is fruitful at this point to consider the connections between activism and service-learning based on relationships. In most situations, relationships are clearly based on difference: I’m homeless; you’re not. Activism argues for relationships based on connection.” (237) I believe it is important to acknowledge these differences and the racial and class implications involved. Rather than understanding the programs as opposites and completely separate from the other, I think that they should be understood as complementary. While the attorneys hold a position that allows them to produce some change, it is limited by the underlying system that creates the “illegal” and deportable subject in the first place. Mobilizing and pressure from activist is what forces legislators to reevaluate their policies, allowing for the gradual change of the system, not just of the individual applicant. 

1 comment:

  1. What an insightful post, about space, power, and hierarchy. I wonder if the move you discussed in your earlier post will shake things up at all? Or if these observations that you shared with us, might be shared with others to try to cross some of those upstairs/downstairs divisions from time to time?

    ReplyDelete